Death of a culture

In the 1920s Indian children were removed from their homes and sent to boarding schools where they learned, ate and slept. In some areas the forced assimilation started as far back as 1891 and most ran up to 1935, thankfully enough slipped through the cracks to keep the language and culture alive.
If you don't know what you're talkin' about then silence is golden, you should practice it from time to time.........
If you have ever been to an Indian reservation you might have a clearer picture. If you had been to an Indian reservation in the 20s and 30s you would have an even better idea.

But dumbing down is part-and-parcel of today's America so it's important to keep things simple I suppose.
Uummmmm, let's see what my ancestors on my mom's side have to say about that........

6500473.jpg
I don't give a rat's ass about what the ancestors on your mother's side have to say about it. I put about the same amount of stock in that as I do, say what Big Michael Brown's mother observations on her "gentle" son were.

STOP BEING SO STUPID, OR AT LEAST STOP EXPECTING OTHERS TO BE SO!!!
 
Last edited:
In the 1920s Indian children were removed from their homes and sent to boarding schools where they learned, ate and slept. In some areas the forced assimilation started as far back as 1891 and most ran up to 1935, thankfully enough slipped through the cracks to keep the language and culture alive.
If you don't know what you're talkin' about then silence is golden, you should practice it from time to time.........
If you have ever been to an Indian reservation you might have a clearer picture. If you had been to an Indian reservation in the 20s and 30s you would have an even better idea.

But dumbing down is part-and-parcel of today's America so it's important to keep things simple I suppose.
Uummmmm, let's see what my ancestors on my mom's side have to say about that........

6500473.jpg
I don't give a rat's ass about the ancestors on your mother's side have to say about it. I put about the same amount of stock in that as I do, say what Big Michael Brown's mother observations on her "gentile"son.
STOP BEING SO STUPID, OR AT LEAST STOP EXPECTING OTHERS TO BE SO!!!

You really should be looking in a mirror when you say that. :thup:
 
It's no one's fault but their own
Maybe the population being decimated had something to do with it ?

No that's not it.

The people decided not to keep their traditions alive.
No, that isnt the case.

From the OP.
5. Verdena Parker
Language: Hupa

The Hupa people of northern California, like most Native American tribes, were subjected to a process of forced assimilation and English-only education. Ms. Parker avoided boarding school, being raised by her grandmother to speak Hupa. Nowadays she works with Stanford and Berkeley scholars to document the language, while also revitalizing it through an immersion program for high-schoolers that seems to have met with some degree of enthusiasm.

Forced assimilation would have a lot to do with it.

So those people were prevented from speaking their native language at home?
They were prevented from teaching their children their native language outside of the school system?

No they weren't
In the 1920s Indian children were removed from their homes and sent to boarding schools where they learned, ate and slept. In some areas the forced assimilation started as far back as 1891 and most ran up to 1935, thankfully enough slipped through the cracks to keep the language and culture alive.
If you don't know what you're talkin' about then silence is golden, you should practice it from time to time.........



The language is dying because it's an oral tradition. language that has no written component has never survived the evolution of society
 
Maybe the population being decimated had something to do with it ?

No that's not it.

The people decided not to keep their traditions alive.
No, that isnt the case.

From the OP.
5. Verdena Parker
Language: Hupa

The Hupa people of northern California, like most Native American tribes, were subjected to a process of forced assimilation and English-only education. Ms. Parker avoided boarding school, being raised by her grandmother to speak Hupa. Nowadays she works with Stanford and Berkeley scholars to document the language, while also revitalizing it through an immersion program for high-schoolers that seems to have met with some degree of enthusiasm.

Forced assimilation would have a lot to do with it.

So those people were prevented from speaking their native language at home?
They were prevented from teaching their children their native language outside of the school system?

No they weren't
In the 1920s Indian children were removed from their homes and sent to boarding schools where they learned, ate and slept. In some areas the forced assimilation started as far back as 1891 and most ran up to 1935, thankfully enough slipped through the cracks to keep the language and culture alive.
If you don't know what you're talkin' about then silence is golden, you should practice it from time to time.........



