MSNBC Apologizes for spreading fake propaganda.

[Roudy]

The propaganda arm of the Democratic Party (Communist Party) and Muslim Brotherhood posted a fake cartoon map, pretending there was actually a state called Palestine before 1948. What a surprise!

MSNBC apologizes for ‘completely wrong’ maps of Israel

Last Thursday during a live on-air discussion between Snow and Fletcher, a series of maps were displayed entitled “Palestinian loss of land 1946 – present.”

The first map pertaining to 1946 labeled the entire territory as “Palestine” with the vast majority of the map colored green, denoting Palestinian control. The following maps dated “UN Plan 1947,” “1949-1967” and “Present” showed Palestinian-controlled territory decreasing dramatically in size over time.

The maps and subsequent analysis gave the impression that a state of Palestine had existed in 1946 when in fact the area was under British Mandatory rule until May 14, 1948.



Screenshot of maps labled “Palestine” displayed during MSNBC coverage of ongoing unrest in Israel, October 15, 2015 (YouTube)

In Monday’s apology, Snow told viewers that the mistake had become apparent after the segment aired and the network regretted using the maps.

"The bottom line is it was completely wrong; there was no state called Palestine,” Fletcher said.

Typical Jewish OCD nitpicking.
I mean it was for British Mandate of Palestine, no?

Besides, even if it was controlled by Britain, it's indisputable that the majority of the territories were Arab, rather than Jewish.

It was not "Arab territory". It was Ottoman territory and they called it Southern Syria. The British / Europeans gave 99% of conquered Ottoman Middle East territory in the region to the Arab Muslims, and decided to give less than 1% to be the future Jewish homeland. Arabs had no say in this matter.

 

[Roudy]

You look it up, jackass.

Larn u summin'.

We don't be worshippin' no Moon Gods 'round heanh.

Allah is the Arabic word referring to God in Abrahamic religions.[11][12][13] It is distinguished from ilāh (Arabic: إله‎‎), the Arabic word meaning deity, which could refer to any of the gods worshipped in pre-Islamic Arabia.[14][15][16]

God in Islam - Wikipedia

BTW Christianity is an Abrahamic religion, along with Islam and Judaism.

Allah was the name for the moon god in ancient Arabia. Mohammad decided to call it that, in order to gain his tribe's allegiance.

Link?

Pagan Arabs worshipped the moon god thousands of years before Muhammad.
>
The notion of "Allah as Moon-God" had existed within certain currents of Evangelicalism in the United States since the 1990s. The idea was supposedly promulgated by Hugo Winckler in 1901, and proliferated from the publication of Robert Morey's book The moon-god Allah in the archeology of the Middle East (1994). Morey argues that "Allah" was the name of a Moon god in pre-Islamic Arabic mythology, the implication being that "Allah" as the term for God in Islam implies that Muslims are worshipping a false god. Some Islamic commentators have refuted the idea as "insulting".[1] The use of a lunar calendar and the prevalence of crescent moon imagery in Islam is said to be the origin of this hypothesis.[2]
Allah as Moon-god - Wikipedia

So let's see, Allah was the name of the moon god in Arabia, the symbol of Islam is the crescent moon, Mohamad's tribe were moon god worhpshippers, and there are archeological finds in Arabia depicting the exact same crescent moon god as the current symbol of Islam.

Like I said, maybe Allah means God to Muslims today, but as the evidence portrays, the name clearly originated from the moon god.

 

[Political Junky]

Allah is the Arabic word referring to God in Abrahamic religions.[11][12][13] It is distinguished from ilāh (Arabic: إله‎‎), the Arabic word meaning deity, which could refer to any of the gods worshipped in pre-Islamic Arabia.[14][15][16]

God in Islam - Wikipedia

BTW Christianity is an Abrahamic religion, along with Islam and Judaism.

Allah was the name for the moon god in ancient Arabia. Mohammad decided to call it that, in order to gain his tribe's allegiance.

Link?

