The DOGE effect. Social Security payments just saw the largest single monthly drop in history

1srelluc

Diamond Member
Joined
Nov 21, 2021
Messages
73,517
Reaction score
108,713
Points
3,488
Location
Shenandoah Valley of Virginia


Guc4vgfWMAACLXW


They must have just stopped paying illegals and dead people. ;)

That and I heard they were really tighting down on earning limits too. If you earn too much they will give you a choice of a 10% reduction each month or rake it all back at one time.
 
We will soon find out that most of it is mistaken and they will have to pay all those folks anyway.

But it does make for a good if momentary headline for tRump right when he needs it.

Which describes most of the "positive" news he gets.
 
We will soon find out that most of it is mistaken and they will have to pay all those folks anyway.

But it does make for a good if momentary headline for tRump right when he needs it.

Which describes most of the "positive" news he gets.
Filings for SS are way down too from what I understand.

What that tells me is that there were a shit-ton of bogus filings.

Why do you like SS abuse?

LOL....Small wonder most of the SS protests are from well-heeled boomers earning too much while on SS that they will now have to pay back..
 
Filings for SS are way down too from what I understand.

What that tells me is that there were a shit-ton of bogus filings.

Why do you like SS abuse?

LOL....Small wonder most of the SS protests are from well-heeled boomers earning too much while on SS that they will now have to pay back..
Not that I'll ever have to worry about earning too much, LOL, but I sorta disagree with denying benefits to people who've paid into the program simply because they are still healthy enough at retirement age to earn some money.
 
Not that I'll ever have to worry about earning too much, LOL, but I sorta disagree with denying benefits to people who've paid into the program simply because they are still healthy enough at retirement age to earn some money.
They get every penny that they are intitled to....If they earn too much they are not entitled to as much....Pretty simple stuff.

Sort of like when the wife retired (full SS benefit)...A couple of weeks later they wanted her back in a contractor role for more money.....She did the math on the SS effect and told them no.
 
They get every penny that they are intitled to....If they earn too much they are not entitled to as much....Pretty simple stuff.

Sort of like when the wife retired (full SS benefit)...A couple of weeks later they wanted her back in a contractor role for more money.....She did the math on the SS effect and told them no.
I've heard of this type of thing and it was a consideration when I was asked back as a consultant. I chose the same way as your wife. Another thing to consider though is why does that five year hole make a difference when at 70 you can earn however much you want?
 
Not that I'll ever have to worry about earning too much, LOL, but I sorta disagree with denying benefits to people who've paid into the program simply because they are still healthy enough at retirement age to earn some money.
Say what? Denying what benefits? I've drawing for years, I could go back to work tomorrow if I wanted. I'm not denied any benefits. :dunno:
 
Say what? Denying what benefits? I've drawing for years, I could go back to work tomorrow if I wanted. I'm not denied any benefits. :dunno:
There is a period between 65 and 70 when a recipient's SS benefit is reduced if they earn too much money. After 70 they can earn whatever they want with no penalty. I think a person should be able to earn whatever in retirement without penalty---they paid their contribution throughout their working lives, why should they be penalized because they are healthy enough to earn in retirement--BTW, those workers who continue to earn, also continue to pay into SS--isn't that enough of a penalty?
 
It's between 62 and your full retirement age. Knew a nurse got in the jackpot making more than her 62 monthly benefit.
 
Pissing in the wind. Trump submitted a budget that increase the deficit $3,000,000,000,000.
 
It's between 62 and your full retirement age. Knew a nurse got in the jackpot making more than her 62 monthly benefit.
I just figured it from normal retirement age, 62 is going early so I didn't include it--I'm pretty sure it continues until age 70 though, do you have a link that would answer it? The penalty for retiring early at 62 is quite severe IMHO as well--I believe it is .5% per month that you go early. So if you go on your 62nd birthday, you lose 18% of your benefit for the rest of your life. There's a formula that tells how long you would have to live to make up the difference, but I can't remember what it is.
 
Last edited:
There is a period between 65 and 70 when a recipient's SS benefit is reduced if they earn too much money. After 70 they can earn whatever they want with no penalty. I think a person should be able to earn whatever in retirement without penalty---they paid their contribution throughout their working lives, why should they be penalized because they are healthy enough to earn in retirement--BTW, those workers who continue to earn, also continue to pay into SS--isn't that enough of a penalty?
Not really denied but delayed until the recipient turns 70. I'm not positive about that but I think that's right.
 
Not really denied but delayed until the recipient turns 70. I'm not positive about that but I think that's right.
During the five year period, I believe they deduct $1 of benefits for every $1 you earn. That money never comes back. Seems like it is effectively an incentive for you to leave the workforce.
 
15th post
During the five year period, I believe they deduct $1 of benefits for every $1 you earn. That money never comes back. Seems like it is effectively an incentive for you to leave the workforce.
"You can get Social Security retirement
or survivors benefits and work at the
same time. But, if you’re younger than
full retirement age, and earn more
than certain amounts, your benefits
will be reduced. The amount that
your benefits are reduced, however,
isn’t lost.
Your benefit will increase at
your full retirement age to account for
benefits withheld due to earlier earnings.

"
 
"You can get Social Security retirement
or survivors benefits and work at the
same time. But, if you’re younger than
full retirement age, and earn more
than certain amounts, your benefits
will be reduced. The amount that
your benefits are reduced, however,
isn’t lost.
Your benefit will increase at
your full retirement age to account for
benefits withheld due to earlier earnings.

"
Can you provide the link? I would like to read it and see the source as it conflicts with what I've been told at my local SS office.
 
Can you provide the link? I would like to read it and see the source as it conflicts with what I've been told at my local SS office.

Scroll about halfway down on how they recalculate your benefits when you reach full retirement age.
 
Back
Top Bottom