The language is dying because it's an oral tradition. language that has no written component has never survived the evolution of society
And you think that is the only reason?
Oh and see if this fits within your paradigm........

"Welcome to the Ojibwe People's Dictionary
The Ojibwe People's Dictionary is a searchable, talking Ojibwe-English dictionary that features the voices of Ojibwe speakers. It is also a gateway into the Ojibwe collections at the Minnesota Historical Society. Along with detailed Ojibwe language entries and voices, you will find beautiful cultural items, photographs, and excerpts from relevant historical documents. Whenever possible, we provide examples of documents in the Ojibwe language."

The Ojibwe People's Dictionary
 
Maybe the population being decimated had something to do with it ?

No that's not it.

The people decided not to keep their traditions alive.
No, that isnt the case.

From the OP.
5. Verdena Parker
Language: Hupa

The Hupa people of northern California, like most Native American tribes, were subjected to a process of forced assimilation and English-only education. Ms. Parker avoided boarding school, being raised by her grandmother to speak Hupa. Nowadays she works with Stanford and Berkeley scholars to document the language, while also revitalizing it through an immersion program for high-schoolers that seems to have met with some degree of enthusiasm.

Forced assimilation would have a lot to do with it.

So those people were prevented from speaking their native language at home?
They were prevented from teaching their children their native language outside of the school system?

No they weren't
In the 1920s Indian children were removed from their homes and sent to boarding schools where they learned, ate and slept. In some areas the forced assimilation started as far back as 1891 and most ran up to 1935, thankfully enough slipped through the cracks to keep the language and culture alive.
If you don't know what you're talkin' about then silence is golden, you should practice it from time to time.........



The language is dying because it's an oral tradition. language that has no written component has never survived the evolution of society
Partly true, but the vocals of dead languages can survive with imported alphabets and more recently audio recordings.

No one even knows really knows what Ancient Egyptians sounded like even though the had an alphabet of sorts. The pronunciations are based on those of the Coptic language.

On the other hand, we know almost exactly what Ancient Greek and Latin sounded like.
 
No that's not it.

The people decided not to keep their traditions alive.
No, that isnt the case.

From the OP.
5. Verdena Parker
Language: Hupa

The Hupa people of northern California, like most Native American tribes, were subjected to a process of forced assimilation and English-only education. Ms. Parker avoided boarding school, being raised by her grandmother to speak Hupa. Nowadays she works with Stanford and Berkeley scholars to document the language, while also revitalizing it through an immersion program for high-schoolers that seems to have met with some degree of enthusiasm.

Forced assimilation would have a lot to do with it.

So those people were prevented from speaking their native language at home?
They were prevented from teaching their children their native language outside of the school system?

No they weren't
In the 1920s Indian children were removed from their homes and sent to boarding schools where they learned, ate and slept. In some areas the forced assimilation started as far back as 1891 and most ran up to 1935, thankfully enough slipped through the cracks to keep the language and culture alive.
If you don't know what you're talkin' about then silence is golden, you should practice it from time to time.........



The language is dying because it's an oral tradition. language that has no written component has never survived the evolution of society
Partly true, but the vocals of dead languages can survive with imported alphabets and more recently audio recordings.

No one even knows really knows what Ancient Egyptians sounded like even though the had an alphabet of sorts. The pronunciations are based on those of the Coptic language.

On the other hand, we know almost exactly what Ancient Greek and Latin sounded like.
Apache language, alphabet and pronunciation

Sioux languages, alphabets and pronunciation

Mohawk language, alphabet and pronunciation

Navajo Language - Diné Bizaad
 
No, that isnt the case.

From the OP.
5. Verdena Parker
Language: Hupa

The Hupa people of northern California, like most Native American tribes, were subjected to a process of forced assimilation and English-only education. Ms. Parker avoided boarding school, being raised by her grandmother to speak Hupa. Nowadays she works with Stanford and Berkeley scholars to document the language, while also revitalizing it through an immersion program for high-schoolers that seems to have met with some degree of enthusiasm.

Forced assimilation would have a lot to do with it.

So those people were prevented from speaking their native language at home?
They were prevented from teaching their children their native language outside of the school system?

