- Banned
- #741
That's like claiming unless you have been a murder victim you cannot have an informed opinion about murder.
no it's not... it's like stating that, unless you are a brain surgeon, you really can't talk, with any level of understanding, about the nuances of brain surgery. NOBODY knows what it's like to be in the military until they've actually been there.
So if someone spent five years studying brain surgery, was tutored by brain surgeons, and watched many operations they wouldn't be abe to intelligently discuss brain surgery unless they physically did it? There is legitimacy to your empirical claim but it's not nearly as cut dry as being stated. People who have never served can make their contributions to how the military is run. Ask Dick Cheney.
the few exceptions prove the general rule, however. Everyone can have an opinion as to how the military will react if gays are allowed to serve openly, but those individuals who have served, have the most valid basis for their opinions.
I served. My opinion is that the military will be just fine if gays are allowed to serve openly. More importantly, however, I really think that it is the sole decision of the commander in chief and he ought not to worry even a little bit as to how the service members will respond to his decision. The military exists to do the bidding of the civilian command authority, not the other way around. "Ours is not to reason why, ours is but to do our die." Soldier and sailors with less than professional attitudes about their service who somehow forget the relationship between those in uniform and those in suits are free to leave if they do not wish to serve under changed circumstances. I would suggest that they not let the door hit them in the ass on their way out.