American killed by bow and arrow trying to visit forbidden North Sentinel Island...

[Rocko]

She would undoubtedly be on YOUR side of this debate, so that was a swing and a miss.

No she would be on yours ..you think the US laws apply around the world.


.

Forget about specific laws. It’s embedded in human DNA to understand taking a life in wrong. One way or another, the savages should pay

Then why are thousands of baby's killed a year?

All those wrongs don’t make this action right. It’s natural law that killing is the worst offense one commit.

They are a race of people that want to be left alone.. it's there island and India acknowledge it ..


.

So what? I want to be left alone and don’t want outsiders coming into my country as well. I can’t kill anyone if I don’t get what I want

 

[Wyatt earp]

American killed by bow and arrow-wielding tribe while trying to visit remote Indian island

An American tourist trying to visit a lush, remote island in India has been killed by a tribe completely cut off from the outside world and known to attack outsiders with bows and arrows, police revealed Wednesday.

Indian officials have identified the victim as John Allen Chau, 27. They added that he was illegally ferried by fishermen to North Sentinel Island last week, part of the Andaman and Nicobar Islands, a group of islands in the Bay of Bengal between India and Burma.

“Adventure awaits. So do leeches,” read the final post on his Instagram account, dated Nov. 2. On his Facebook profile, Chau described himself as a “soccer coach, traveller, and writer.” He often posted images of his worldwide exploits online, such as hikes in Washington state and prior trips to India.

Dependera Pathak, director-general of police on India's Andaman and Nicobar Islands, told the Associated Press that Chau arrived in the region on Oct. 16 and stayed in a hotel while he prepared to visit the prohibited island.

He said Chau organized his visit to the island through a friend who hired seven fishermen for $325 to take him there on a boat, which also towed his kayak.

Chau went ashore in his kayak on Nov. 15 and sent the boat with the fishermen out to sea to avoid detection, Pathak said. He interacted with some of the tribespeople, giving them gifts he had prepared such as a football and fish. But the tribespeople became angry and shot an arrow at him which apparently hit a book he was carrying, Pathak said.

The American's kayak became damaged, so he swam to the fishermen's boat, which was waiting at a prearranged location. There he spent the night and wrote out his experiences on pages of paper which he gave to the fishermen, Pathak said.

In one of the notes handed over, according to the New York Times, Chau wrote about Jesus bestowing him with the strength to visit some of the most forbidden places on Earth.

Chau then set off for the island again the following day. Sources who spoke to AFP though said once he set foot on shore, he was “attacked by arrows but he continued walking.

“The fishermen saw the tribals tying a rope around his neck and dragging his body,” one source added.

Following Chau's death, the fishermen left for Port Blair, the capital of the Andaman and Nicobar Islands, where they informed Chau's friend, who notified his family, Pathak said.

He said the family got in touch with Indian police and U.S. consular officials.

"It was a case of misdirected adventure," he added.

The body, according to Reuters, has not yet been recovered as of Wednesday, and those who took him to the island are said to have been arrested.

"The investigation in this matter is on," senior police officer Deepak Yadav said, announcing that the seven fishermen have been taken into custody.

Did this dummy spend even five minutes Googling "North Sentinel Island" before going on his "adventure"? Turns out they don't like visitors.

Actually he had already been there 2 to 3 times before and had made communications with the tribe. On this trip, he had planned to start living there with the tribe... I guess something must have gotten lost in translation.

Do you have a link?


Because I am well read and familiar about this island.


.

 

[Godboy]

Who’s personal property did this doofus missionary invade?

It's there fucking island idiot..the India laws reconizre that


.

Dumbass. I just told you we’re not talking about laws. Let me ask you a question. Do you condone the murder of this missionary? Yes or no

Was he trespassing on an acknowledged island off limits?





.

Can i kill you for stepping into my yard with a clearly visible "do not trespass" sign in it?

You don't have a yard, you don't even have the money to rent an apartment.


.

...and you clearly dont have a good argument. Thanks for playing.

 

[JustAnotherNut]

So how the hell do you know or can you prove they are suffering in any way????? And just what are they suffering from?

You do realize that with an isolated tribe AKA no contact with the outside world...….they would have NO access to germs, viruses that would make them sick? If they did, then the tribe would have been wiped out years ago

These people are practically midgets due to malnutrition. No tribe is ever doing good; certainly not by our standards. In fact, if a man decided to take his family to some remote spot, stop wearing clothes, using no technology (not even fire), never allowing their children access to medicine or doctors, no school, etc, you would want his kids to be taken away and youd be right. That is no life for a human being.

You guys need to stop thinking its so cool to be a fucking cave man. It isnt cool. Those people would be so much better off with real world help, whether they know it or not.

You still don't get it do you? For the last time...…..if they were in such dire straits, the tribe would have died off many years ago. Their primitive lifestyle has been the same for many generations and they are still in existence. Just because they aren't living up to your ideal standards, doesn't mean they are suffering in any way.

And you're wrong about what I think of someone that chooses to leave the high tech world behind in favor of living a more recluse lifestyle. Anyone that does and can make a go of it is applauded...….but there is a big difference between this and not knowing any different like this tribe.