No they weren't
In the 1920s Indian children were removed from their homes and sent to boarding schools where they learned, ate and slept. In some areas the forced assimilation started as far back as 1891 and most ran up to 1935, thankfully enough slipped through the cracks to keep the language and culture alive.
If you don't know what you're talkin' about then silence is golden, you should practice it from time to time.........



The language is dying because it's an oral tradition. language that has no written component has never survived the evolution of society
Partly true, but the vocals of dead languages can survive with imported alphabets and more recently audio recordings.

No one even knows really knows what Ancient Egyptians sounded like even though the had an alphabet of sorts. The pronunciations are based on those of the Coptic language.

On the other hand, we know almost exactly what Ancient Greek and Latin sounded like.
Apache language, alphabet and pronunciation

Sioux languages, alphabets and pronunciation

Mohawk language, alphabet and pronunciation

Navajo Language - Diné Bizaad
You are correct. The vocals have indeed been preserved by an import alphabet. That was my point.

Still, that does not mean you are not a dingbat.
 
So those people were prevented from speaking their native language at home?
They were prevented from teaching their children their native language outside of the school system?

No they weren't
In the 1920s Indian children were removed from their homes and sent to boarding schools where they learned, ate and slept. In some areas the forced assimilation started as far back as 1891 and most ran up to 1935, thankfully enough slipped through the cracks to keep the language and culture alive.
If you don't know what you're talkin' about then silence is golden, you should practice it from time to time.........



The language is dying because it's an oral tradition. language that has no written component has never survived the evolution of society
Partly true, but the vocals of dead languages can survive with imported alphabets and more recently audio recordings.

No one even knows really knows what Ancient Egyptians sounded like even though the had an alphabet of sorts. The pronunciations are based on those of the Coptic language.

On the other hand, we know almost exactly what Ancient Greek and Latin sounded like.
Apache language, alphabet and pronunciation

Sioux languages, alphabets and pronunciation

Mohawk language, alphabet and pronunciation

Navajo Language - Diné Bizaad
You are correct. The vocals have indeed been preserved by an import alphabet.

That does not mean you are not a dingbat.
Coming from you I'll take that as a compliment. :thup:
 
In the 1920s Indian children were removed from their homes and sent to boarding schools where they learned, ate and slept. In some areas the forced assimilation started as far back as 1891 and most ran up to 1935, thankfully enough slipped through the cracks to keep the language and culture alive.
If you don't know what you're talkin' about then silence is golden, you should practice it from time to time.........



The language is dying because it's an oral tradition. language that has no written component has never survived the evolution of society
Partly true, but the vocals of dead languages can survive with imported alphabets and more recently audio recordings.

No one even knows really knows what Ancient Egyptians sounded like even though the had an alphabet of sorts. The pronunciations are based on those of the Coptic language.

On the other hand, we know almost exactly what Ancient Greek and Latin sounded like.
Apache language, alphabet and pronunciation

Sioux languages, alphabets and pronunciation

Mohawk language, alphabet and pronunciation

Navajo Language - Diné Bizaad
You are correct. The vocals have indeed been preserved by an import alphabet.

That does not mean you are not a dingbat.
Coming from you I'll take that as a compliment. :thup:
I suspect, given what you are, you would take pretty much anything as a compliment.
 
The language is dying because it's an oral tradition. language that has no written component has never survived the evolution of society
Partly true, but the vocals of dead languages can survive with imported alphabets and more recently audio recordings.

No one even knows really knows what Ancient Egyptians sounded like even though the had an alphabet of sorts. The pronunciations are based on those of the Coptic language.

On the other hand, we know almost exactly what Ancient Greek and Latin sounded like.
Apache language, alphabet and pronunciation

Sioux languages, alphabets and pronunciation

Mohawk language, alphabet and pronunciation

Navajo Language - Diné Bizaad
You are correct. The vocals have indeed been preserved by an import alphabet.

That does not mean you are not a dingbat.
Coming from you I'll take that as a compliment. :thup:
I suspect, given what you are, you would take pretty much anything as a compliment.
Missed my point...... Not surprised....... :lmao:
 
No that's not it.

The people decided not to keep their traditions alive.
No, that isnt the case.

