Deconstructing the Protocols of the Learned Elders of Zion

[BackAgain]

I suppose the interview with Harold Rosenthal back in the 70s is also "anti-semitic" even though it was made by a Jewish individual?

The Harold Wallace Rosenthal Interview 1976 The Hidden Tyranny – Crucible Media

cruciblemedia.tv

You need to learn that the protocols of the elders of Zion is horseshit before you bleat so much.

Start with something as easy as chat GPT:

The Protocols of the Elders of Zion is widely recognized as a fraudulent and antisemitic hoax. The evidence proving its fraudulent nature includes:

### 1. Plagiarism of Earlier Works
In 1921, journalist Philip Graves of The Times (London) exposed that large parts of the Protocols were plagiarized from a satirical political work published in 1864 titled Dialogue in Hell Between Machiavelli and Montesquieu by Maurice Joly. That book was a critique of Napoleon III, not Jews.

• Passages were copied almost verbatim.
• The structure and tone were closely mimicked.
• Names were replaced and antisemitic themes inserted.

### 2. Historical Inconsistencies

• The Protocols claim to describe a secret Jewish conspiracy, yet no credible evidence has ever surfaced of such meetings or plans.
• The supposed "minutes" of a secret meeting contain vague and generic language, unlike any actual documented conspiracy or political plan.
• The text first appeared in Russia in 1903, during a period of intense antisemitism, and was used to justify pogroms.

### 3. Intentional Fabrication

• Investigations have shown that the Protocols were likely fabricated by agents of the Russian secret police (the Okhrana) to incite hatred against Jews and distract from political unrest in the Russian Empire.
• Historians such as Norman Cohn (Warrant for Genocide) and Cesare G. De Michelis have studied its origins and confirmed it is a fake.

### 4. Court Rulings and Public Debunking

• In 1935, a Swiss court ruled in the Bern Trial that the Protocols were “forgeries” and “obvious plagiarism.”
• Numerous governments and organizations (including the United Nations, the U.S. State Department, and scholars worldwide) have denounced it as a hoax.

In short, the Protocols are conclusively proven to be a fabricated, plagiarized, and malicious antisemitic text, used historically to spread conspiracy theories and justify persecution.

Also, have you never heard about “self hating Jews?”

 

[PeterPilot]

You need to learn that the protocols of the elders of Zion is horseshit before you bleat so much.

Start with something as easy as chat GPT:



Also, have you never heard about “self hating Jews?”

Maybe you're right, but what I do know for sure is that the Israeli State is notorious for deception and lies. I know I need to learn many things, and I try to do that by reading. What's for sure is that it's downright stupid to believe known liars, and the Israeli State and the US Government it owns are notorious and well known liars.

They still lie about the Liberty incident, they still lie about 911, and they lies famously about events since October 7. They recently lied about the medics they lured to a vehicle and then shot them up killing 15. They are known liars.

Do you make a habit of believing known liars?

 

[BackAgain]

Maybe you're right, but what I do know for sure is that the Israeli State is notorious for deception and lies.

As opposed to all the states who speak nothing but the full truth.

Do you make a habit of believing known liars?

nope. I reject your shit.

 

[PeterPilot]

As opposed to all the states who speak nothing but the full truth.

nope. I reject your shit.

If a person believes the claims of known liars, he ain't too smart.

 

[Stryder50]

Maybe you're right, but what I do know for sure is that the Israeli State is notorious for deception and lies. I know I need to learn many things, and I try to do that by reading. What's for sure is that it's downright stupid to believe known liars, and the Israeli State and the US Government it owns are notorious and well known liars.

They still lie about the Liberty incident, they still lie about 911, and they lies famously about events since October 7. They recently lied about the medics they lured to a vehicle and then shot them up killing 15. They are known liars.

Do you make a habit of believing known liars?

Since you are one, should be clear we don't believe you.
Thanks for your revealing pravda, komrade.

 

[BackAgain]

If a person believes the claims of known liars, he ain't too smart.

