That is not true. In fact, as you know, the violent crime rate in the United States is far lower than most of Western Europe along with Australia.
The most violent country in Europe: Britain is also worse than South Africa and U.S.
Not really. The problem with these kinds of statistics is that not every country counts crime the same way. The UK counts assault as anyone taking a swing at anyone else, while in the US
By the Numbers: Is the UK really 5 times more violent than the US?
2.
“In the UK there are 2,034 violent crimes per 100,000 people. …The US has a violent crime rate of 466 [violent] crimes per 100,000 residents.”
Some advice for Mr. Swann: when you see statistics that look
unbelievable, you probably
shouldn’t believe them, at least until you dig deeper into the data. Based on these figures, it appears that Britain is over 4 times more violent than the US, and since this is all he gives you, that is exactly what he leads his viewers to believe.
What Swann either doesn’t know, or simply doesn’t bother to tell his viewers, is that the definitions for “violent crime” are very different in the US and Britain, and the methodologies of the two statistics he cites are also different. (He probably simply doesn’t realize this: it appears that he lifted his data wholesale from a story
in the Daily Mail, without checking it–something you might expect a
fact checker to have done.)
First, it should be noted that the figures Swann gives are out of date: in 2010,
according to the FBI, the reported rate of violent crime in the US was 403 incidents per 100,000 people–the 466 figure comes from 2007. Second, and more importantly, the
FBI’s Uniform Crime Reports defines a “violent crime” as one of four specific offenses: murder and nonnegligent manslaughter, forcible rape, robbery, and aggravated assault.
The British Home Office, by contrast, has a substantially different definition of violent crime. The British definition includes all “crimes against the person,”
including simple assaults, all robberies, and all “sexual offenses,” as opposed to the FBI, which only counts
aggravated assaults and “
forcible rapes.”