As a former cop of 8 years, I wanna say thanks to all of you who posted positive things about law enforcement. Yes, it's an incredibly tough job and getting harder thanks to sleazy lawyers. But they do the job anyway.
As far as pay, I have an interesting perspective on this. Yes, I was among the officers who was sure we deserved to be paid more.
BUT I had an old veteran sergeant put it into perspective for me in a really awesome way. Here is what he said:
"Yeah, we'd all like to make $80,000 a year. But if we did, how many people would become cops for the money? And if your daughter is in a school shooting like Columbine, who do you want coming to save her ? A cop who is in it for the money? Or a cop is in it despite the money?"
And that summed it up all I needed. Cops do the job despite the money. Risk getting killed for strangers, a lot of times for strangers who hate cops. And that is what makes cops, soldiers and firemen different from anyone else. They risk death on behalf of others. The safety of all of us depends on cops, soldiers, and firemen taking that risk. Thus, if we pay them $100,000 a year, we'll inevitably end up with a few cops who are in it ONLY for the pay, and at the first call where they must risk their life, they will not do it. They'll back out and show cowardice, and a citizen is hurt or killed. We cannot afford to have anyone in a police, military or fire uniform that hesitates to take that risk. Thus, the pay must be modest in order to only attract and retain the people who are willing to take that risk and are only in the job for the honor and duty of the job, not the pay.
That is why they are different than teachers, politicians, or the "most dangerous job in the world" of a crab fisherman, miner, logger, etc. All of those jobs are either important or dangerous. But none of them are both important, dangerous AND causes each citizens safety to be dependent on them performing that job.
So trying to compare cops, soldiers or firemen to a teacher, politician, steel worker, logger, or fisherman is just a bad comparison because no other job in society puts the direct safety of all citizens at the mercy of the person being willing to risk their lives to do the job. And thats why none of them can be very highly paid, because we can't risk people in those 3 jobs who are in it only for the money, because they'll fail and not take that risk.
So, a modest, average wage for cops is fair. $40,000 or so. Good benefits. They deserve a good wage, but the profession cannot attract those in it for the money. Thats my take.