Zone1 Here's Why White Guilt About Slavery Is Insane

Mr. Friscus

Diamond Member
Joined
Dec 28, 2020
Messages
8,806
Reaction score
9,135
Points
2,138
Modern woke pseudo-history paints a fabricated story of slavery; that white men came to Africa, stole Africans from their lands, and brought them to America. It was White American men, and only White American men, who were guilty of this, and it was a large majority of them as well. This was unique to the world at the time and in world history, and is a special evil in the history of mankind.

Of course, this is all complete nonsense, and is just woke propaganda we were taught in schools or are being told by politicians or media pundits today. But it's important to look at the context and just how insanely wrong these claims are. Let's look at total number of slaves, for example:

It is absolutely true that the Trans-Atlantic slave trade, in which Africans captured other Africans and sold them, shipped approximately 12.5 million slaves across the Atlantic to the Americas.

The Issue becomes where those slaves were taken. A woke liberal would probably assume that 12.5 million slaves were taken from Africa and sent to the American south. That would be insanely false. The breakdown looks like this:
  • 5.4 million were sent to Brazil
  • 3.6 million were sent to the Carribean
  • 1.2 million were sent to Jamaica
  • 900,000 were sent to St. Dominique (French Colony)
  • 889,000 were sent to Cuba
  • 470,000 were sent to the United States

So in this cry of woke left Democrat social justice warriors... cries of the unique evil of America, white men, etc... they make the claims they do when American only partook in 3% of the Trans-Atlantic Slave trade.

Add to that how there were only about 390,000 slave owners in the USA out of a population of 31 million... and you have approximately 1.2% of the population participating or benefitting from it, yet is that what Democrats, leftists, or educators say, address, or teach?

Slavery is an evil that has existed as long as human history has. All races have been enslaved, many continue to be. As far as America is concerned, it basically happened for 90 years nearly 200 years ago. However, no woke Democrat can legitimately point the finger at the USA as some unique evil in slavery, nor can they say we were any leader in it. They need to point the finger at Africans of the times first, and then all the South American/Brazilian/Carribean nations who were far greater participants.

And this is just the Trans-Atlantic slave trade. Again, Slavery exists across the world at far greater rates throughout history.

So, any person who wants to demonize the USA and White people as a unique evil as far as slavery, or as a major historical cause of it, is just revealing their tragic indoctrination and ignorance of history.
 
Modern woke pseudo-history paints a fabricated story of slavery; that white men came to Africa, stole Africans from their lands, and brought them to America. It was White American men, and only White American men, who were guilty of this, and it was a large majority of them as well. This was unique to the world at the time and in world history, and is a special evil in the history of mankind.

Of course, this is all complete nonsense, and is just woke propaganda we were taught in schools or are being told by politicians or media pundits today. But it's important to look at the context and just how insanely wrong these claims are. Let's look at total number of slaves, for example:

It is absolutely true that the Trans-Atlantic slave trade, in which Africans captured other Africans and sold them, shipped approximately 12.5 million slaves across the Atlantic to the Americas.

The Issue becomes where those slaves were taken. A woke liberal would probably assume that 12.5 million slaves were taken from Africa and sent to the American south. That would be insanely false. The breakdown looks like this:
  • 5.4 million were sent to Brazil
  • 3.6 million were sent to the Carribean
  • 1.2 million were sent to Jamaica
  • 900,000 were sent to St. Dominique (French Colony)
  • 889,000 were sent to Cuba
  • 470,000 were sent to the United States

So in this cry of woke left Democrat social justice warriors... cries of the unique evil of America, white men, etc... they make the claims they do when American only partook in 3% of the Trans-Atlantic Slave trade.

Add to that how there were only about 390,000 slave owners in the USA out of a population of 31 million... and you have approximately 1.2% of the population participating or benefitting from it, yet is that what Democrats, leftists, or educators say, address, or teach?

Slavery is an evil that has existed as long as human history has. All races have been enslaved, many continue to be. As far as America is concerned, it basically happened for 90 years nearly 200 years ago. However, no woke Democrat can legitimately point the finger at the USA as some unique evil in slavery, nor can they say we were any leader in it. They need to point the finger at Africans of the times first, and then all the South American/Brazilian/Carribean nations who were far greater participants.

And this is just the Trans-Atlantic slave trade. Again, Slavery exists across the world at far greater rates throughout history.

So, any person who wants to demonize the USA and White people as a unique evil as far as slavery, or as a major historical cause of it, is just revealing their tragic indoctrination and ignorance of history.
You left out the Arabic colonizers that bought the slaves from African tribesmen.
 