Pagan Arabs worshipped the moon god thousands of years before Muhammad.
>
The notion of "Allah as Moon-God" had existed within certain currents of Evangelicalism in the United States since the 1990s. The idea was supposedly promulgated by Hugo Winckler in 1901, and proliferated from the publication of Robert Morey's book The moon-god Allah in the archeology of the Middle East (1994). Morey argues that "Allah" was the name of a Moon god in pre-Islamic Arabic mythology, the implication being that "Allah" as the term for God in Islam implies that Muslims are worshipping a false god. Some Islamic commentators have refuted the idea as "insulting".[1] The use of a lunar calendar and the prevalence of crescent moon imagery in Islam is said to be the origin of this hypothesis.[2]
Allah as Moon-god - Wikipedia

So let's see, Allah was the name of the moon god in Arabia, the symbol of Islam is the crescent moon, Mohamad's tribe were moon god worhpshippers, and there are archeological finds in Arabia depicting the exact same crescent moon god as the current symbol of Islam.

Like I said, maybe Allah means God to Muslims today, but as the evidence portrays, the name clearly originated from the moon god.

And Christmas was a Pagan celebration which the Church took advantage of and named it Christmas. Jesus was born in the Spring.
The virgin birth has been used by other religions for centuries.

 

[Roudy]

Allah was the name for the moon god in ancient Arabia. Mohammad decided to call it that, in order to gain his tribe's allegiance.

Link?

Pagan Arabs worshipped the moon god thousands of years before Muhammad.
>
The notion of "Allah as Moon-God" had existed within certain currents of Evangelicalism in the United States since the 1990s. The idea was supposedly promulgated by Hugo Winckler in 1901, and proliferated from the publication of Robert Morey's book The moon-god Allah in the archeology of the Middle East (1994). Morey argues that "Allah" was the name of a Moon god in pre-Islamic Arabic mythology, the implication being that "Allah" as the term for God in Islam implies that Muslims are worshipping a false god. Some Islamic commentators have refuted the idea as "insulting".[1] The use of a lunar calendar and the prevalence of crescent moon imagery in Islam is said to be the origin of this hypothesis.[2]
Allah as Moon-god - Wikipedia

So let's see, Allah was the name of the moon god in Arabia, the symbol of Islam is the crescent moon, Mohamad's tribe were moon god worhpshippers, and there are archeological finds in Arabia depicting the exact same crescent moon god as the current symbol of Islam.

Like I said, maybe Allah means God to Muslims today, but as the evidence portrays, the name clearly originated from the moon god.

And Christmas was a Pagan celebration which the Church took advantage of and named it Christmas. Jesus was born in the Spring.
The virgin birth has been used by other religions for centuries.

Correct, and yet that doesn't negate the fact that Allah was the name for the Saudi Arabian moon god.

 

[Political Junky]

Link?

Pagan Arabs worshipped the moon god thousands of years before Muhammad.
>
The notion of "Allah as Moon-God" had existed within certain currents of Evangelicalism in the United States since the 1990s. The idea was supposedly promulgated by Hugo Winckler in 1901, and proliferated from the publication of Robert Morey's book The moon-god Allah in the archeology of the Middle East (1994). Morey argues that "Allah" was the name of a Moon god in pre-Islamic Arabic mythology, the implication being that "Allah" as the term for God in Islam implies that Muslims are worshipping a false god. Some Islamic commentators have refuted the idea as "insulting".[1] The use of a lunar calendar and the prevalence of crescent moon imagery in Islam is said to be the origin of this hypothesis.[2]
Allah as Moon-god - Wikipedia

So let's see, Allah was the name of the moon god in Arabia, the symbol of Islam is the crescent moon, Mohamad's tribe were moon god worhpshippers, and there are archeological finds in Arabia depicting the exact same crescent moon god as the current symbol of Islam.

Like I said, maybe Allah means God to Muslims today, but as the evidence portrays, the name clearly originated from the moon god.

And Christmas was a Pagan celebration which the Church took advantage of and named it Christmas. Jesus was born in the Spring.
The virgin birth has been used by other religions for centuries.

Correct, and yet that doesn't negate the fact that Allah was the name for the Saudi Arabian moon god.

Allah means God.

 

[Roudy]

Pagan Arabs worshipped the moon god thousands of years before Muhammad.
>
The notion of "Allah as Moon-God" had existed within certain currents of Evangelicalism in the United States since the 1990s. The idea was supposedly promulgated by Hugo Winckler in 1901, and proliferated from the publication of Robert Morey's book The moon-god Allah in the archeology of the Middle East (1994). Morey argues that "Allah" was the name of a Moon god in pre-Islamic Arabic mythology, the implication being that "Allah" as the term for God in Islam implies that Muslims are worshipping a false god. Some Islamic commentators have refuted the idea as "insulting".[1] The use of a lunar calendar and the prevalence of crescent moon imagery in Islam is said to be the origin of this hypothesis.[2]
Allah as Moon-god - Wikipedia

So let's see, Allah was the name of the moon god in Arabia, the symbol of Islam is the crescent moon, Mohamad's tribe were moon god worhpshippers, and there are archeological finds in Arabia depicting the exact same crescent moon god as the current symbol of Islam.

