Sgt_Gath
Diamond Member
- Jul 25, 2014
- 2,486
- 1,547
- 2,030
To sum it up, "trying waaaay too hard, and sorely lacking in focus." I had reasonably high hopes for this, but it just came out badly.
5 out of 10
Will Smith and Margot Robbie were highpoints (though... if we're being honest, even they had a couple of rather clunky lines, and cringeworthy scenes), but the rest of this movie was just a mess. The plot jumped all over the place, often made little sense, and had a tendency to be wildly uneven in tone. The retro soundtrack also felt more than a bit forced, and the rest of the cast felt so neglected in comparison to Smith and Robbie that it was almost comical. Several of them (most notably Katana and the wall jumping guy, though one could also make an argument for Captain Boomerang) were almost literally dumped on the audience half-way through the film with no real fanfare or characterization whatsoever.
The villain was also lame. She looked a lot better when she was filthy and crawling around all fours. In "goddess" mode, she just looked like doofy - A slightly blueish twenty-something year old woman in a chainmail bikini, who talks in cliches with a really obviously dubbed voiced, and needlessly shakes her ass all the over the place while shooting badly CGIed "magic" out of her finger tips.
The Joker was a disappointment. Leto's interpretation of the character simply doesn't feel like it has anything in common with the Joker of previous films or the comic books. He's not frightening enough, he's not intelligent enough, he's not lucid enough, and he's not animated enough. The guy barely talks! He mostly just poses for the camera, and floats around like he's doing a bad Jack Sparrow impression while high on quaaludes. I simply don't buy that this guy could be a serious intellectual threat to Batman. He comes off more like an upjumped gangbanger who dabbles too heavily in his own supply than a criminal mastermind.
He also seems to legitimately, and rather deeply, be in love with Harley, going to almost heroic extremes to rescue her. That's so far out of line with previous characterizations of their relationship that it's not even funny.