The Democratic commissioners, Shana M. Broussard and Ellen L. Weintraub, argued that the charges against Trump — that he "knowingly and willfully accepted contributions nearly 5,000% over the legal limit to suppress a negative story mere days before Election Day" — were "well-grounded."
The Republican commissioners, Sean J. Cooksey and James E. Trainor III, didn’t address the charges’ validity, but instead argued that Cohen’s guilty plea in federal court made the public record "complete." This, they argued, made moot any actions by the commission, including action against Trump.
"We concluded that pursuing these matters further was not the best use of agency resources," Cooksey and Trainor wrote. "The commission regularly dismisses matters where other government agencies have already adequately enforced and vindicated the commission’s interests. Furthermore, by the time (the general counsel’s) recommendations came before us, the commission was facing an extensive enforcement docket backlog resulting from a prolonged lack of a quorum."