Your judgement and opinion of what the ideal life should be...….is just that, your ideal

Who cares cares about casting judgement on their lifestyle?!

The issue is they committed a murder!


Please think before you post!

Godboy is the one casting judgement with their lifestyle.

He's pissed because they don't have 'all the luxuries of the modern age' at their disposal. Please read the string before you quote!


BTW...…..the guy was trespassing and violating a foreign country's law...…..they were within their rights.

No, ive clearly stated that i dont condone them murdering people. Do you have any arguments against that?

you've also clearly stated, many times that you don't agree with them living a remote & primitive lifestyle as well. You want to save them from themselves, so to speak.

I don't think they committed murder (willful intent), they were protecting their own.

 

[Rocko]

Always do

If I killed an illegal, I would be on trial for murder, correct? One good reason why these savages shouldn’t face consequences of their actions?

You can kill a us citizen on tresspasing on your property in most places.





.

Name on place where im allowed to kill someone, merely for stepping in my yard.

Where they threatening you?


.

You’re continuing to move the goal posts

I didn't make the goal posts, you and doodo head don't have the brain power between you to figure out this island is a unique ecosystem that must be preserved ..



.

Human life needs to be preserved first and foremost

 

[Wyatt earp]

No she would be on yours ..you think the US laws apply around the world.


.

Forget about specific laws. It’s embedded in human DNA to understand taking a life in wrong. One way or another, the savages should pay

Then why are thousands of baby's killed a year?

All those wrongs don’t make this action right. It’s natural law that killing is the worst offense one commit.

They are a race of people that want to be left alone.. it's there island and India acknowledge it ..


.

So what? I want to be left alone and don’t want outsiders coming into my country as well. I can’t kill anyone if I don’t get what I want

Start your own country


.

 

[Wyatt earp]

You can kill a us citizen on tresspasing on your property in most places.





.

Name on place where im allowed to kill someone, merely for stepping in my yard.

Where they threatening you?


.

You’re continuing to move the goal posts

I didn't make the goal posts, you and doodo head don't have the brain power between you to figure out this island is a unique ecosystem that must be preserved ..



.

Human life needs to be preserved first and foremost

Then don't tresspass on this unique ecosystem.

.

 

[Rocko]

Forget about specific laws. It’s embedded in human DNA to understand taking a life in wrong. One way or another, the savages should pay

Then why are thousands of baby's killed a year?

All those wrongs don’t make this action right. It’s natural law that killing is the worst offense one commit.

They are a race of people that want to be left alone.. it's there island and India acknowledge it ..


.

So what? I want to be left alone and don’t want outsiders coming into my country as well. I can’t kill anyone if I don’t get what I want

Start your own country


.

I’ve always been an advocate

 

[Godboy]

These people are practically midgets due to malnutrition. No tribe is ever doing good; certainly not by our standards. In fact, if a man decided to take his family to some remote spot, stop wearing clothes, using no technology (not even fire), never allowing their children access to medicine or doctors, no school, etc, you would want his kids to be taken away and youd be right. That is no life for a human being.

You guys need to stop thinking its so cool to be a fucking cave man. It isnt cool. Those people would be so much better off with real world help, whether they know it or not.

You still don't get it do you? For the last time...…..if they were in such dire straits, the tribe would have died off many years ago. Their primitive lifestyle has been the same for many generations and they are still in existence. Just because they aren't living up to your ideal standards, doesn't mean they are suffering in any way.

And you're wrong about what I think of someone that chooses to leave the high tech world behind in favor of living a more recluse lifestyle. Anyone that does and can make a go of it is applauded...….but there is a big difference between this and not knowing any different like this tribe.

Your judgement and opinion of what the ideal life should be...….is just that, your ideal

Who cares cares about casting judgement on their lifestyle?!

The issue is they committed a murder!


Please think before you post!

Godboy is the one casting judgement with their lifestyle.

He's pissed because they don't have 'all the luxuries of the modern age' at their disposal. Please read the string before you quote!


BTW...…..the guy was trespassing and violating a foreign country's law...…..they were within their rights.

No, ive clearly stated that i dont condone them murdering people. Do you have any arguments against that?

you've also clearly stated, many times that you don't agree with them living a remote & primitive lifestyle as well. You want to save them from themselves, so to speak.

I don't think they committed murder (willful intent), they were protecting their own.

Protecting themselves from what, the attacks against them that NEVER happen? The only violence that takes place there is perpetrated by them.

 

[Godboy]

Forget about specific laws. It’s embedded in human DNA to understand taking a life in wrong. One way or another, the savages should pay

Then why are thousands of baby's killed a year?

All those wrongs don’t make this action right. It’s natural law that killing is the worst offense one commit.

They are a race of people that want to be left alone.. it's there island and India acknowledge it ..


.

So what? I want to be left alone and don’t want outsiders coming into my country as well. I can’t kill anyone if I don’t get what I want

Start your own country


.

Our people did that, now everyone wants to come here, but we dont kill them for it.

 

[Wyatt earp]

Then why are thousands of baby's killed a year?

