That is just sports in general. You typically have the same teams win over, and over, and over, and over again.
We all have a pretty good idea who will be back next year.
It feeds itself - a winning team is more successful in recruiting the best players, which only help it win more.
People (Red Sox fans) used to say that the Yankees bought the championships but they were really a magnet for the best players.
That is partially true. In baseball, you have to be a big market team to win. About every 20 years or so a small market team sneaks in like the Royals, but for the most part, you have to spend the money to win
As for college football, it does not matter where Urban goes, he wins. That is a sign of a good coach.
It would be interesting to see Saban venture out of the security blanket of the SEC where all the best players go in college football to see if he can still win a NCG.
Until that time, I say Urban is the best. Who else could cause a Big 10 team to win it all? The conference is horrible.
Having a top recruiting class, and therefore the best athletes, is a huge help. But that is not what wins consistently.
I don't think this Bama team was the most talented Saban has had.
And the flaw in your logic is that Ohio State does get top level recruits. According to Scout.com, for the period 2008 to 2015,OSU had a top 10 recruiting class every year except 2010 (ranked #20 that year). OSU has pulled in the #1 twice in that time period.
Alabama, during the same period, had a top 10 recruiting class every year. And had the #1 class twice.
But the big difference is, OSU was the ONLY Big 10 team with a top 10 recruiting class for 5 of those years, and the other 3 years there was only 1 other Big 10 team in the top 10 recruiting classes.
Bama, on the other hand, was never the only SEC team with a top 10 recruiting class. For two of the years, there were 6 other SEC teams with a top 10 class. The lowest number was 4, which happened 4 times.
So Bama has to play against those top level athletes year in and year out. OSU does not.
Also, Urban Meyer came to OSU in 2012. In 2011 OSU had the #6 recruiting class in the nation.
Saban showed up in 2007. Bama was not in the rankings for recruiting the previous year.
Urban walked into a quality program. Saban walked into a nightmare.