The case against the case against Alberta independence

[Doc7505]

The case against the case against Alberta independence​

The arrogance of Canada's sneering Eastern establishment is inadvertently paving the way for a sovereign Alberta.​

The case against the case against Alberta independence

The arrogance of Canada's sneering Eastern establishment is inadvertently paving the way for a sovereign Alberta.

www.rebelnews.com

3 Feb 2026 ~~ By Ezra Levant

While the media fawns over Mark Carney’s "central banker" aesthetic and his promises to "whisper" to Donald Trump, Albertans see a different reality: a return to the same globalist policies that have long suppressed Western interests.
This growing divide was perfectly captured in a recent viral video from an Eastern "educator" who crudely attempted to lecture Albertans on why independence is a "stupid" idea. It was a masterclass in the very condescension that fuels separatism. Mocking Premier Danielle Smith and calling Albertans "potato men," the wannabe critic relied on a series of debunked scare tactics that fall apart under the slightest scrutiny.

​

The argument that Alberta would face economic devastation if it left Confederation is historically backwards. Alberta is the nation’s largest net contributor, sending tens of billions of dollars to Ottawa every year to subsidize other provinces.
In a sovereign Alberta, that wealth stays home. While critics claim corporations would flee, the oil and gas aren't moving; industry leaders will stay where the resources are, and if anything, it is the Canadian dollar that would collapse the day after a "Yes" vote, not the Alberta economy.
This economic leverage extends to the "landlocked" argument, which is equally hollow. Under the current federal framework, Alberta is already effectively landlocked by political vetoes. International law provides frameworks for landlocked nations to access tidewater, rights Alberta currently lacks within Canada, and a sovereign Alberta would likely find a much warmer reception in Washington.
~Snip~
Albertans are tired of being the "poor cousin" who pays all the bills while being told to be grateful for the privilege. If the response from the East continues to be mockery and actual misinformation, don’t be surprised when the West finally walks out the door.

Commentary:
Factually Alberta is considered the wealthiest province in Canada, consistently ranking first in per capita GDP—approximately $71,000 to $82,200 CAD in recent years. Its economy is heavily driven by its massive oil sands, producing roughly 95% of Canada's oil. The province also holds a dominant position in agriculture, contributing significantly to Canada's beef and wheat production, along with a strong forestry sector.
Alberta also holds vast unconventional oil resources in its bituminous oil sands, making it the top producer in Canada.
In oil production alone the loss to Canada would amount to a minimum of $71.Billion GDP annually.
Additionally, Alberta is on the cusp of manufacturing "Graphene" in large quantities from waste petroleum increasing their GDP by another $10 to 15 billion annually.
The $64 dollar question is whether British Columbia and Saskatchewan will join Alberta?
See also:

Support for Independence in Alberta Reaches Levels Similar to Quebec

Committed Separatists Attribute Their Support for Independence to Optimism About the Future

www.ipsos.com

​

 

[westwall]

The case against the case against Alberta independence​

The arrogance of Canada's sneering Eastern establishment is inadvertently paving the way for a sovereign Alberta.​

The case against the case against Alberta independence

The arrogance of Canada's sneering Eastern establishment is inadvertently paving the way for a sovereign Alberta.

www.rebelnews.com

3 Feb 2026 ~~ By Ezra Levant

While the media fawns over Mark Carney’s "central banker" aesthetic and his promises to "whisper" to Donald Trump, Albertans see a different reality: a return to the same globalist policies that have long suppressed Western interests.
This growing divide was perfectly captured in a recent viral video from an Eastern "educator" who crudely attempted to lecture Albertans on why independence is a "stupid" idea. It was a masterclass in the very condescension that fuels separatism. Mocking Premier Danielle Smith and calling Albertans "potato men," the wannabe critic relied on a series of debunked scare tactics that fall apart under the slightest scrutiny.

​

The argument that Alberta would face economic devastation if it left Confederation is historically backwards. Alberta is the nation’s largest net contributor, sending tens of billions of dollars to Ottawa every year to subsidize other provinces.
In a sovereign Alberta, that wealth stays home. While critics claim corporations would flee, the oil and gas aren't moving; industry leaders will stay where the resources are, and if anything, it is the Canadian dollar that would collapse the day after a "Yes" vote, not the Alberta economy.
This economic leverage extends to the "landlocked" argument, which is equally hollow. Under the current federal framework, Alberta is already effectively landlocked by political vetoes. International law provides frameworks for landlocked nations to access tidewater, rights Alberta currently lacks within Canada, and a sovereign Alberta would likely find a much warmer reception in Washington.
~Snip~
Albertans are tired of being the "poor cousin" who pays all the bills while being told to be grateful for the privilege. If the response from the East continues to be mockery and actual misinformation, don’t be surprised when the West finally walks out the door.

