Arabs and Jews Negev

[shoshi]

No conflict between the communities .I myself have dined in a Bedouin tent. Only political policies cause anger.

 

[rylah]

No conflict between the communities .I myself have dined in a Bedouin tent. Only political policies cause anger.

So what that You dined in a Bedouin tent?!
Don't You think racket causes anger?

Tribal law acceptable only along compliance to conditions of public safety.
If anything, for now I would be content with closing some of the villages,
until those conditions return according to the residents of the Negev.

That short term, long term there's the need to ban goat herding,
restrict movement of stock within eco-systems, tribal migration,
law as mentioned above - illegal, until practiced to comply
with public safety and rules of local ecology.

 

[shoshi]

Yes the ecology must be considered. I am saying the Bedouin are not our enemies.

 

[rylah]

Yes the ecology must be considered. I am saying the Bedouin are not our enemies.

In any country they move in and or out, they deny all but their tribal law,
among main income sources are racket and trafficking.

If You don't believe me ask the neighboring Arabs
why they don't get along with Bedouins.

 

[rylah]

Yes the ecology must be considered. I am saying the Bedouin are not our enemies.

Yes ecology...not the racket?
Listen, if even the outgoing police maj.
is already alarming of the need for civil guard,
what does a Bedouin dish serve understanding the Negev?

 

[teddyearp]

shoshi
Is this the shoshi I think it is?

 

[surada]

In any country they move in and or out, they deny all but their tribal law,
among main income sources are racket and trafficking.

If You don't believe me ask the neighboring Arabs
why they don't get along with Bedouins.

In Arabia the Bedouin camps are set up in perpetuity along the traditional grazing routes.

 

[rylah]

In Arabia the Bedouin camps are set up in perpetuity along the traditional grazing routes.

Unlike Arabia, Levant has its unique and delicate eco-system,
you don't just graze at will in the wild, certain stock suits
certain landscapes and harmful to others.

While grazing is not the main problem,
Bedouin tribes disregard local law, following only their tribal law,
which would be possible to work with if they weren't constantly at war with each other.

Their main source of income is illegal trafficking,
and usually move around communities
targeted for 'protection' extortion.

If our state doesn't want the responsibility,
the people in the Negev take the matters
into their own hands, and motivate
population in other parts of the
country to join in solidarity.

 

[surada]

Ye

Unlike Arabia, Levant has its unique and delicate eco-system,
you don't just graze at will in the wild, certain stock suits
certain landscapes and harmful to others.

While grazing is not the main problem,
Bedouin tribes disregard local law, following only their tribal law,
which would be possible to work with if they weren't constantly at war with each other.

Their main source of income is illegal trafficking,
and usually stay around communities
targeted for 'protection' extortion.

If the state doesn't respond adequately,
the people in the Negev take matters
into their own hands... and motivate
the population in other parts of the
country to express likely solidarity.

Yeah, getting rid of the bedu has been ongoing in Palestine since the 1940s.

 

[rylah]

Ye
Yeah, getting rid of the bedu has been ongoing in Palestine since the 1940s.

I know, you want to blame everything in the Middle East on Israel,
but this was already a main problem during the Ottoman rule.

And remains a problem for the Arab states in the region.

 

[surada]

O

I know, you want to blame everything in the Middle East on Israel,
but this was already a main problem during the Ottoman rule.

And remains a problem for the Arab states in the region.

Only from the pov of a European refugee. The Zionists think they have the right to do away with their way of life.

 

[rylah]

O
Only from the pov of a European refugee. The Zionists think they have the right to do away with their way of life.

Nah, before any European refugees,
the Zionists have already been dealing
for centuries with the Bedouine invaders.

Of course, we have the right and responsibility to
govern our life and ecosystem, do you think otherwise?