Should businesses owned by members of a religion be accountable to the law?

[JakeStarkey]

No court will buy that "no legitimate distinction between profit and non profit corporations."

 

[OKTexas]

Again, for the slow readers:

A private organization isn't defined as a business though.

Churches are businesses.

There is no reasonable distinction between a profit and a non profit corporation in the law regarding exemptions for religious liberty. Why should The Little Sisters have an exemption to Obmaacare on religious grounds but not Hobby Lobby? There is no reason. Both of them are entitled to the same exemption.

Because the sisters are about religion, Hobby Lobby is about business.

Businesses have no religious liberty.

Really, are you saying a kosher butcher shop can be required to stock pork chops for me?

 

[Yurt]

of course they should...did someone say otherwise?

 

[JakeStarkey]

Churches are businesses.

There is no reasonable distinction between a profit and a non profit corporation in the law regarding exemptions for religious liberty. Why should The Little Sisters have an exemption to Obmaacare on religious grounds but not Hobby Lobby? There is no reason. Both of them are entitled to the same exemption.

Because the sisters are about religion, Hobby Lobby is about business.

Businesses have no religious liberty.

Really, are you saying a kosher butcher shop can be required to stock pork chops for me?

If it is in the business of pork chops, sure.

 

[OKTexas]

Because the sisters are about religion, Hobby Lobby is about business.

Businesses have no religious liberty.

Really, are you saying a kosher butcher shop can be required to stock pork chops for me?

If it is in the business of pork chops, sure.

So since Hobby Lobby isn't in the business of providing abortion inducing drugs then they would also have no obligation to provide them?

 

[Yurt]

Because the sisters are about religion, Hobby Lobby is about business.

Businesses have no religious liberty.

Really, are you saying a kosher butcher shop can be required to stock pork chops for me?

If it is in the business of pork chops, sure.

whoooooooooooooosh

Texas: can a kosher shop be required to sell non kosher meat

Jakey: of course, if they are in the business of selling non-kosher meat

i can't stop laughing....i can't believe jake is this retarded....yeah...kosher shops the world over are all about selling pork

 

[JakeStarkey]

Really, are you saying a kosher butcher shop can be required to stock pork chops for me?

If it is in the business of pork chops, sure.

So since Hobby Lobby isn't in the business of providing abortion inducing drugs then they would also have no obligation to provide them?

That's a standard benefit in health insurance packages, so a religious exemption is not in order.

 

[JakeStarkey]

Really, are you saying a kosher butcher shop can be required to stock pork chops for me?

If it is in the business of pork chops, sure.

i can't stop laughing....i can't believe jake is this retarded....yeah...kosher shops the world over are all about selling pork

but since it isn't, then of course not.

Yurt, you truly are unable to abstract to the second level.

 

[OKTexas]

If it is in the business of pork chops, sure.

So since Hobby Lobby isn't in the business of providing abortion inducing drugs then they would also have no obligation to provide them?

That's a standard benefit in health insurance packages, so a religious exemption is not in order.

Wrong again, Catholic Charities get a religious exemption, they provide health insurance.