Commentary:
Factually Alberta is considered the wealthiest province in Canada, consistently ranking first in per capita GDP—approximately $71,000 to $82,200 CAD in recent years. Its economy is heavily driven by its massive oil sands, producing roughly 95% of Canada's oil. The province also holds a dominant position in agriculture, contributing significantly to Canada's beef and wheat production, along with a strong forestry sector.
Alberta also holds vast unconventional oil resources in its bituminous oil sands, making it the top producer in Canada.
In oil production alone the loss to Canada would amount to a minimum of $71.Billion GDP annually.
Additionally, Alberta is on the cusp of manufacturing "Graphene" in large quantities from waste petroleum increasing their GDP by another $10 to 15 billion annually.
The $64 dollar question is whether British Columbia and Saskatchewan will join Alberta?
See also:

Support for Independence in Alberta Reaches Levels Similar to Quebec

Committed Separatists Attribute Their Support for Independence to Optimism About the Future

www.ipsos.com

​

She's a ******* moron.

 

[Eman623]

I will never support a state joining my union where the people think "about" rhymes with "boat".

More seriously, would you vote D or R, Alberta? That's all that matters. If you vote D, then we gotta find an R state to balance you. It's a twofer. But if you're an R, then maybe we can let Puerto Rico join. They would be a total D.

Maybe! That island is fucked in so many ways, I'm not even sure we want that basket case!

 

[shockedcanadian]

The chances of Alberta separating is slim but there is plenty of division now with Quebec now seeing it rise again even as they make by far the most in federal transfers to subsidize their social programs. Citizens do not feel represented as they once did especially out West and many of us worry about a naive shift towards China. With Harper recently coming out and suggesting Conservatives and Liberals unite, I suspect another election is coming soon.

 

[Doc7505]

The chances of Alberta separating is slim but there is plenty of division now with Quebec now seeing it rise again even as they make by far the most in federal transfers to subsidize their social programs. Citizens do not feel represented as they once did especially out West and many of us worry about a naive shift towards China. With Harper recently coming out and suggesting Conservatives and Liberals unite, I suspect another election is coming soon.

<~~~~~~~~~~>
Been to the Medicine Hat, Lethbridge and Calgary both to hunt Elk, Bear and fish and attending the Calgary Stampede several times in my life.
For the most part the people I met were no different than you or me. They have more in common with America than those in Ottawa, or Quebec. The people of Western Canada would fit in perfectly with the American way of life, better than the illegal aliens we are dealing with today.

 

[TheInfiniteSadness]

The chances of Alberta separating is slim but there is plenty of division now with Quebec now seeing it rise again even as they make by far the most in federal transfers to subsidize their social programs. Citizens do not feel represented as they once did especially out West and many of us worry about a naive shift towards China. With Harper recently coming out and suggesting Conservatives and Liberals unite, I suspect another election is coming soon.

We never felt represented but their isn't a ******* thing we could do about it. She is right about six of those things. I'l get into that later if I can.

 

[1srelluc]

Well, it just a matter of paperwork....It's not like the Hoser Army could do anything about it.

 

[August West]

The case against the case against Alberta independence​

The arrogance of Canada's sneering Eastern establishment is inadvertently paving the way for a sovereign Alberta.​

The case against the case against Alberta independence

The arrogance of Canada's sneering Eastern establishment is inadvertently paving the way for a sovereign Alberta.

www.rebelnews.com

3 Feb 2026 ~~ By Ezra Levant

While the media fawns over Mark Carney’s "central banker" aesthetic and his promises to "whisper" to Donald Trump, Albertans see a different reality: a return to the same globalist policies that have long suppressed Western interests.
This growing divide was perfectly captured in a recent viral video from an Eastern "educator" who crudely attempted to lecture Albertans on why independence is a "stupid" idea. It was a masterclass in the very condescension that fuels separatism. Mocking Premier Danielle Smith and calling Albertans "potato men," the wannabe critic relied on a series of debunked scare tactics that fall apart under the slightest scrutiny.

​

The argument that Alberta would face economic devastation if it left Confederation is historically backwards. Alberta is the nation’s largest net contributor, sending tens of billions of dollars to Ottawa every year to subsidize other provinces.
In a sovereign Alberta, that wealth stays home. While critics claim corporations would flee, the oil and gas aren't moving; industry leaders will stay where the resources are, and if anything, it is the Canadian dollar that would collapse the day after a "Yes" vote, not the Alberta economy.
This economic leverage extends to the "landlocked" argument, which is equally hollow. Under the current federal framework, Alberta is already effectively landlocked by political vetoes. International law provides frameworks for landlocked nations to access tidewater, rights Alberta currently lacks within Canada, and a sovereign Alberta would likely find a much warmer reception in Washington.
~Snip~
Albertans are tired of being the "poor cousin" who pays all the bills while being told to be grateful for the privilege. If the response from the East continues to be mockery and actual misinformation, don’t be surprised when the West finally walks out the door.

