Hamas Threatens Another Attack

[toastman]

It didn't say that Israel won anything.

Why do you need a link for that ? Israel captured that land, and you already know that the land belongs to Israel. It's inside the green line. That's winning the land.

Why the **** do I bother do you. You make me run around in circles explaining things to you that you know is right. You make my head hurt.

What's YOUR definition of winning land in a war?

For one thing it is illegal to "win" land in war.

Another is that nobody won that war.

The green line is specifically not to be a political or territorial border. If Israel had won that land it would be a border.

Poppycock.

2. The Armistice Demarcation Line is not to be construed in any sense as a political or territorial boundary,...

The Avalon Project Egyptian-Israeli General Armistice Agreement February 24 1949

What is Israel's stance? That's what matters.

Tinmore will ask you for a link to back this statement up

 

[theliq]

Sure, I gave you a link. You need to learn to read.

It didn't say that Israel won anything.

Why do you need a link for that ? Israel captured that land, and you already know that the land belongs to Israel. It's inside the green line. That's winning the land.

Why the **** do I bother do you. You make me run around in circles explaining things to you that you know is right. You make my head hurt.

What's YOUR definition of winning land in a war?

For one thing it is illegal to "win" land in war.

Another is that nobody won that war.

The green line is specifically not to be a political or territorial border. If Israel had won that land it would be a border.

Poppycock.

2. The Armistice Demarcation Line is not to be construed in any sense as a political or territorial boundary,...

The Avalon Project Egyptian-Israeli General Armistice Agreement February 24 1949

Thanks,as always Tinnie.......steve....Free Palestine

 

[theliq]

In order to win land in a war, you must capture it first. This is common sense

you reckoned the Jews didn't have a WAR pre 1948........you used stealth and manipulation in the UN to gain land.....pure and simple....most of the worlds governments didn't want Jews close to them so they gave you parts of Palestine

".most of the worlds governments didn't want Jews close to them so they gave you parts of Palestine"

link ?

Hi Toastie,trust you are in good spirits.....look all this link business......I often give them but the Crets either don't bother to read them or do but still make excuses to deny facts and truth.......so if my word isn't good enough so be it.......it is pointless giving links to most of the Rabid Zionists because they live by their shocking bullshit Zionist Mantra.........I don't just make things up Toastie,at times I have been incorrect or not understood something but always apologies for any slackness on my part...as I have to you on the odd occasion.......but most of the time I'm very accurate......as I have said to you before....I am not perfect.....BUT VERY CLOSE..LOL..see you around soon methinks.

The weather is glorious today........Check out Mullaloo Beach,Western Australia on Google Earth...where I live........Australia Great One Day...Perfect The Next..just sayin, steve

ps we also have a suburb called Innaloo.......!!!!!!!!! not what you are thinking LOL....These are Aboriginal place names,which we love here (Wanneroo,Mariginup,Coolbellup,Dardenup,Mindarie and so on)

 

[Phoenall]

How is it a smokescreen if he responded directly you your post?

As for no one winning:


Result Israeli victory; Palestinian Arab defeat; Arab League strategic failure;[5]Armistice Agreements

1948 Arab Israeli War - Wikipedia the free encyclopedia

Interesting.

What were the terms of surrender?

A cease fire arrangement and armistice lines, not all wars end with massive reparations you know.

The key point is that Israel claims it won land in the 1948 war.

That is a lie.

LINK ?

You want me to prove a negative?

If you think Israel won land in the 1948 war it is up to you to prove that positive.

In a court of law that is what you need to do. So produce the evidence that substantiates your claim that Israel did not acquire land in 1948/1949. Just as Jordan acquired land in 1948/1949 only to lose it in 1967.

 

[Phoenall]

A cease fire arrangement and armistice lines, not all wars end with massive reparations you know.

The key point is that Israel claims it won land in the 1948 war.

That is a lie.

LINK ?

You want me to prove a negative?

If you think Israel won land in the 1948 war it is up to you to prove that positive.

The problem with you is that's it's already been proven to you, with links, many times. It is YOU that refuses to believe it.
You really are something else Tinmore. When you ask someone to back up their claim with a link and they do so, you STILL act as if you're right and they're wrong. Why do you bother asking for links ???

Yeah, yeah, same old blabber even though nothing has been posted to show that Israel won land in the 1948 war.

If you have such a link, post it.

Did israel win the arab israel war in 1948

 

[Phoenall]

In order to win land in a war, you must capture it first. This is common sense

you reckoned the Jews didn't have a WAR pre 1948........you used stealth and manipulation in the UN to gain land.....pure and simple....most of the worlds governments didn't want Jews close to them so they gave you parts of Palestine

".most of the worlds governments didn't want Jews close to them so they gave you parts of Palestine"

link ?

Hi Toastie,trust you are in good spirits.....look all this link business......I often give them but the Crets either don't bother to read them or do but still make excuses to deny facts and truth.......so if my word isn't good enough so be it.......it is pointless giving links to most of the Rabid Zionists because they live by their shocking bullshit Zionist Mantra.........I don't just make things up Toastie,at times I have been incorrect or not understood something but always apologies for any slackness on my part...as I have to you on the odd occasion.......but most of the time I'm very accurate......as I have said to you before....I am not perfect.....BUT VERY CLOSE..LOL..see you around soon methinks.

The weather is glorious today........Check out Mullaloo Beach,Western Australia on Google Earth...where I live........Australia Great One Day...Perfect The Next..just sayin, steve

ps we also have a suburb called Innaloo.......!!!!!!!!! not what you are thinking LOL....These are Aboriginal place names,which we love here (Wanneroo,Mariginup,Coolbellup,Dardenup,Mindarie and so on)

A pity you don't love the Aborigines as much as you love their language