Modern woke pseudo-history paints a fabricated story of slavery; that white men came to Africa, stole Africans from their lands, and brought them to America. It was White American men, and only White American men, who were guilty of this, and it was a large majority of them as well. This was unique to the world at the time and in world history, and is a special evil in the history of mankind.
Classic Strawman. Nice work.
 
Modern woke pseudo-history paints a fabricated story of slavery; that white men came to Africa, stole Africans from their lands, and brought them to America. It was White American men, and only White American men, who were guilty of this, and it was a large majority of them as well. This was unique to the world at the time and in world history, and is a special evil in the history of mankind.

Of course, this is all complete nonsense, and is just woke propaganda we were taught in schools or are being told by politicians or media pundits today. But it's important to look at the context and just how insanely wrong these claims are. Let's look at total number of slaves, for example:

It is absolutely true that the Trans-Atlantic slave trade, in which Africans captured other Africans and sold them, shipped approximately 12.5 million slaves across the Atlantic to the Americas.

The Issue becomes where those slaves were taken. A woke liberal would probably assume that 12.5 million slaves were taken from Africa and sent to the American south. That would be insanely false. The breakdown looks like this:
  • 5.4 million were sent to Brazil
  • 3.6 million were sent to the Carribean
  • 1.2 million were sent to Jamaica
  • 900,000 were sent to St. Dominique (French Colony)
  • 889,000 were sent to Cuba
  • 470,000 were sent to the United States

So in this cry of woke left Democrat social justice warriors... cries of the unique evil of America, white men, etc... they make the claims they do when American only partook in 3% of the Trans-Atlantic Slave trade.

Add to that how there were only about 390,000 slave owners in the USA out of a population of 31 million... and you have approximately 1.2% of the population participating or benefitting from it, yet is that what Democrats, leftists, or educators say, address, or teach?

Slavery is an evil that has existed as long as human history has. All races have been enslaved, many continue to be. As far as America is concerned, it basically happened for 90 years nearly 200 years ago. However, no woke Democrat can legitimately point the finger at the USA as some unique evil in slavery, nor can they say we were any leader in it. They need to point the finger at Africans of the times first, and then all the South American/Brazilian/Carribean nations who were far greater participants.

And this is just the Trans-Atlantic slave trade. Again, Slavery exists across the world at far greater rates throughout history.

So, any person who wants to demonize the USA and White people as a unique evil as far as slavery, or as a major historical cause of it, is just revealing their tragic indoctrination and ignorance of history.
Do you have white guilt?
 
What "white guilt"? :dunno:

Don't get me started on Black Fatigue though 'cause it's real.
I’m attacking the concept, and yes, black fatigue has occurred from the constant obsession with slavery, race, etc. It’s more and more accepted to roll your eyes and mock it than it was 10 years ago.
 
15th post
Everything he stated is true. Don't be scared, tell us SPECIFICALLY what statements you believe are false and what your belief is based upon.
Everything he stated is false based on my knowledge and experience. If you think they are true, it is incumbent on you to prove them true, I don't need to prove them false.
 
Everything he stated is false based on my knowledge and experience. If you think they are true, it is incumbent on you to prove them true, I don't need to prove them false.
What a crock. I've studied African slavery and everything I've read supports the OP. You are going with your FEELZ, which is what I expected. You again failed to address even one assertion from the OP. Typical.
 
I have and I don't recall anyone saying what you claim. Got a quote or link? I think MarcATL also would like to see them.
Let's just ask a few questions. Have you ever heard a leftist, Democrat, woke SJW, or BLM activist say:

1. Slavery is a world-history problem that goes back as long as humans have been alive, and has manifested in all races and cultures and thus has just been another chapter in a long-standing evil institution?

2. Blacks are the ones who captured other blacks in Africa, and thus are guilty of initiating the Trans-Atlantic Slave Trade?

3. 97% of Africans were not brought to the USA?

4. Only 1% of White people owned slaves?

I've never heard any of it. Never. Not from a Democrat, not from a CRT/1619 Project guru, not from a woke SJW, not from a BLM activist...

On the contrary, we've seen the messaging from the left on the topic. White people hold an "original sin", black slavery was uniquely evil, all of white people benefitted, we need reparations from all whites. Africans were victims only (despite being the ones who enslaved one another).
 
What a crock. I've studied African slavery and everything I've read supports the OP. You are going with your FEELZ, which is what I expected. You again failed to address even one assertion from the OP. Typical.
Which assertion did you defend? Not one. Even with your vast store of education and experience.
 
Back
Top Bottom