2aguy
Diamond Member
- Jul 19, 2014
- 112,556
- 52,803
- 2,290
- Thread starter
- #61
/----/ What part of gang-related homicides do you not understand?
For various reasons the total number of gang-related homicides appears to be about 11,500; while the total for the rest of us is about 3,000. Essentially, then; the percentage of gang-related homicides in the United States is about 74 percent – and rising as the number of murders among the general population declines.
And this is where he will cite a bogus stat that most murder is not gang related....but that is a fail because in crime reporting,
Gangs and Violence
Armstrong: Let’s turn to questions of where crime is coming from in our country. How much violent crime takes place in the subset of the population we would typically associate with the gang culture?Kleck: In places like Chicago or Los Angeles, it’s a huge fraction of it. It varies enormously from place to place. It may well be that half or more of the gun homicides in those cities are gang related. But in most places in America, it’s a somewhat more modest fraction.
We don’t have national figures that are of any use. For what it’s worth, in the FBI uniform crime reports data, they do have a category for the circumstance in which the crime was committed.
One possible box that local police can check in filling out the homicide reports for the FBI could indeed be for gang-related. But the problem is that the FBI forms require police to check just one circumstance. So if a guy belongs to a gang, and he was selling drugs, and he has a dispute with his customer over the price, and then they get into an argument and one shoots the other, that could go into any of three or four different categories, only one of which is gang-related.
So those data are useless.
What we’re stuck with are local estimates, and, as I say, it varies enormously from one locality to another. It’s a huge percentage in a couple of cities. Chicago and Los Angeles have really bad street-gang problems. On the other hand, in Peoria it’s probably a relatively small fraction, certainly well under half.
Criminologist Gary Kleck on Guns, Crime, and Their Study - Ari Armstrong
Youtu