heil hitler
Senior Member
- Mar 11, 2017
- 952
- 118
- 45
- Banned
- #21
Please elaborate as to how federal immigration laws are a states rights issue.States' right issue
Follow along with the video below to see how to install our site as a web app on your home screen.
Note: This feature may not be available in some browsers.
Please elaborate as to how federal immigration laws are a states rights issue.States' right issue
The Constitution clearly establishes that Immigration is in fact a FEDERAL power and duty NOT a State one.
Article 1 - The Legislative Branch
Section 9 - Limits on Congress
<<Back | Table of Contents | Next>>
The Migration or Importation of such Persons as any of the States now existing shall think proper to admit, shall not be prohibited by the Congress prior to the Year one thousand eight hundred and eight, but a tax or duty may be imposed on such Importation, not exceeding ten dollars for each person.
These traitors are by no means liberals. These seditionists are hard core communist America-haters. What needs to be done is force Israel to have sanctuary cities, open borders, and take in mass floods of refugees - give them a dose of the medicine they've been forcing upon America.
Huh?These traitors are by no means liberals. These seditionists are hard core communist America-haters. What needs to be done is force Israel to have sanctuary cities, open borders, and take in mass floods of refugees - give them a dose of the medicine they've been forcing upon America.
States' right issue
States are part of the union, they comprise the body of this government via duly and commensurately apportioned representatives who are voted upon by the people, according to the US Constitution. What the Constitution is is a contract among the states and the overall government. How can we call ourselves a "Union" when there are states bucking the authority of a constitutionally established federal government? How can there be a union when states are refusing to obey just law?
Yeah, state's rights. It was a stupid argument when conservatives were using it, and it's a stupid argument now when liberals like you are using it.
I am? It seems to me the states are the ones stealing the power here.States' right issue
States are part of the union, they comprise the body of this government via duly and commensurately apportioned representatives who are voted upon by the people, according to the US Constitution. What the Constitution is is a contract among the states and the overall government. How can we call ourselves a "Union" when there are states bucking the authority of a constitutionally established federal government? How can there be a union when states are refusing to obey just law?
Yeah, state's rights. It was a stupid argument when conservatives were using it, and it's a stupid argument now when liberals like you are using it.
You seem to be having trouble distinguishing between proper enumerated powers like this one and stolen powers where the feds were enabled by the courts.
I am? It seems to me the states are the ones stealing the power here.States' right issue
States are part of the union, they comprise the body of this government via duly and commensurately apportioned representatives who are voted upon by the people, according to the US Constitution. What the Constitution is is a contract among the states and the overall government. How can we call ourselves a "Union" when there are states bucking the authority of a constitutionally established federal government? How can there be a union when states are refusing to obey just law?
Yeah, state's rights. It was a stupid argument when conservatives were using it, and it's a stupid argument now when liberals like you are using it.
You seem to be having trouble distinguishing between proper enumerated powers like this one and stolen powers where the feds were enabled by the courts.
Explain.
Yeah, state's rights. It was a stupid argument when conservatives were using it, and it's a stupid argument now when liberals like you are using it.
Do you have other examples?
Do you have other examples?
Remember the Arizona immigration law? That there was a state trying to take power away from the government that did not belong to it. No matter how much I agreed with the intentions, it wasn't Arizona's right to assume powers given to the federal government, even while the government was refusing to exercise them.
What's happening with California, Washington, Massachusetts and others, who are passing sanctuary bills, is essentially the same thing. The individual state is saying it is more powerful than the government and that is has no obligation to enforce a duly and justly enacted law, e.g. our immigration laws.
Gay rights would be another issue where conservatives used the "states rights" or "people's rights" argument. But that's a Pandora's box I'd rather not open tonight if I can help it.
Then you will never bring it up again. Ever.States' right issue
Not since 1808. See Article 1, Section 9, Clause 1.
Then you will never bring it up again. Ever.States' right issue
Not since 1808. See Article 1, Section 9, Clause 1.
Then you will never bring it up again. Ever.States' right issue
Not since 1808. See Article 1, Section 9, Clause 1.
You were the one being emphatic so I made fun of you.Then you will never bring it up again. Ever.States' right issue
Not since 1808. See Article 1, Section 9, Clause 1.
Oh look at Jake issuing commands!
The Alt Right crazies are posting tonight!
"Liberalism" is a title that the Alt Right gives to everyone who disagrees with their movement.