Like I said, maybe Allah means God to Muslims today, but as the evidence portrays, the name clearly originated from the moon god.

And Christmas was a Pagan celebration which the Church took advantage of and named it Christmas. Jesus was born in the Spring.
The virgin birth has been used by other religions for centuries.

Correct, and yet that doesn't negate the fact that Allah was the name for the Saudi Arabian moon god.

Allah means God.

LOL. You remind me of a dog trying to chase its own tail. I already said that, Mohammad decided to use the same name "Allah" in order to gain his moon god worshiping tribe's allegiance, in order to make it more palatable for them. It was a political move. For the same reason Constantine made it Christianty conform to the pagan faith of the Romans.

 

[SobieskiSavedEurope]

The propaganda arm of the Democratic Party (Communist Party) and Muslim Brotherhood posted a fake cartoon map, pretending there was actually a state called Palestine before 1948. What a surprise!

MSNBC apologizes for ‘completely wrong’ maps of Israel

Last Thursday during a live on-air discussion between Snow and Fletcher, a series of maps were displayed entitled “Palestinian loss of land 1946 – present.”

The first map pertaining to 1946 labeled the entire territory as “Palestine” with the vast majority of the map colored green, denoting Palestinian control. The following maps dated “UN Plan 1947,” “1949-1967” and “Present” showed Palestinian-controlled territory decreasing dramatically in size over time.

The maps and subsequent analysis gave the impression that a state of Palestine had existed in 1946 when in fact the area was under British Mandatory rule until May 14, 1948.



Screenshot of maps labled “Palestine” displayed during MSNBC coverage of ongoing unrest in Israel, October 15, 2015 (YouTube)

In Monday’s apology, Snow told viewers that the mistake had become apparent after the segment aired and the network regretted using the maps.

"The bottom line is it was completely wrong; there was no state called Palestine,” Fletcher said.

Typical Jewish OCD nitpicking.
I mean it was for British Mandate of Palestine, no?

Besides, even if it was controlled by Britain, it's indisputable that the majority of the territories were Arab, rather than Jewish.

It was not "Arab territory". It was Ottoman territory and they called it Southern Syria. The British / Europeans gave 99% of conquered Ottoman Middle East territory in the region to the Arab Muslims, and decided to give less than 1% to be the future Jewish homeland. Arabs had no say in this matter.

The people who live on the land, are the natives, you sound like a colonist who thinks it's their God given right to steal land from others.

 

[Roudy]

The propaganda arm of the Democratic Party (Communist Party) and Muslim Brotherhood posted a fake cartoon map, pretending there was actually a state called Palestine before 1948. What a surprise!

MSNBC apologizes for ‘completely wrong’ maps of Israel

Last Thursday during a live on-air discussion between Snow and Fletcher, a series of maps were displayed entitled “Palestinian loss of land 1946 – present.”

The first map pertaining to 1946 labeled the entire territory as “Palestine” with the vast majority of the map colored green, denoting Palestinian control. The following maps dated “UN Plan 1947,” “1949-1967” and “Present” showed Palestinian-controlled territory decreasing dramatically in size over time.

The maps and subsequent analysis gave the impression that a state of Palestine had existed in 1946 when in fact the area was under British Mandatory rule until May 14, 1948.



Screenshot of maps labled “Palestine” displayed during MSNBC coverage of ongoing unrest in Israel, October 15, 2015 (YouTube)

In Monday’s apology, Snow told viewers that the mistake had become apparent after the segment aired and the network regretted using the maps.

"The bottom line is it was completely wrong; there was no state called Palestine,” Fletcher said.

Typical Jewish OCD nitpicking.
I mean it was for British Mandate of Palestine, no?

Besides, even if it was controlled by Britain, it's indisputable that the majority of the territories were Arab, rather than Jewish.

