Iran Absurd Arguments

CrusaderFrank

Diamond Member
Joined
May 20, 2009
Messages
161,491
Reaction score
87,948
Points
2,645
Please explain how this ends

Reductio ad absurdum (argument to absurdity) is a logical technique that disproves a statement by showing it leads to an impossible, illogical, or absurd conclusion.

We agree the war is ongoing. Can we agree that sending Mossad Jared and Witkoff to Pakistan as "American" negotiators proves we're totally unserious about any negotiation, there is no off ramp and that the war will only end when one side is clearly victorious?

From Iran's POV they want USA out of the Middle East. They've already made a good case for it by rendering many of our bases inoperative. They are backed by Russia and China who are providing ISR, but, so far no weapons. Their capacity to continue the fight is robust.

From the USA/Israel "Alliance" POV we have to default to what Bibi and Greater Israel wants. If you had any doubts before, it is now embarrassingly obvious that Bibi is the lead partner in the USA/Israeli relationship. Trump crafted an off-ramp through Pakistan, Bibi vetoed it. From our senior partners POV, they want Iran, the entire Middle East destabilized so that they will rule the world. They want to destroy Iran as a nation and take down the GCC in the process and thought that Trump would do it for them.

How does this end, who "wins"?
 
As I have typed in this space before, the NORMAL way that a war ends is, one side punishes the other side so severely that the punished State finally says, "I give up; please stop." In diplomatic terms, this is often described as "sues for peace."

But in the Islamic world, belligerence is a religious mandate, so they are constitutionally unable to say, "I give up." And they accept massive death and destruction as "par for the course."

Iran is defeated, but not totally. In a country of ninety-plus million, where a major portion of the population is an armed part of the ruling "mafia," it would be necessary to kill every one of the fukkers to "win." We could do that, but Americans would be outraged.

Even at 90% defeated, they have the means to continue to take "potshots" at their adversaries, and apparently to control traffic through the infamous Strait. The objective would be to find a way to HURT them such that they feel the pain, so to speak. Any civilized country would have passed that point when we killed all their top leaders, eh?

Our Beloved President and the Secretary of War must find this point of vulnerability and attack it, and SOON. The bullshit "cease fire" was breached before the figurative ink was dry, and the Administration is hemming and hawing about how it's still "working." NOBODY is buying it. Time to declare it a failure and move on to Death & Destruction, as Trump threatened for the past two weeks.
 
As I have typed in this space before, the NORMAL way that a war ends is, one side punishes the other side so severely that the punished State finally says, "I give up; please stop." In diplomatic terms, this is often described as "sues for peace."

But in the Islamic world, belligerence is a religious mandate, so they are constitutionally unable to say, "I give up." And they accept massive death and destruction as "par for the course."

Iran is defeated, but not totally. In a country of ninety-plus million, where a major portion of the population is an armed part of the ruling "mafia," it would be necessary to kill every one of the fukkers to "win." We could do that, but Americans would be outraged.

Even at 90% defeated, they have the means to continue to take "potshots" at their adversaries, and apparently to control traffic through the infamous Strait. The objective would be to find a way to HURT them such that they feel the pain, so to speak. Any civilized country would have passed that point when we killed all their top leaders, eh?

Our Beloved President and the Secretary of War must find this point of vulnerability and attack it, and SOON. The bullshit "cease fire" was breached before the figurative ink was dry, and the Administration is hemming and hawing about how it's still "working." NOBODY is buying it. Time to declare it a failure and move on to Death & Destruction, as Trump threatened for the past two weeks.
If any supporters of this insanity have sons/daughters between 18 and 25, make sure they know what's coming, time for them to step up and do their duty for Israel.


1775751332139.webp
 
Back
Top Bottom