And there you are.

 

[PeterPilot]

Since you are one, should be clear we don't believe you.
Thanks for your revealing pravda, komrade.

Oh Stryder, LOL, you're just one of those humans who is averse to bad news, averse to facts that contradict your worldview. Keep on truckin' old buddy, your Zionist masters will treat you well.

 

[Stryder50]

Is that why various religions have banned books they didn't like? Do you think those ideas and precepts should be banned?

I didn't say anything about banning books, that's your rabid imagination at work.

What religions do within their own congregations is their affair/business.

As a libertarian and student of Sun Tzu, and similar, I don't support banning "ideas and precepts" since such need to be studied and countered where necessary.

However I would oppose something like 'Protocols" be presented as truth and indoctrination in schools without any equally strong counter presentations.

Judging from your later post here, I'd wager you the sort who would support the banning of conservative speaks at public paid colleges in the USA.

 

[Stryder50]

Oh Stryder, LOL, you're just one of those humans who is averse to bad news, averse to facts that contradict your worldview. Keep on truckin' old buddy, your Zionist masters will treat you well.

After nearly eight decades I see wisdom still eludes you PP.

I don't relish or enjoy bad news, but notice it is part of the duality of the Cosmos.

I also know how to separate facts from fictions and false propaganda, which it appears you are either not capable of, &/or enjoy spreading of lies, distortions, and disinformation.

I'm sure your AntiFa-communist manipulators appreciate your efforts.

 

[PeterPilot]

I didn't say anything about banning books, that's your rabid imagination at work.

What religions do within their own congregations is their affair/business.

As a libertarian and student of Sun Tzu, and similar, I don't support banning "ideas and precepts" since such need to be studied and countered where necessary.

However I would oppose something like 'Protocols" be presented as truth and indoctrination in schools without any equally strong counter presentations.

Judging from your later post here, I'd wager you the sort who would support the banning of conservative speaks at public paid colleges in the USA.

You probably didn't notice I included a question mark after my question regarding your position on banning books. Certainly you must know what a question mark means?

LOL, under your plan for schools, would you have the "counter presentations" created and given by AIPAC? Or maybe Rabbi Schmuley? Or Bibi?

 

[PeterPilot]

After nearly eight decades I see wisdom still eludes you PP.

I don't relish or enjoy bad news, but notice it is part of the duality of the Cosmos.

I also know how to separate facts from fictions and false propaganda, which it appears you are either not capable of, &/or enjoy spreading of lies, distortions, and disinformation.

I'm sure your AntiFa-communist manipulators appreciate your efforts.

If you really knew how to separate fact from fiction and propaganda, it would seem that the simple rule of "do not believe known liars" would be operative. Alas, I guess it's not, as you seem to place great faith in the words of the pathological liars that lead the Zionist movement.

 

[Stryder50]

If you really knew how to separate fact from fiction and propaganda, it would seem that the simple rule of "do not believe known liars" would be operative. Alas, I guess it's not, as you seem to place great faith in the words of the pathological liars that lead the Zionist movement.

Which is why I don't believe a word of your lies.

 

[PeterPilot]

Which is why I don't believe a word of your lies.

Yes, and you do believe known liars in government and MSM.

 

[Stryder50]

Yes, and you do believe known liars in government and MSM.

You are clueless and have no idea or concept of what I believe it would seem.

Not all in government or MSM are "liars", though it would appear many to most might be. Unlike you I won't broad brush and lump all into the same bag. I can trust and believe some but I get my information through alternate channels.

 

[PeterPilot]

You are clueless and have no idea or concept of what I believe it would seem.

Not all in government or MSM are "liars", though it would appear many to most might be. Unlike you I won't broad brush and lump all into the same bag. I can trust and believe some but I get my information through alternate channels.

Your posts and actions show who you believe.

 

[Stryder50]

Your posts and actions show who you believe.

Well then Komrade, your posts show you are an enemy of the USA and humanity in general.
"Mouth of Sauron" ~ "Servant of the Sith"