It was not "Arab territory". It was Ottoman territory and they called it Southern Syria. The British / Europeans gave 99% of conquered Ottoman Middle East territory in the region to the Arab Muslims, and decided to give less than 1% to be the future Jewish homeland. Arabs had no say in this matter.

The people who live on the land, are the natives, you sound like a colonist who thinks it's their God given right to steal land from others.

And Jews have been migrating back to their ancestral and religious homeland for the last two thousand years. Arab Muslims are the invaders.

 

[peach174]

The propaganda arm of the Democratic Party (Communist Party) and Muslim Brotherhood posted a fake cartoon map, pretending there was actually a state called Palestine before 1948. What a surprise!

MSNBC apologizes for ‘completely wrong’ maps of Israel

Last Thursday during a live on-air discussion between Snow and Fletcher, a series of maps were displayed entitled “Palestinian loss of land 1946 – present.”

The first map pertaining to 1946 labeled the entire territory as “Palestine” with the vast majority of the map colored green, denoting Palestinian control. The following maps dated “UN Plan 1947,” “1949-1967” and “Present” showed Palestinian-controlled territory decreasing dramatically in size over time.

The maps and subsequent analysis gave the impression that a state of Palestine had existed in 1946 when in fact the area was under British Mandatory rule until May 14, 1948.



Screenshot of maps labled “Palestine” displayed during MSNBC coverage of ongoing unrest in Israel, October 15, 2015 (YouTube)

In Monday’s apology, Snow told viewers that the mistake had become apparent after the segment aired and the network regretted using the maps.

"The bottom line is it was completely wrong; there was no state called Palestine,” Fletcher said.

Typical Jewish OCD nitpicking.
I mean it was for British Mandate of Palestine, no?

Besides, even if it was controlled by Britain, it's indisputable that the majority of the territories were Arab, rather than Jewish.

It was not "Arab territory". It was Ottoman territory and they called it Southern Syria. The British / Europeans gave 99% of conquered Ottoman Middle East territory in the region to the Arab Muslims, and decided to give less than 1% to be the future Jewish homeland. Arabs had no say in this matter.

The people who live on the land, are the natives, you sound like a colonist who thinks it's their God given right to steal land from others.

You can't steal from a territory.
It would have been a different ball game if Palestine had become a State.

 

[hadit]

The propaganda arm of the Democratic Party (Communist Party) and Muslim Brotherhood posted a fake cartoon map, pretending there was actually a state called Palestine before 1948. What a surprise!

MSNBC apologizes for ‘completely wrong’ maps of Israel

Last Thursday during a live on-air discussion between Snow and Fletcher, a series of maps were displayed entitled “Palestinian loss of land 1946 – present.”

The first map pertaining to 1946 labeled the entire territory as “Palestine” with the vast majority of the map colored green, denoting Palestinian control. The following maps dated “UN Plan 1947,” “1949-1967” and “Present” showed Palestinian-controlled territory decreasing dramatically in size over time.

The maps and subsequent analysis gave the impression that a state of Palestine had existed in 1946 when in fact the area was under British Mandatory rule until May 14, 1948.



Screenshot of maps labled “Palestine” displayed during MSNBC coverage of ongoing unrest in Israel, October 15, 2015 (YouTube)

In Monday’s apology, Snow told viewers that the mistake had become apparent after the segment aired and the network regretted using the maps.

"The bottom line is it was completely wrong; there was no state called Palestine,” Fletcher said.

So you are stealing the land from the British colony, which was and is called Palestine for many centuries. The state of Israel is what is new.

I don't recall the British complaining about it, do you?

 

[SobieskiSavedEurope]

The propaganda arm of the Democratic Party (Communist Party) and Muslim Brotherhood posted a fake cartoon map, pretending there was actually a state called Palestine before 1948. What a surprise!

MSNBC apologizes for ‘completely wrong’ maps of Israel

Last Thursday during a live on-air discussion between Snow and Fletcher, a series of maps were displayed entitled “Palestinian loss of land 1946 – present.”

The first map pertaining to 1946 labeled the entire territory as “Palestine” with the vast majority of the map colored green, denoting Palestinian control. The following maps dated “UN Plan 1947,” “1949-1967” and “Present” showed Palestinian-controlled territory decreasing dramatically in size over time.

The maps and subsequent analysis gave the impression that a state of Palestine had existed in 1946 when in fact the area was under British Mandatory rule until May 14, 1948.



