Zone1 can it be sinful to attend religious ceremonies of other religions?

[Zebra]

as a boy i was told that it would be sinful

i did not believe it then, and i do not believe it now.

what do you think?

 

[Care4all]

No, of course not!

I might have been trained in that matter too by the Church, when young...but not in a forceful, sticking way...I never believed it either.

 

[Zebra]

i was told that i must confess this, so i did

but even as a boy i thought while confessing it, that it cannot possibly be a sin for a Catholic to attend a Protetant church service

 

[Zebra]

No, of course not!

I might have been trained in that matter too by the Church, when young...but not in a forceful, sticking way...I never believed it either.

Good to see .... so we have that in common!

 

[Care4all]

i was told that i must confess this, so i did

but even as a boy i thought while confessing it, that it cannot possibly be a sin for a Catholic to attend a Protetant church service

They were not that forceful in my Church! I did not have to Confess it! It was just an underlying feeling that I came away with...somehow? I'm really up there in years so this was a very long time ago....hard to remember.

 

[fncceo]

can it be sinful to attend religious ceremonies of other religions?​

Depends on the religion ...

 

[Zebra]

They were not that forceful in my Church! I did not have to Confess it! It was just an underlying feeling that I came away with...somehow? I'm really up there in years so this was a very long time ago....hard to remember.

i was not told that by a person.
but i was asked the question in our printed confession manual

and today i think it was a sin to put the question in a manual for children

 

[Deplorable Yankee]

as a boy i was told that it would be sinful

i did not believe it then, and i do not believe it now.

what do you think?

No ..most will welcome you in ....especially if your curious Jews Islam Christian Buddhist Hindus....
If there's gay tranny time you're not in a real Church

 

[Zebra]

as i said, it was because i had been to a Protestant service as a Catholic.

what i wonder ,,,, would a Protestant see it as sinful to attend a Catholic Mass?

 

[Zebra]

Depends on the religion ...

View attachment 1162647

did Duids such sacifices?

 

[ShahdagMountains]

as a boy i was told that it would be sinful

i did not believe it then, and i do not believe it now.

what do you think?

Today is the funeral of the deceased Duchess of Kent in Westminster Cathedral in London, worth noting, with regard to your thread, she converted to Roman Catholicism quite late in life, with the permission and approval of Queen Elizabeth. When one thinks of the wars fought between Protestantism and Catholicism in former times.

Today, in the aforementioned cathedral, a requiem mass will be held over the coffin, where it has been lying in state for the past two days. I presume most members of the Royal Family will attend, including tbe King.

 

[Zebra]

Today is the funeral of the deceased Duchess of Kent in Westminster Cathedral in London, worth noting, with regard to your thread, she converted to Roman Catholicism quite late in life, with the permission and approval of Queen Elizabeth. When one thinks of the wars fought between Protestantism and Catholicism in former times.

Today, in the aforementioned cathedral, a requiem mass will be held over the coffin, where it has been lying in state for the past two days. I presume most members of the Royal Family will attend, including tbe King.

exactly my idea!

i am for tolerance between religions.

not for making it a sin to visit other religion'services but one's own

 

[Zebra]

my example was from decades ago
i hope the Catholic clergy is more tolerant today

 

[ShahdagMountains]

my example was from decades ago
i hope the Catholic clergy is more tolerant today

Look at the representatives of all religions attending British royal weddings

 

[Zebra]

Look at the representatives of all religions attending British royal weddings

exactly!

how stupid to tell a boy this was a sin!

 

[ShahdagMountains]

exactly!

how stupid to tell a boy this was a sin!

A Sikh chorister in the Westminster Abbey Choir.

 

[Zebra]

1 vote for no

why not more?