Independent of who? The voters? In our system NO ONE is independent of the voters. The only person in the entire Executive Branch who wields power is the President. All the powers in Article II are vested in the President of the United States. Only Trump stood before the Voters. All the FBI and DOJ's powers are derived from the President. We have no Lords or Nobles. No one in America has an inherent right to power. All power is derived from the People, and in the case of the FBI and DOJ, their power is derived from Trump's.
And Trump is accountable, Congress has the power of Impeachment. The DOJ and FBI aren't part of the Legislative Branch, they are part of the Executive Branch.
Of course. And Article II starts with this sentence: The Executive Power shall be vested in the President of the United States. You are asking for a DOJ and FBI that is independent of the President's power and that is simply not allowed in our form of government.
WE must have gone to different schools. I was taught that there are three branches of American Government, each independent of the other that hopefully work together. You give Supreme Power the Trump and expect the other branches to fall into line (which they did til 2018).
I did no such thing. Trump has all of the power of the Executive Branch.
... How come you didn't feel that way about Presidential power before 2016? ...
It's not about how I "feel" this how our Constitution was drafted and ratified.
... you completely negated Legislative and Judicial power as secondary...
Untrue. Reread my post. I quite clearly posted this:
And Trump is accountable, Congress has the power of Impeachment. The DOJ and FBI aren't part of the Legislative Branch, they are part of the Executive Branch.
But their oath is not to the President, nor in the past has their loyalty expected to be.
I never said it was. I said their AUTHORITY was DERIVED from the President. They have no authority INDEPENDENT of the President. You started off by grieving over the "loss" of FBI and DOJ "Independence".
A good exercise is diagramming it. First, in our system ALL sovereignty resides in the People. We rule ourselves. We GRANT some of our authority to handle certain duties that are spelled out in our governing documents. Our Constitution splits our Federal Government into 3 areas of power:
Article 1 invests Legislative Authority into Congress and then describes the process by which the voters select them.
Article II invests Executive Power into ONE PERSON, the President.
Article III describes the Judicial Branch.
Everyone with power in the Federal government operates from within one of these 3 branches. There are no exceptions. The President is accountable to US and stands before us to obtain office and then has one additional opportunity.
Congress has the power to impeach and the power to conduct an impeachment inquiry. The DOJ and the FBI do not. They are subordinate to the President.
I got the impression you think...
You are attributing your mental construct to me.
... Flynn who lobbied the US as a paid illegally undocumented procurer of a foreign entity...
Slander of a 32 year veteran who has served our nation under enemy fire. He was thoroughly examined by the SC counsel and they found no grounds to charge him with anything of the sort.
... the report of findings should be filtered thru the more-loyal-to-the-man-than-the-office AG who thinks a President is above the law and cannot be held accountable?...
More slander. Barr stated that if the President committed clear crimes, like Nixon and Clinton did that would be obstruction of justice, and then warned Mueller against pursuing Obstruction Charges based on an incorrect untested reading of the stature that misapplies post Enron changes in the stature. The major problem being that it would allow prosecutors to charge as "crimes" lawful acts that they disagreed with politically, after the fact, by not just the President,
but anyone in the Administration!
...You admit it is Congress that has the power to impeach...
What I admit, or fail to, has no bearing this is the plain reading of the Constitution and precedent.
... yet you have no problem with the AG holding off presenting the Report to the House...
By LAW the Special Counsel report is released
confidentially to the AG. He is under no duty to release it to anyone. When Ken Starr released his report, he first prepared it for public release by removing all Grand Jury Testimony, sources and methods, classified information, and information on uncharged persons, as is required by Law and Procedures. Mueller did not do this. Barr is doing that now, in consultation with Rosenstein and Mueller and working to get the report out the public as quickly as possible.
...Lies like "spying' for example...
Oh the spying was unfortunately quite real, and the lies and fraud that appear to have been perpetuated on the FISA Court make Watergate look like child's play.
...Like 'total exoneration' for example, even after all the convictions.
Trump has been through a witch hunt and examination like few have ever experienced and not a single charge was brought against him. Few in DC would be able to withstand an examination like that. He may be the cleanest guy in DC.
Now the apple turns, and the Witch Hunters, Comey, McCabe, The Ohrs and the rest of the Obama Administration that was in on this vile misuse of the authority we grant them, in order to witch hunt their political opponents, will be just as carefully and closely examined.
Is this a great country or what!?
Robespierre launched the French Revolution with it's orgy of beheadings, the French Revolution ended when public approval turned against him and he died on the guillotine.