The Best DNA Ancestry Test?

abu afak

ALLAH SNACKBAR!
Mar 3, 2006
7,211
2,560
315
Best for the money that is.
One can spend many hundreds on some tests.

Been wanting to do this for some time.
May want more details than the standard ones provide, but this article gives a good look at where to start.
Just got Ancestry.com promo for their test at a very reasonable $59. in my Yahoo mail, which spurred a search yielding...
PS: 'Forbe's Finds' takes advertising that may influence the results.

APR 16, 2018 - Forbes
The Best DNA Ancestry Test
The Best DNA Ancestry Test

[.....]We narrowed down our picks from 15 US-based contenders to five by selected services that were under $400, and by identifying the services which had large databases of DNA reference samples. According to the experts that we spoke to, most services use the same techniques and offer similar results. A large databases is the differentiator which contributes to accuracy. Our tested DNA services include AncestryDNA, 23andMe, African Ancestry, Family Tree DNA, and National Geographic.
[.....]
We tested our picks using a panel of seven participants. The three men and four women have known ancestry from South Asia, Africa, Europe, East Asia, Polynesia, the Middle East, and (native) North America. After gathering at our offices in the New York Times building, participants registered their kits online and swabbed the inside of their cheeks, or spit into a tube, to provide their DNA samples.

After participants received their results, we conducted a survey which posed questions about how ancestry information was displayed, and how easy or difficult it was to further analyze results.

Our pick: AncestryDNA
[.....]​
`
 
Last edited:
Best for the money that is.
One can spend many hundreds on some tests.

Been wanting to do this for some time.
May want more details than the standard ones provide, but this article gives a good look at where to start.
Just got Ancestry.com promo for their test at a very reasonable $59. in my Yahoo mail, which spurred a search yielding...
PS: 'Forbe's Finds' takes advertising that may influence the results.

APR 16, 2018 @ 11:45 AM 73,566
The Best DNA Ancestry Test
The Best DNA Ancestry Test

[.....]We narrowed down our picks from 15 US-based contenders to five by selected services that were under $400, and by identifying the services which had large databases of DNA reference samples. According to the experts that we spoke to, most services use the same techniques and offer similar results. A large databases is the differentiator which contributes to accuracy. Our tested DNA services include AncestryDNA, 23andMe, African Ancestry, Family Tree DNA, and National Geographic.
[.....]
We tested our picks using a panel of seven participants. The three men and four women have known ancestry from South Asia, Africa, Europe, East Asia, Polynesia, the Middle East, and (native) North America. After gathering at our offices in the New York Times building, participants registered their kits online and swabbed the inside of their cheeks, or spit into a tube, to provide their DNA samples.

After participants received their results, we conducted a survey which posed questions about how ancestry information was displayed, and how easy or difficult it was to further analyze results.

Our pick: AncestryDNA
[.....]​
`
I was just looking into that and decided to dig deeper..........

Pulling Back the Curtain on DNA Ancestry Tests

Problems with AncestryDNA’s Genetic Ethnicity Prediction? - The Genetic Genealogist

Genetic Ancestry Tests Mostly Hype, Scientists Say

One can get ten different results from ten different DNA companies. Personal DNA testing still has a long way to go before becoming scientifically reliable so take your results with a block of salt.
 
I was toying with the idea of taking one just to see if the rumor of a Native American somewhere in the wood pile was true. But Pogo says these tests won't tell you that; they're a hoax.
 
Best for the money that is.
One can spend many hundreds on some tests.

Been wanting to do this for some time.
May want more details than the standard ones provide, but this article gives a good look at where to start.
Just got Ancestry.com promo for their test at a very reasonable $59. in my Yahoo mail, which spurred a search yielding...
PS: 'Forbe's Finds' takes advertising that may influence the results.

APR 16, 2018 @ 11:45 AM 73,566
The Best DNA Ancestry Test
The Best DNA Ancestry Test

[.....]We narrowed down our picks from 15 US-based contenders to five by selected services that were under $400, and by identifying the services which had large databases of DNA reference samples. According to the experts that we spoke to, most services use the same techniques and offer similar results. A large databases is the differentiator which contributes to accuracy. Our tested DNA services include AncestryDNA, 23andMe, African Ancestry, Family Tree DNA, and National Geographic.
[.....]
We tested our picks using a panel of seven participants. The three men and four women have known ancestry from South Asia, Africa, Europe, East Asia, Polynesia, the Middle East, and (native) North America. After gathering at our offices in the New York Times building, participants registered their kits online and swabbed the inside of their cheeks, or spit into a tube, to provide their DNA samples.

After participants received their results, we conducted a survey which posed questions about how ancestry information was displayed, and how easy or difficult it was to further analyze results.

Our pick: AncestryDNA
[.....]​
`
I was just looking into that and decided to dig deeper..........

Pulling Back the Curtain on DNA Ancestry Tests

Problems with AncestryDNA’s Genetic Ethnicity Prediction? - The Genetic Genealogist

Genetic Ancestry Tests Mostly Hype, Scientists Say

One can get ten different results from ten different DNA companies. Personal DNA testing still has a long way to go before becoming scientifically reliable so take your results with a block of salt.

Good to know. My results were boring.
 
Google DNA tests and then compare. Some just do the father's line, some just do the mother's line and a few do both. You'll want the one that does both.
CRIgenentics is more expensive, but gives you more info. Ancestry is good for the money.
 

Forum List

Back
Top