If the Bears D had just destroyed Tony Eason and the Pats and were average in every other game, I would agree with you
But that Bear Defense killed everyone. They were downright scary. Intimidating as hell. What they did to the Pats, they did to everyone
Like Huggy said though the topic of the OP here is best SUPERBOWL defense.as far as regular season goes its hard to say which of the two was the better but were talking best superbowl defense though and thats a no brainer since the Bears did not face a formidable offense in that game.
Doesn't mean they had a weaker defense than Seattle
If you ask who had the greatest defense on the field at a Superbowl....I go Chicago and then Pittsburgh
Look at the teams the Bears had to face in the playoffs that year.My LA Rams whom I lost interest in pro football for the last 20 years for moving away from LA till Carrol and Wilson joined the seahawks making the game fun again for me for the first time since then.
Their first playoff game they had that year was against the New York Giants.Look who the quarterback was they faced in that game? Phil Simms.Not a bad quarterback but not someone scary either.True he set a superbowl record for completing most his passes the next season but look who that came against? The Donkeys who hardly had a defense,they rode their way to the superbowl that year solely on the play of John Elway.
He was all the Giants had to worry about in that game.The donkeys got there despite the defense not because of it. Simms was a pocket passer with no scrambing ability so they coud sit back and pin their ears back and rush the passér without worrying about trying to contain him which is why they shut out the giants that day.
Then look who they beat in the NFC championship game the nexyt week that year.My LA RAMS.Look who the quarterback was that year for them.The biggest joke of the league,Dieter Brock.The Rams that year were like the bears were the last time they made it to the superbowl.
Like the bears that season,they got as far as they did not because they had a good quarterback but despite him.Getting that far because of a great defense and one of the best running backs ever in Eric Dickerson carrying the load for them that year.
Soon as they got to the NFC championship game against The Bears that year,their true colors were exposed and Brock was shown that he was the biggest joke of a quarterback in the NFL that year finally having to face a Great football team in The Bears.
The Bears only had a running game to worry about in that game because of Dickerson making the Rams one dimensional since they had no passing game that was a threat. because of that the Bears hade a field day that day licking their chops knowing the rams passing game was about as effective as much as a five year old out there throwing the ball. Like Rex Grossman of the bears,Brock disappeared after that being exposed as the joke he was never to be heard from again.
Now lets take a look at the seahawks and the opponents THEY faced in the playoffs before the superbowl last year. First team they face is the saints who have one of the best quarterbacks in the NFL currently and has been in many pro bowls over the years and has an excellent chance of making it to the hall of fame.They shut him down for most the entire game.
The next game they played was the niners who were in the superbowl the previous year and had to worry about containing a quarterback who carried them to the superbowl the year before and could not pin their ears back to rush the passer since they had to worry about his scrambling ability as well.
Like Wilson,his legs are a big weapon.His legs and scrambliing ability is the only reason the game was as close as it was. The seahawks beat that team.The Bears that year,in all three of those playoff games,they never had to face a scrambling quarterback who took his team to the superbowl the previous year which makes them getting to the superbowl all the more impressive than what the Bears accomplished that year I would say.