That's No Way to Treat a Hero

odanny

Diamond Member
Gold Supporting Member
Joined
May 7, 2017
Messages
25,470
Reaction score
20,836
Points
2,290
Location
Midwest - Trumplandia
Back in the day, even a Medal of Honor winner was not exempt from KP, or being busted down to a private. None of that would happen today, probably.

Maybe because he was an enlisted man the brass had no sympathy for him, and they most likely did not bother to consider PTSD. Smith was the first enlisted member of the United States Army Air Forces to earn the Medal of Honor
.




RAF_Thurleigh_-_306th_Bombardment_Group_-_MoH_Ceremony_Maynard_Smith.webp


Maynard-H-Smith.webp


Staff Sergeant Maynard Smith of the 306th Bombardment Group, is presented with the Medal of Honor by Secretary of War Henry L Stimson in front of a B-17 Flying Fortress at Thurleigh Airfield, USAAF Station 111, England.

423d_Bombardment_Squadron_-_Maynard_Harrison_Smith.webp



Staff Sergeant Smith's bomber was hit, rupturing a fuel tank and igniting a massive fire in the center of the fuselage. The damage was severe, knocking out communications and compromising the fuselage's integrity. Smith's ball turret lost power, and he scrambled out to assist the other crew members. Three crew members bailed out, while Smith tended to two others who were seriously wounded.

In between helping his wounded comrades, Smith also manned the .50 caliber machine guns and fought the raging fire. The heat from the fire was so intense that it began to melt the metal in the fuselage, threatening to break the plane in half.

For nearly 90 minutes, Smith alternated between shooting at attacking fighters, tending to the wounded, and fighting the fire. To starve the fire of fuel, he threw burning debris and exploding ammunition through the large holes that the fire had melted in the fuselage. After the fire extinguishers were exhausted, Smith finally managed to put the fire out, in part by urinating on it.

Smith's bomber reached England and landed at the first available airfield, where it broke in half as it touched down. It had been hit with more than 3,500 bullets and pieces of shrapnel. The three crew members who bailed out were never seen again and were presumed lost at sea, but Smith's efforts undoubtedly saved the lives of the six others aboard his aircraft.

Smith flew four more combat missions after earning the Medal of Honor, but was then grounded as a result of combat stress reaction/Post-traumatic stress disorder and was reassigned to non-combat clerical work. On December 17, 1944, he was forced to accept a reduction in rank to private for poor job performance, and was shortly thereafter permanently grounded.

Smith was sent home to the United States on February 2, 1945, and despite his transgressions, received a hero's welcome and a parade when he returned to his hometown. Smith was discharged from the U.S. Army on May 26, 1945. In his later years, he despised his time in the military and ran into legal troubles, but eventually retired quietly to Florida, dying of heart failure on May 11, 1984, in Saint Petersburg, at the age of 72. Maynard Harrison Smith is buried in Arlington National Cemetery, in Arlington, Virginia


 
It is amusing that the OP thinks that the Brass should think of anything other than winning the conflict.

There are systems in place to deal with the aftermath.

This is an attempt to paralyze our military from acting on the basis that the leadership does not consider the feelings of the rank and file.
 
It is amusing that the OP thinks that the Brass should think of anything other than winning the conflict.

There are systems in place to deal with the aftermath.

This is an attempt to paralyze our military from acting on the basis that the leadership does not consider the feelings of the rank and file.
WTF are you babbling about.
 
Rabble babble.
Let me ask you one question, and then I'll put you on ignore.

What is the primary role of our military leadership in ensuring our security?
 
Let me ask you one question, and then I'll put you on ignore.

What is the primary role of our military leadership in ensuring our security?
Why does the rabble babble, asked the camel?
 
Why does the rabble babble, asked the camel?
Exactly.

Why would the leadership ask the rank and file?

They would not.

You have to first win the war. The aftermath is not the concern of the leadership, but of trained mental professionals.

Never be paralyzed to do what is needed on the basis of some bullshit and made-up belief.
 
Exactly.

Why would the leadership ask the rank and file?

They would not.

You have to first win the war. The aftermath is not the concern of the leadership, but of trained mental professionals.

Never be paralyzed to do what is needed on the basis of some bullshit and made-up belief.

That's a rousing speech, right there.
 
Smith flew four more combat missions after earning the Medal of Honor

This is actually pretty typical. There is typically a delay of 2-4 months from an event and the awarding of medals for the event. And this is one of those typical ones. His action took place on 1 May 1943, the medal was awarded to him 15 July 1943, two and a half months later.

Just because somebody does something to merit an ward, that does not mean that they are just pulled off the line. They continue to do their duties until assigned elsewhere.

Another example is Dick Winters, who was recommended for the Medal of Honor for the Assault at Brecourt Manor on 6 June 1944. But it was downgraded and he received the Distinguished Service Cross on 1 July 1944. And as all should know that for getting the second highest award for valor he still served on the line for the rest of the war.
 
There is an even greater tale of courage when a plane was on fire, I don't remember the MoH recipients name, or the exact circumstances, but remember enough that an incendiary device of some type, I believe it was a flare that was supposed to be dropped to signify something, ignited on the aircraft, as result of enemy fire, and in order to save the aircraft, the airman picked it up and managed to throw it out a window of the aircraft, it burned off both hands and much of his face.
 
15th post
There is an even greater tale of courage when a plane was on fire, I don't remember the MoH recipients name, or the exact circumstances, but remember enough that an incendiary device of some type, I believe it was a flare that was supposed to be dropped to signify something, ignited on the aircraft, as result of enemy fire, and in order to save the aircraft, the airman picked it up and managed to throw it out a window of the aircraft, it burned off both hands and much of his face.
Many acts of bravery would have gone unrecorded i am sure, one interesting statistic from WW1 which i don't read much about because it's just too horrific, 13k Men from my town and surrounding area in lancashire were killed in that war and three Victoria Crosses were awarded to three men from the Town, the highest award for Gallantry, one for a Soldier who threw himself on a grenade to save his comrades, one other was a Soldier who stormed a German machine gun bunker and captured some Germans he was from the Coldstream Guards my Dads regiment in WW2 he was 29 but died aged just 35,heroes are among us.
1757711977520.webp
 
There is an even greater tale of courage when a plane was on fire, I don't remember the MoH recipients name, or the exact circumstances, but remember enough that an incendiary device of some type, I believe it was a flare that was supposed to be dropped to signify something, ignited on the aircraft, as result of enemy fire, and in order to save the aircraft, the airman picked it up and managed to throw it out a window of the aircraft, it burned off both hands and much of his face.
I believe that was John Levitow in Vietnam, and he won the Medal of Honor. He saved the aircraft by carrying a flare in his hands to the door and throwing it out.
 
Let me ask you one question, and then I'll put you on ignore.

What is the primary role of our military leadership in ensuring our security?
"The purpose of the military is to kill people and break things." It's brutal, but unfortunately, it's true—and it's the world we live in.
 
Back
Top Bottom