Jena 6
Duke Lacross
Oprah
Tawana Brawley
how many more hoaxes do you need. I know of one incident at a small college campus that was swept under the rug.
I need way more than whites have gotten away with. Thousands of so called "raped" white women, thousands of "you fit the description", thousands of "well this black guy did it" only to find out it was another white woman killing her young. How many hoaxes do you think I should wait to equal the amount of hoaxes whites have pulled?
So another lie, another hoax, another false accusation, is all ok, until we somehow "balance the books"? Is that what you're implying? An eye for an eye, a lie for a lie, "Look, THEY did it, so I can do it too!" And when one race has finally "gotten even", then what? The fundamental problem is this pernicious idea that "Someone else did wrong yesterday, so it's ok for me to do wrong today. After all, I'm only getting even!" Never mind whether the individual target actually DID anything or not; it's getting even with "THEM" that matters. Be careful, because that kind of thinking, that reduces individuals of a different group from ones own to an amorphous "THEY" or "THEM", and concludes that "THEY" don't matter, is at the root of racism and every other kind of group hatred.
In the meantime, neither you nor I know whether the customer wrote the slur, or the waitress did; and we may never know. If the guy did write a racial slur, what does he "deserve"? To be shunned? To be physically attacked? To be run out of town? To lose his job? If the waitress perpetrated a hoax, what does She deserve? The same? Is that for us to decide? What if someone else is harmed as a result; is that just? Look, if someone has committed a criminal or civil wrong here, there is a process to address that, and that process should take its course; if not, well, not every reprehensible act, word or sentiment, however ugly it may be, is ours to punish. It may offend our sensibilities that someone "got away" with something we deplore. All I know is that when any of us, as a group, take it upon ourselves to punish what the law cannot, there can be unforeseen consequences, and I'm not sure that doesn't outweigh any potential deterrent value in the exercise.We might just view this entire affair as a shining example of "what NOT to do" and leave it at that.