Screenshot of maps labled “Palestine” displayed during MSNBC coverage of ongoing unrest in Israel, October 15, 2015 (YouTube)

In Monday’s apology, Snow told viewers that the mistake had become apparent after the segment aired and the network regretted using the maps.

"The bottom line is it was completely wrong; there was no state called Palestine,” Fletcher said.

Typical Jewish OCD nitpicking.
I mean it was for British Mandate of Palestine, no?

Besides, even if it was controlled by Britain, it's indisputable that the majority of the territories were Arab, rather than Jewish.

It was not "Arab territory". It was Ottoman territory and they called it Southern Syria. The British / Europeans gave 99% of conquered Ottoman Middle East territory in the region to the Arab Muslims, and decided to give less than 1% to be the future Jewish homeland. Arabs had no say in this matter.

The people who live on the land, are the natives, you sound like a colonist who thinks it's their God given right to steal land from others.

You can't steal from a territory.
It would have been a different ball game if Palestine had become a State.

It's a Colonist argument to say that because one has no statehood, but live on the land, they therefor don't have a right to that land.

Zionists prove to be scum.

 

[SobieskiSavedEurope]

The propaganda arm of the Democratic Party (Communist Party) and Muslim Brotherhood posted a fake cartoon map, pretending there was actually a state called Palestine before 1948. What a surprise!

MSNBC apologizes for ‘completely wrong’ maps of Israel

Last Thursday during a live on-air discussion between Snow and Fletcher, a series of maps were displayed entitled “Palestinian loss of land 1946 – present.”

The first map pertaining to 1946 labeled the entire territory as “Palestine” with the vast majority of the map colored green, denoting Palestinian control. The following maps dated “UN Plan 1947,” “1949-1967” and “Present” showed Palestinian-controlled territory decreasing dramatically in size over time.

The maps and subsequent analysis gave the impression that a state of Palestine had existed in 1946 when in fact the area was under British Mandatory rule until May 14, 1948.



Screenshot of maps labled “Palestine” displayed during MSNBC coverage of ongoing unrest in Israel, October 15, 2015 (YouTube)

In Monday’s apology, Snow told viewers that the mistake had become apparent after the segment aired and the network regretted using the maps.

"The bottom line is it was completely wrong; there was no state called Palestine,” Fletcher said.

Typical Jewish OCD nitpicking.
I mean it was for British Mandate of Palestine, no?

Besides, even if it was controlled by Britain, it's indisputable that the majority of the territories were Arab, rather than Jewish.

It was not "Arab territory". It was Ottoman territory and they called it Southern Syria. The British / Europeans gave 99% of conquered Ottoman Middle East territory in the region to the Arab Muslims, and decided to give less than 1% to be the future Jewish homeland. Arabs had no say in this matter.

The people who live on the land, are the natives, you sound like a colonist who thinks it's their God given right to steal land from others.

And Jews have been migrating back to their ancestral and religious homeland for the last two thousand years. Arab Muslims are the invaders.

The key word is "Immigrating"

 

[Roudy]

The propaganda arm of the Democratic Party (Communist Party) and Muslim Brotherhood posted a fake cartoon map, pretending there was actually a state called Palestine before 1948. What a surprise!

MSNBC apologizes for ‘completely wrong’ maps of Israel

Last Thursday during a live on-air discussion between Snow and Fletcher, a series of maps were displayed entitled “Palestinian loss of land 1946 – present.”

The first map pertaining to 1946 labeled the entire territory as “Palestine” with the vast majority of the map colored green, denoting Palestinian control. The following maps dated “UN Plan 1947,” “1949-1967” and “Present” showed Palestinian-controlled territory decreasing dramatically in size over time.

The maps and subsequent analysis gave the impression that a state of Palestine had existed in 1946 when in fact the area was under British Mandatory rule until May 14, 1948.



Screenshot of maps labled “Palestine” displayed during MSNBC coverage of ongoing unrest in Israel, October 15, 2015 (YouTube)

In Monday’s apology, Snow told viewers that the mistake had become apparent after the segment aired and the network regretted using the maps.

"The bottom line is it was completely wrong; there was no state called Palestine,” Fletcher said.

Typical Jewish OCD nitpicking.
I mean it was for British Mandate of Palestine, no?

Besides, even if it was controlled by Britain, it's indisputable that the majority of the territories were Arab, rather than Jewish.

