The first Indian American Senator

[Faun]

Who gives a shit?

I dont hate it but its not cause for a celebration either

So? You don't have to celebrate it. Others can, if they want.

 

[progressive hunter]

Nope. The Constitution says if you're born here, you're a citizen. Period. Your illiteracy doesn't change that.

again youre only reading part of what it says,,

 

[Faun]

you are subject to their laws,,

your home country has jurisdiction ,,

Moron, your home country has no jurisdiction in other countries. They's why leaders of countries negotiate trading prisoner swaps, like Biden did the other day.

 

[progressive hunter]

Moron, your home country has no jurisdiction in other countries. They's why leaders of countries negotiate trading prisoner swaps, like Biden did the other day.

they have jurisdiction over you and why when someone takes you hostage america comes to your aid,,

and that other country also cant force you into their military or tax your income made in america,, along with other things,,
just like we cant do with visitors from other countries,,

 

[Faun]

again youre only reading part of what it says,,

Liar. I posted the entire relevant part...

All persons born or naturalized in the United States, and subject to the jurisdiction thereof, are citizens of the United States and of the state wherein they reside.​

Savvy?

Born here and you're a U.S. citizen. The exception are those who are here but nut subject to our juristdictions, such as diplomats.

 

[Faun]

they have jurisdiction over you and why when someone takes you hostage america comes to your aid,,

and that other country also cant force you into their military or tax your income made in america,, along with other things,,
just like we cant do with visitors from other countries,,

LOL

You're a ******* retard.

The U.S. has no jurisdiction in other countries.

 

[progressive hunter]

Liar. I posted the entire relevant part...

All persons born or naturalized in the United States, and subject to the jurisdiction thereof, are citizens of the United States and of the state wherein they reside.​

Savvy?

Born here and you're a U.S. citizen. The exception are those who are here but nut subject to our juristdictions, such as diplomats.

thanks for proving my point,,

visitors from other countries are not under our jurisdiction,, they are subject to our laws bit still under the jurisdiction of their home country,,

 

[progressive hunter]

LOL

You're a ******* retard.

The U.S. has no jurisdiction in other countries.

they have jurisdiction over american citizens regardless of where they are at,,

thats why americans living abroad are still taxed by america

 

[Mac-7]

So? You don't have to celebrate it. Others can, if they want.

What libs want is a pat on the back

But for what is not clear

 

[Faun]

thanks for proving my point,,

visitors from other countries are not under our jurisdiction,, they are subject to our laws bit still under the jurisdiction of their home country,,

LOL

Subject to our laws is subject to our juristdictions, you flaming imbecile.

 

[progressive hunter]

LOL

Subject to our laws is subject to our juristdictions, you flaming imbecile.

nope,, two different things,,

I have given several examples why you are wrong and youve given nothing,,

 

[Faun]

nope,, two different things,,

I have given several examples why you are wrong and youve given nothing,,

Nope...

United States v. Wong Kim Ark

Generally speaking, non-citizens must follow American laws when on American soil, so they are “subject to the jurisdiction thereof” within the language of the Citizenship Clause.​

 

[progressive hunter]

Nope...

United States v. Wong Kim Ark​

​

Generally speaking, non-citizens must follow American laws when on American soil, so they are “subject to the jurisdiction thereof” within the language of the Citizenship Clause.​

so we can tax their income they make back home and force them into military service,,,

that only applies to laws not full jurisdiction,,
it says so right there in your comment

 

[Faun]

so we can tax their income they make back home and force them into military service,,,

that only applies to laws not full jurisdiction,,
it says so right there in your comment

It says foreigners generally have to follow our laws which makes subject to our jurisdictions. The exception is diplomats.

jurisdiction

Jurisdiction can be defined as:

Power of a court to adjudicate cases and issue orders; or

Territory within which a court or government agency may properly exercise its power.​

 

[progressive hunter]

It says foreigners generally have to follow our laws which makes subject to our jurisdictions. The exception is diplomats.

jurisdiction​

​

Jurisdiction can be defined as:​

​

Power of a court to adjudicate cases and issue orders; or​

​

Territory within which a court or government agency may properly exercise its power.​

so foreigners can vote in our elections and be taxed on their income from their home country??

and why do you always edit your definitions instead of posting the whole things??

 

[Faun]

so foreigners can vote in our elections and be taxed on their income from their home country??

and why do you always edit your definitions instead of posting the whole things??

Not sure why you're so fixated on taxes. Only one or two other countries even tax their citizens who come here to work. And it's meaningless anyway. Except for diplomats, foreigners who come here are subject to our jurisdictions.

And foreigners can only vote in a few cities in local elections if they're a legal resident. Also a meaningless point to this.

And the definition I posted has 2 examples and I posted both of them. Plus I gave you a link to it so you could read beyond the definition, if you want to. Stop crying like a 4 year old.

 

[EvilEyeFleegle]

They are tremendously confused. They don't know a person can have two different separate ethnicities.

Apparently the concept of Native American vs Indian-American also escapes them.

But so much does, after all~

 

[surada]

GASP!

I like people from India. I lived with an Indian doctor and his wife in 1952 and part of 1953... And my doctor was from India. It's a small world these days what with jet airliners. Why are we so provincial? Kamala Harris may turn out to be a very good president.

 

[progressive hunter]

Not sure why you're so fixated on taxes. Only one or two other countries even tax their citizens who come here to work. And it's meaningless anyway. Except for diplomats, foreigners who come here are subject to our jurisdictions.

And foreigners can only vote in a few cities in local elections if they're a legal resident. Also a meaningless point to this.

And the definition I posted has 2 examples and I posted both of them. Plus I gave you a link to it so you could read beyond the definition, if you want to. Stop crying like a 4 year old.

taxes and voting are an indication who controls full jurisdiction,,

anyone in the country is under legal jurisdiction of our laws but not jurisdiction of citizenship..

thats one of the reasons other countries have embassies here so their people if need be can go to them for help and protection,,

 

[surada]

The irony being she has all the same if not more economic, social and political privilege than any white suburban female.

You mean because of her education? She does have a fine education and a law degree, but there are many well educated, suburban white women. I don't understand your remarks.