Obamanation -
Ah, I see. So now you'd like to have Qaddafi back, or what?
A things stand, all 3 countries (Libya, Egypt and Tunisia) have governments which are more pro-western and more peaceful than they did a year or so ago.
So really any objective person is going to welcome that.
What the US right wing SHOULD be doing is getting in behind those moderate governments and showing support for those leader. It's a shame partisanhip prevents that, so that you may end up backing nutvase extremists again - just as you did with the Mujahadeen.
See this is where we have real differences. You ask me if I'd like to have Qaddafi back -- he wasn't my leader -- but I know when he was their leader Sirya wasn't going to work with 4 other muslim nations in an effort to stregthen muslim interests. So, would I like him back in charge --- I dunno, very hard to say whats best or worst. Sometimes it may be best to not pick a side.
You say that all 3 are more "pro-western" than they were 3 years ago. How do we really know where their heart lies? They are saying what they think we want to hear for the most part, but their book of worship specifically tells them to war with anyone who doesn;t share their beliefs. The results of this belief go back to the beginning of recorded history. Can you really have a "pro-western" muslim.
I am a practicing Christian who holds no hate for muslims. I only put that as a preface.
If I find a Christian who doesn't practice the guides put forth in the Bible I consider that they back-slid. Apply the same logic to a muslim. Their book tells them to kill infidels - if that isn't their intention they have back-slid.
The bottom line is that a "good" muslim, like a "good" Christian trys to follow the guides of the book that defines their beliefs. As long as they carry the faith along, there will ALWAYS, be "good" muslims looking to kill infidels.
So here we are, giving them assistance by allowing the dominant factions to elevate in multiple countries creating an organized muslim world - telling us everything we want to hear.
I'm sure you won't see my points (at least entirely), but frankly, it's almost as scary to me as the imminent financial crisis that our country will face in the next 5-10 years if we don't quit borrowing .40 of every dollar our gov't spends.