I believe the EC should stay, for good reason.
The race for the Presidency is like a World Series. It's not a single match. It's a race of endurance. It should be as grueling as possible. Our President is the leader of the Free World and will be tested every single day on the job in a limitless number of ways.
And we need to know that person has heard EVERY voice in America, not just the same voices in all our urban centers. They need to hear the farmers and the miners and the traders and the poor and the rich and the blue collars and the white collars and every race and creed.
And that is nowhere NEAR the case now or in any of our lifetimes.
The whole completely-bullshit concepts of "red states" and "blue states" ---- concepts which would simply not exist if not for the distortion of the WTA-EC --- means that no candidate will bother with the Massachusettses or the Alabamas, because everybody already knows those are predetermined (<< that
alone makes the entire electoral process a sham). And forget altogether about Alaska and Hawaii, who will never get a visit from
anybody under the gentlemen's agreement.
In practice all the attention goes to the so-called "battleground" states (equally bullshitious concept) to the exclusion of the vast majority of the nation, already taken for granted by the respective camps. My own "battleground" state went to Congress and lied through its teeth dumping all 15 of its electoral votes to one candidate even though
nobody got as much as 50% of the state vote. That's complete bullshit. All states but two have caved to the WTA idiocy (and those two just do a smaller version of the same thing), and many (most?) have actually passed laws
dictating how their electors may vote, which further degrades the legitimacy of the entire exercise.
James Madison could see that already in his own lifetime and wanted to abolish it.
Besides shutting out all those voters from contact and tossing all those millions of votes immediately in the shitcan, this perverse system depresses national voter turnout (because for most voters what's the point); makes us all dependent on polls to determine whether it's worth leaving the house on election day at all; shuts out any possibility of a third party and ensures that the Duopoly continues to perpetuate itself, forever.
How a case can be made for
that is way beyond my pay grade.