It was not "Arab territory". It was Ottoman territory and they called it Southern Syria. The British / Europeans gave 99% of conquered Ottoman Middle East territory in the region to the Arab Muslims, and decided to give less than 1% to be the future Jewish homeland. Arabs had no say in this matter.

The people who live on the land, are the natives, you sound like a colonist who thinks it's their God given right to steal land from others.

And Jews have been migrating back to their ancestral and religious homeland for the last two thousand years. Arab Muslims are the invaders.

The key word is "Immigrating"

Yes, despite the many pogroms and invasions, Jews maintained a presence and kept coming back to their holyland to rebuild the ancient communities.

 

[SobieskiSavedEurope]

Typical Jewish OCD nitpicking.
I mean it was for British Mandate of Palestine, no?

Besides, even if it was controlled by Britain, it's indisputable that the majority of the territories were Arab, rather than Jewish.

It was not "Arab territory". It was Ottoman territory and they called it Southern Syria. The British / Europeans gave 99% of conquered Ottoman Middle East territory in the region to the Arab Muslims, and decided to give less than 1% to be the future Jewish homeland. Arabs had no say in this matter.

The people who live on the land, are the natives, you sound like a colonist who thinks it's their God given right to steal land from others.

And Jews have been migrating back to their ancestral and religious homeland for the last two thousand years. Arab Muslims are the invaders.

The key word is "Immigrating"

Yes, despite the many pogroms and invasions, Jews maintained a presence and kept coming back to their holyland to rebuild the ancient communities.

But, the Zionists displaced Palestinians from their land.

 

[Roudy]

It was not "Arab territory". It was Ottoman territory and they called it Southern Syria. The British / Europeans gave 99% of conquered Ottoman Middle East territory in the region to the Arab Muslims, and decided to give less than 1% to be the future Jewish homeland. Arabs had no say in this matter.

The people who live on the land, are the natives, you sound like a colonist who thinks it's their God given right to steal land from others.

And Jews have been migrating back to their ancestral and religious homeland for the last two thousand years. Arab Muslims are the invaders.

The key word is "Immigrating"

Yes, despite the many pogroms and invasions, Jews maintained a presence and kept coming back to their holyland to rebuild the ancient communities.

But, the Zionists displaced Palestinians from their land.

Actually, no such thing as "Palestinians" or "Palestinian land". And it was the Arabs that started attacking the Jewish communities such as Hebron, which had Jews who's ancestors fought against the Crusaders.

 

[peach174]

The propaganda arm of the Democratic Party (Communist Party) and Muslim Brotherhood posted a fake cartoon map, pretending there was actually a state called Palestine before 1948. What a surprise!

MSNBC apologizes for ‘completely wrong’ maps of Israel

Last Thursday during a live on-air discussion between Snow and Fletcher, a series of maps were displayed entitled “Palestinian loss of land 1946 – present.”

The first map pertaining to 1946 labeled the entire territory as “Palestine” with the vast majority of the map colored green, denoting Palestinian control. The following maps dated “UN Plan 1947,” “1949-1967” and “Present” showed Palestinian-controlled territory decreasing dramatically in size over time.

The maps and subsequent analysis gave the impression that a state of Palestine had existed in 1946 when in fact the area was under British Mandatory rule until May 14, 1948.



Screenshot of maps labled “Palestine” displayed during MSNBC coverage of ongoing unrest in Israel, October 15, 2015 (YouTube)

In Monday’s apology, Snow told viewers that the mistake had become apparent after the segment aired and the network regretted using the maps.

"The bottom line is it was completely wrong; there was no state called Palestine,” Fletcher said.

Typical Jewish OCD nitpicking.
I mean it was for British Mandate of Palestine, no?

Besides, even if it was controlled by Britain, it's indisputable that the majority of the territories were Arab, rather than Jewish.

It was not "Arab territory". It was Ottoman territory and they called it Southern Syria. The British / Europeans gave 99% of conquered Ottoman Middle East territory in the region to the Arab Muslims, and decided to give less than 1% to be the future Jewish homeland. Arabs had no say in this matter.

The people who live on the land, are the natives, you sound like a colonist who thinks it's their God given right to steal land from others.

You can't steal from a territory.
It would have been a different ball game if Palestine had become a State.

It's a Colonist argument to say that because one has no statehood, but live on the land, they therefor don't have a right to that land.

Zionists prove to be scum.

