Performance layers on top of moral outrage

Anomalism

Diamond Member
Joined
Dec 1, 2020
Messages
11,555
Reaction score
8,643
Points
2,138
I’ve been noticing something about how people express outrage in high profile cases like Epstein.

On the surface, everyone agrees the act is horrific. Nobody is defending the crime. But if you look closer, a lot of the public conversation isn’t just about the wrongdoing itself. It’s also about signaling moral commitment.

People seem to compete over who can be the most outraged. Criticizing someone else’s outrage is often treated as morally suspect. The actual facts or deeper analysis sometimes get buried under louder declarations.

This isn’t automatically bad. The outrage often reflects genuine concern. But the louder it gets, the more it can feel like a performance layer over the actual moral concern. Part of it is audience management. People showing alignment, signaling values, or even calming some internal tension.
 
I’ve been noticing something about how people express outrage in high profile cases like Epstein.

On the surface, everyone agrees the act is horrific. Nobody is defending the crime. But if you look closer, a lot of the public conversation isn’t just about the wrongdoing itself. It’s also about signaling moral commitment.

People seem to compete over who can be the most outraged. Criticizing someone else’s outrage is often treated as morally suspect. The actual facts or deeper analysis sometimes get buried under louder declarations.

This isn’t automatically bad. The outrage often reflects genuine concern. But the louder it gets, the more it can feel like a performance layer over the actual moral concern. Part of it is audience management. People showing alignment, signaling values, or even calming some internal tension.

Let's look at the scoreboard so far:

Andrew Mountbatten-Windsor
Peter Mandelson
Thorbjørn Jagland
Tom Pritzker
Kathy Ruemmler
Brad Karp
George J. Mitchel
Sultan Ahmed bin Sulayem
Casey Wasserman
Peter Attia
Sarah Ferguson
Mona Juul
Miroslav Lajčák
Jack Lang
Mohamed Waheed Hassan
Richard Axel
David A. Ross
Larry Summers
Jes Staley
Leon Black

Every one of them a verifiable liberal, progressive, Democrat, or former Clinton or Obama cabinet member or associate.

And every one of them either arrested, charged, stepped down, resigned, replaced, fired, lost positions, shut down businesses, or is under investigation.

Epstein files fallout: Tracking the resignations, firings and investigations
 
Let's look at the scoreboard so far:

Andrew Mountbatten-Windsor
Peter Mandelson
Thorbjørn Jagland
Tom Pritzker
Kathy Ruemmler
Brad Karp
George J. Mitchel
Sultan Ahmed bin Sulayem
Casey Wasserman
Peter Attia
Sarah Ferguson
Mona Juul
Miroslav Lajčák
Jack Lang
Mohamed Waheed Hassan
Richard Axel
David A. Ross
Larry Summers
Jes Staley
Leon Black

Every one of them a verifiable liberal, progressive, Democrat, or former Clinton or Obama cabinet member or associate.

And every one of them either arrested, charged, stepped down, resigned, replaced, fired, lost positions, shut down businesses, or is under investigation.

Epstein files fallout: Tracking the resignations, firings and investigations
Andrew getting arrested surprised me. I figured he would be invulnerable.
 
1772120266757.webp
 

New Topics

Back
Top Bottom