Commentary:
Factually Alberta is considered the wealthiest province in Canada, consistently ranking first in per capita GDP—approximately $71,000 to $82,200 CAD in recent years. Its economy is heavily driven by its massive oil sands, producing roughly 95% of Canada's oil. The province also holds a dominant position in agriculture, contributing significantly to Canada's beef and wheat production, along with a strong forestry sector.
Alberta also holds vast unconventional oil resources in its bituminous oil sands, making it the top producer in Canada.
In oil production alone the loss to Canada would amount to a minimum of $71.Billion GDP annually.
Additionally, Alberta is on the cusp of manufacturing "Graphene" in large quantities from waste petroleum increasing their GDP by another $10 to 15 billion annually.
The $64 dollar question is whether British Columbia and Saskatchewan will join Alberta?
See also:

Support for Independence in Alberta Reaches Levels Similar to Quebec

Committed Separatists Attribute Their Support for Independence to Optimism About the Future

www.ipsos.com

When I see a person who covers him or herself with grotesque tattoos, I steer clear. Are they insecure attention seekers?

​

 

[sparky]

from FB>>>>


Well friends, here in Alberta as many of you know, we are working on getting a referendum to vote for separating from Canada.....we should have enough signatures to warrant a vote sometime later in 2026 and our Premier has stated as much.
We are at a crossroads here in decaying Canada.....the Liberal party has brought ruination to our nation.....we have far to many dangerous immigrants running about and our economy is heading south (no pun intended).....
As disgusting as it is having seen the Liberals win the last election, it is for Alberta's separation aspirations, a good thing....every time Carney opens his mouth, more people come over to the separatists side....
Along with Alberta, likely Quebec will be electing a separatist govt later this year and Saskatchewan as well is starting to organize to leave....
If you want to know why separatism is rising, it is because the Canadian confederation is absurd.....Alberta has subsidized all the have not Provinces for decades with hundreds of billions of dollars going out East and to places like Manitoba as well....mainly Quebec has been a recipient of our largesse.....combine that with socialism and radical immigration from countries that hate us, Alberta wants out and rightly so....the benefits to a Free Alberta will be massive to us .....we would automatically be one of the richest nations on earth....our pensions would increase hugely.....far greater economic freedom ......our best ally to the South of us where we can sell our Oil ......if you do a cost benefit analysis, the answer is easy....Separation will be a financial boon to us.
Our preference is to become our own nation....not a 51st State ....though admittedly if we leave, it would eventually be the case where we join America....the main thing is to divorce ourselves from Ottawa.
The fight will be hard and dirty...the East of Canada has been saying many ugly things about us along with the far left....the national media is going to attack again and again.....
They are scared....and they should be...if Alberta leaves, the rest of Canada will split apart because they will have lost their sugar Daddy ....no more transfer pmts....the only province that will survive on its own will be Ontario....
We should have left decades ago but better late then never....

 

[Delldude]

51?

The Trump administration has been holding covert meetings with a fringe group seeking to separate the oil-rich province of Alberta from the rest of Canada, adding a layer of intrigue to the increasingly tense relationship between Washington and Ottawa.

State Department officials have met three times since April with leaders of the Alberta Prosperity Project, which advocates for secession from Canada.
The Alberta Prosperity Project backs an independence referendum in Alberta. The referendum, which has yet to be called, would make Canada’s fourth-largest province an independent nation. A group allied with the project, Stay Free Alberta, is trying to gather the 177,000 signatures necessary for a referendum. If successful, the vote could be scheduled from late 2026 to May 2027

---

Alberta Prosperity Project CEO Mitch Sylvestre told The Washington Times that the meetings with U.S. officials have focused on establishing a trade deal in the event Alberta breaks away from Canada. Although he acknowledged that the Alberta Prosperity Project does not have the authority to negotiate such an agreement, he said he didn’t want an independent Alberta to be caught flat-footed if the referendum wins approval.
“Since we do 88% of our trade with the U.S., I think that’s a very prudent step before you go off half-cocked and, all of a sudden, Day 1, you no longer have any trade agreements with anyone,” he said. “It would be good to gauge the temperature in the room.
Mr. Sylvestre said the Trump administration officials did not make any promises or pledges to help the separatist group. He said Alberta Prosperity Project leaders made it clear that they would prefer the Trump administration stay clear of the independence movement because “the most polarizing thing in Canada is Donald Trump.”
“There were no promises made because what would be the point of them promising three Alberta citizens anything?” he said.
He insisted that the Alberta Prosperity Project’s goal is a sovereign Alberta.

Trump admin holds secret talks with Canada separatist group

The Trump administration has been holding covert meetings with a fringe group seeking to separate the oil-rich province of Alberta from the rest of Canada, adding a layer of intrigue to the increasingly tense relationship between Washington and Ottawa.

www.washingtontimes.com