It didn't turn out to well for them when the Ottomans controlled either.
When any of them who were in control after each of the wars, the natives always lost their rights .
You can't own or have rights of your own land if you have no State rights protection. This would also have given the Bedouin tribes. They could have gotten tribal rights.
It's too bad they didn't understand this, back in the 1800's.

 

[peach174]

It was not "Arab territory". It was Ottoman territory and they called it Southern Syria. The British / Europeans gave 99% of conquered Ottoman Middle East territory in the region to the Arab Muslims, and decided to give less than 1% to be the future Jewish homeland. Arabs had no say in this matter.

The people who live on the land, are the natives, you sound like a colonist who thinks it's their God given right to steal land from others.

And Jews have been migrating back to their ancestral and religious homeland for the last two thousand years. Arab Muslims are the invaders.

The key word is "Immigrating"

Yes, despite the many pogroms and invasions, Jews maintained a presence and kept coming back to their holyland to rebuild the ancient communities.

But, the Zionists displaced Palestinians from their land.

No they didn't, unless you think Brits and all of the UN is Zionists.
Remember the Ottomans was on the Nazi's side.

 

[SobieskiSavedEurope]

Typical Jewish OCD nitpicking.
I mean it was for British Mandate of Palestine, no?

Besides, even if it was controlled by Britain, it's indisputable that the majority of the territories were Arab, rather than Jewish.

It was not "Arab territory". It was Ottoman territory and they called it Southern Syria. The British / Europeans gave 99% of conquered Ottoman Middle East territory in the region to the Arab Muslims, and decided to give less than 1% to be the future Jewish homeland. Arabs had no say in this matter.

The people who live on the land, are the natives, you sound like a colonist who thinks it's their God given right to steal land from others.

You can't steal from a territory.
It would have been a different ball game if Palestine had become a State.

It's a Colonist argument to say that because one has no statehood, but live on the land, they therefor don't have a right to that land.

Zionists prove to be scum.

It didn't turn out to well for them when the Ottomans controlled either.
When any of them who were in control after each of the wars, the natives always lost their rights .
You can't own or have rights of your own land if you have no State rights protection. This would also have given the Bedouin tribes. They could have gotten tribal rights.
It's too bad they didn't understand this, back in the 1800's.

So because Ottomans gave Arabs in Palestine poor rights, it somehow means Jews must follow the same path?

 

[SobieskiSavedEurope]

The people who live on the land, are the natives, you sound like a colonist who thinks it's their God given right to steal land from others.

And Jews have been migrating back to their ancestral and religious homeland for the last two thousand years. Arab Muslims are the invaders.

The key word is "Immigrating"

Yes, despite the many pogroms and invasions, Jews maintained a presence and kept coming back to their holyland to rebuild the ancient communities.

But, the Zionists displaced Palestinians from their land.

No they didn't, unless you think Brits and all of the UN is Zionists.
Remember the Ottomans was on the Nazi's side.

Brits can be very Zionist, as for Turkey they rejected Hitler's invitation to join them.

 

[Roudy]

It was not "Arab territory". It was Ottoman territory and they called it Southern Syria. The British / Europeans gave 99% of conquered Ottoman Middle East territory in the region to the Arab Muslims, and decided to give less than 1% to be the future Jewish homeland. Arabs had no say in this matter.

The people who live on the land, are the natives, you sound like a colonist who thinks it's their God given right to steal land from others.

You can't steal from a territory.
It would have been a different ball game if Palestine had become a State.

It's a Colonist argument to say that because one has no statehood, but live on the land, they therefor don't have a right to that land.

Zionists prove to be scum.

It didn't turn out to well for them when the Ottomans controlled either.
When any of them who were in control after each of the wars, the natives always lost their rights .
You can't own or have rights of your own land if you have no State rights protection. This would also have given the Bedouin tribes. They could have gotten tribal rights.
It's too bad they didn't understand this, back in the 1800's.

So because Ottomans gave Arabs in Palestine poor rights, it somehow means Jews must follow the same path?

Your grasp of history is pathetic. The Arabs of Southern Syria who were fellow Sunni Muslims, had better rights than the Jews, however the Ottomans knew that even prophet Mohammad recognized that the land was the promised land of the Jews, as confirmed in the Koran. That's why as early as the 1500's they invaded the Jews who were fleeing the Inquisition and Crusades, to come back and join fellow Jews in their own holy land, who had already been there.