Joz said:
While I think might be a good start, this will solve nothing. Castration removes the sex glands/testes. This is NOT about sex.
I understand your point, but I can't help but focus on the fact that we are talking about sexual molestation here, not random violence or burglary. I assume you are referring to the generally accepted theory that rape is not about sex. I agree that it is primarily about aggression and power, but it is expressed sexually.
While you are talking about physical castration, there is also chemical castration, which apprently is suggested for repeat rapists as well. I'm certainly no expert on this subject, but here is one report on it's use with pedophiles:
"Sex offenders, such as rapists,
pedophiles, and exhibitionists, are among the highest reoccurring offense populations in the United States probation system... Chemical castration is an ideal punishment for sex offenders. When Depo-Provera is administered, recidivism rates fall to 5%. Their sexual fantasies are lessened as a result of the reduction of testosterone levels..."
And:
"Proponents of castration argue that it is justified and appropriate, that by controlling sex offenders' irresistable urges to rape or molest again, castration allows them to be released without endangering the public. Of more than 700 Danish sex offenders castrated following multiple convictions, relapse rates dropped from between 17% and 50% to just 2%. A Norwegian study showed the same for selected male and female sex offenders (the women had their ovaries removed). In smaller studies in Scandinavia and Italy, chemical castration was equally effective in some groups of volunteer prisoners,
with the most dramatic reductions among pedophiles. These studies suggest the common argument-that rape is all about power, not sex, and therefore castration won't work-is wrong. A German study found that up to half of castrated men still could have erections and sex, but their desire was weakened or even extinguished. Johns Hopkins University psychiatrist and expert on treating sex offenders, Fred Berlin, points out that castration works "mainly in those who are sexually aroused by their crime...sadists and pedophiles."
I am sure that we can find certain "civil liberties" groups against this, with their own studies to back them up, but I remain for it, even if it is not 100% guaranteed to prevent all further child molestation.