Best Metallica Album

[Zhukov]

And Justice for All

It just kicks ass in so many ways.

Here's one way it doesn't kick ass: listen to the bass...what's that? you can't hear it? ah....


If Cliff hadn't died this 'would' have been their best album. Alas.

 

[Shattered]

Justice was their last *good* album. Everything prior to that just kicked ass. Period.

Everything after that isn't even worth mentioning. King Nothing was the only good song they put out after the Justice album.

 

[Nightwish]

I can't really pick a single best album. I'd say it's almost an even split between Master, AJFA, and Metallica (aka "the Black album"). The first two were also pretty good.

Hands down the worst, however, is St. Anger. What a piece of drivel! And they were hyping it big time before it came out, claiming they were "getting back to their metal roots." Riiiiiiiiiight.

 

[Bonnie]

Nightwish...Hands down the worst, however, is St. Anger. What a piece of drivel! And they were hyping it big time before it came out, claiming they were "getting back to their metal roots." Riiiiiiiiiight.

I agree wholeheartedly with that. What a let down!!