From the OP.
5. Verdena Parker
Language: Hupa

The Hupa people of northern California, like most Native American tribes, were subjected to a process of forced assimilation and English-only education. Ms. Parker avoided boarding school, being raised by her grandmother to speak Hupa. Nowadays she works with Stanford and Berkeley scholars to document the language, while also revitalizing it through an immersion program for high-schoolers that seems to have met with some degree of enthusiasm.

Forced assimilation would have a lot to do with it.

So those people were prevented from speaking their native language at home?
They were prevented from teaching their children their native language outside of the school system?

No they weren't
In the 1920s Indian children were removed from their homes and sent to boarding schools where they learned, ate and slept. In some areas the forced assimilation started as far back as 1891 and most ran up to 1935, thankfully enough slipped through the cracks to keep the language and culture alive.
If you don't know what you're talkin' about then silence is golden, you should practice it from time to time.........



The language is dying because it's an oral tradition. language that has no written component has never survived the evolution of society
And you think that is the only reason?
Oh and see if this fits within your paradigm........

"Welcome to the Ojibwe People's Dictionary
The Ojibwe People's Dictionary is a searchable, talking Ojibwe-English dictionary that features the voices of Ojibwe speakers. It is also a gateway into the Ojibwe collections at the Minnesota Historical Society. Along with detailed Ojibwe language entries and voices, you will find beautiful cultural items, photographs, and excerpts from relevant historical documents. Whenever possible, we provide examples of documents in the Ojibwe language."

The Ojibwe People's Dictionary

It's certainly a historically relevant reason along with the lack of will among the people to keep their language and traditions alive
 
No, that isnt the case.

From the OP.
5. Verdena Parker
Language: Hupa

The Hupa people of northern California, like most Native American tribes, were subjected to a process of forced assimilation and English-only education. Ms. Parker avoided boarding school, being raised by her grandmother to speak Hupa. Nowadays she works with Stanford and Berkeley scholars to document the language, while also revitalizing it through an immersion program for high-schoolers that seems to have met with some degree of enthusiasm.

Forced assimilation would have a lot to do with it.

So those people were prevented from speaking their native language at home?
They were prevented from teaching their children their native language outside of the school system?

No they weren't
In the 1920s Indian children were removed from their homes and sent to boarding schools where they learned, ate and slept. In some areas the forced assimilation started as far back as 1891 and most ran up to 1935, thankfully enough slipped through the cracks to keep the language and culture alive.
If you don't know what you're talkin' about then silence is golden, you should practice it from time to time.........



The language is dying because it's an oral tradition. language that has no written component has never survived the evolution of society
Partly true, but the vocals of dead languages can survive with imported alphabets and more recently audio recordings.

No one even knows really knows what Ancient Egyptians sounded like even though the had an alphabet of sorts. The pronunciations are based on those of the Coptic language.

On the other hand, we know almost exactly what Ancient Greek and Latin sounded like.
Apache language, alphabet and pronunciation

Sioux languages, alphabets and pronunciation

Mohawk language, alphabet and pronunciation

Navajo Language - Diné Bizaad
Did all these exist prior to Western Colonization or were they attempts to codify the languages later?
 
No, that isnt the case.

From the OP.
5. Verdena Parker
Language: Hupa

The Hupa people of northern California, like most Native American tribes, were subjected to a process of forced assimilation and English-only education. Ms. Parker avoided boarding school, being raised by her grandmother to speak Hupa. Nowadays she works with Stanford and Berkeley scholars to document the language, while also revitalizing it through an immersion program for high-schoolers that seems to have met with some degree of enthusiasm.

Forced assimilation would have a lot to do with it.

So those people were prevented from speaking their native language at home?
They were prevented from teaching their children their native language outside of the school system?

No they weren't
In the 1920s Indian children were removed from their homes and sent to boarding schools where they learned, ate and slept. In some areas the forced assimilation started as far back as 1891 and most ran up to 1935, thankfully enough slipped through the cracks to keep the language and culture alive.
If you don't know what you're talkin' about then silence is golden, you should practice it from time to time.........



The language is dying because it's an oral tradition. language that has no written component has never survived the evolution of society
And you think that is the only reason?
Oh and see if this fits within your paradigm........

"Welcome to the Ojibwe People's Dictionary
The Ojibwe People's Dictionary is a searchable, talking Ojibwe-English dictionary that features the voices of Ojibwe speakers. It is also a gateway into the Ojibwe collections at the Minnesota Historical Society. Along with detailed Ojibwe language entries and voices, you will find beautiful cultural items, photographs, and excerpts from relevant historical documents. Whenever possible, we provide examples of documents in the Ojibwe language."

The Ojibwe People's Dictionary

It's certainly a historically relevant reason along with the lack of will among the people to keep their language and traditions alive
There are many reasons, meathead, being the black and white thinking hack he is assumed the reason I initially addressed with my first response to you was the only reason I was claiming existed. Like with everything culture related there are always many causative factors, some more prevalent than others. Given your claim of laziness we could further explore the huge historical factor of government "stewardship" and it's ramifications for the native peoples up to today.
English is the primary language in this country so of course it's going to be the predominant language taught, that much is obvious and has worked better at assimilating Indians than the old forced methods. You want to live and work in this country? Get a higher education? In most areas of this country one needs a good working knowledge of English.
Things are slowly changing though, look at many of the BIA jobs available, one requirement is the applicant must speak the tribe's language so there is a resurgence.
 
So those people were prevented from speaking their native language at home?
They were prevented from teaching their children their native language outside of the school system?

No they weren't
In the 1920s Indian children were removed from their homes and sent to boarding schools where they learned, ate and slept. In some areas the forced assimilation started as far back as 1891 and most ran up to 1935, thankfully enough slipped through the cracks to keep the language and culture alive.
If you don't know what you're talkin' about then silence is golden, you should practice it from time to time.........



The language is dying because it's an oral tradition. language that has no written component has never survived the evolution of society
Partly true, but the vocals of dead languages can survive with imported alphabets and more recently audio recordings.

No one even knows really knows what Ancient Egyptians sounded like even though the had an alphabet of sorts. The pronunciations are based on those of the Coptic language.

On the other hand, we know almost exactly what Ancient Greek and Latin sounded like.
Apache language, alphabet and pronunciation

Sioux languages, alphabets and pronunciation

Mohawk language, alphabet and pronunciation

Navajo Language - Diné Bizaad
Did all these exist prior to Western Colonization or were they attempts to codify the languages later?
Probably later with some but not all but that's not the point, the point is these languages are no longer based on oral tradition and unlike the ancient Egyptians we have immediate, direct knowledge with how the NAs sounded.
 
Essentially there are only a handful of practical world languages left.

1 - English (thank you Queen Elizabeth 1st)
2 - Spanish (thank you Charles 5th)
3 - Mandarin (thank you Ming Dynasty)
4 - Hindu (thank you Veda's)
5 - Arabic (due to Muhammad -- I'm not going to thank him -- he has caused all kinds of other sh!t as well)
6 - Russian (thank you Katherine The Great)

All the other languages are useless and should be allowed to die, other than perhaps ancient Hebrew and ancient Greek and Latin for Biblical purposes.
7. Ebonics (a curse on a culture but they don't buy it)
 
Essentially there are only a handful of practical world languages left.

1 - English (thank you Queen Elizabeth 1st)
2 - Spanish (thank you Charles 5th)
3 - Mandarin (thank you Ming Dynasty)
4 - Hindu (thank you Veda's)
5 - Arabic (due to Muhammad -- I'm not going to thank him -- he has caused all kinds of other sh!t as well)
6 - Russian (thank you Katherine The Great)

All the other languages are useless and should be allowed to die, other than perhaps ancient Hebrew and ancient Greek and Latin for Biblical purposes.









Holy crap, you're a dope.
 
Poor taint.

The loss of cultural identity and language is the result of uniquely lefty policies.

Right now they are eliminating all rural white culture in the us, by forcing ranchers and farmers out of business, closing the mills, closing the forests, and subjecting the children to lefty propaganda via education directed by the feds...who despise Indians, who hate individuality, and who think an educated citizenry is a dangerous citizenry (which is absolutely correct).
 

Forum List

Back
Top