All those wrongs don’t make this action right. It’s natural law that killing is the worst offense one commit.

They are a race of people that want to be left alone.. it's there island and India acknowledge it ..


.

So what? I want to be left alone and don’t want outsiders coming into my country as well. I can’t kill anyone if I don’t get what I want

Start your own country


.

I’ve always been an advocate

Sounds like a Homer Simpson fan..


Go to the zoo , go to a museum or something...you guys sound retarded or way to uneducated.


.

 

[iceberg]

They have been cool. They've been chilling out on an island for 60,000 years, and only killed a few people.

Their history is far from cool. These are sucky people.

What history? What was the last continent they occupied?

Exactly, what history? What have these savages achieved?

They achieved minding their own business, and only killing a few people who entered their land in the past 200 years. I know they have nothing on us. We have invaded lands, killed millions, and conquered a continent in the same time. But these "savages" have to go.

So “minding their own business” is what defines a great culture?? You’ve been indoctrinated, which is why your perspective is warped. These people are too stupid to not mind their own business. And we done more to enhance and save lives that can even be fathomed.

youve been indoctrinated to think you have a "right" to their island.

 

[iceberg]

You don't have to be a "great culture" to expect to be left alone. They have survived for 60,000 years without us. Leave them the fuck alone if they want left alone.

That hasn’t worked for the rest of the world. They don’t deserve to be any exception.

not your call to make.

 

[Rocko]

All those wrongs don’t make this action right. It’s natural law that killing is the worst offense one commit.

They are a race of people that want to be left alone.. it's there island and India acknowledge it ..


.

So what? I want to be left alone and don’t want outsiders coming into my country as well. I can’t kill anyone if I don’t get what I want

Start your own country


.

I’ve always been an advocate

Sounds like a Homer Simpson fan..


Go to the zoo , go to a museum or something...you guys sound retarded or way to uneducated.


.

I read your post as start with your own country. I thought you were referring to abortion, again. I was stating that I’m a pro life advocate

 

[JustAnotherNut]

Here....we'll try it again...in India they have different laws than we do in the US. This island and the people that inhabit it are under India jurisdiction.


North Sentinel Island - Wikipedia
Wikipedia › wiki › North_Sentinel_Island
North Sentinel Island is one of the Andaman Islands, which includes South Sentinel Island, in the Bay of Bengal. ... In practice, Indian authorities recognise the islanders' desire to be left alone and restrict their role to remote monitoring; they do not prosecute them for killing non-Sentinelese people.

Population rank: -1

Location: Bay of Bengal

Population: 40 (2011); (census estimate, actual population highly uncertain) May be ...

Area: 59.67 km2 (23.04 sq mi)
Missing: un ‎| ‎Must include

 

[Godboy]

Their history is far from cool. These are sucky people.

What history? What was the last continent they occupied?

Exactly, what history? What have these savages achieved?

They achieved minding their own business, and only killing a few people who entered their land in the past 200 years. I know they have nothing on us. We have invaded lands, killed millions, and conquered a continent in the same time. But these "savages" have to go.

So “minding their own business” is what defines a great culture?? You’ve been indoctrinated, which is why your perspective is warped. These people are too stupid to not mind their own business. And we done more to enhance and save lives that can even be fathomed.

youve been indoctrinated to think you have a "right" to their island.

Do you support killing illegals in the US?

 

[iceberg]

What history? What was the last continent they occupied?

Exactly, what history? What have these savages achieved?

They achieved minding their own business, and only killing a few people who entered their land in the past 200 years. I know they have nothing on us. We have invaded lands, killed millions, and conquered a continent in the same time. But these "savages" have to go.

So “minding their own business” is what defines a great culture?? You’ve been indoctrinated, which is why your perspective is warped. These people are too stupid to not mind their own business. And we done more to enhance and save lives that can even be fathomed.

Maybe those people don't give a fuck about what you define as a great culture

Exactly. Those people don’t give a fuck about anything but killing their dinner. Hardly the benchmark for a great culture

theyve been at it 60k years. at 250 we are tearing our own shit up.

 

[Rocko]

Their history is far from cool. These are sucky people.

What history? What was the last continent they occupied?

Exactly, what history? What have these savages achieved?

They achieved minding their own business, and only killing a few people who entered their land in the past 200 years. I know they have nothing on us. We have invaded lands, killed millions, and conquered a continent in the same time. But these "savages" have to go.

So “minding their own business” is what defines a great culture?? You’ve been indoctrinated, which is why your perspective is warped. These people are too stupid to not mind their own business. And we done more to enhance and save lives that can even be fathomed.

youve been indoctrinated to think you have a "right" to their island.

Bullshit. Never did I say that

 

[iceberg]

What history? What was the last continent they occupied?

Exactly, what history? What have these savages achieved?

They achieved minding their own business, and only killing a few people who entered their land in the past 200 years. I know they have nothing on us. We have invaded lands, killed millions, and conquered a continent in the same time. But these "savages" have to go.

So “minding their own business” is what defines a great culture?? You’ve been indoctrinated, which is why your perspective is warped. These people are too stupid to not mind their own business. And we done more to enhance and save lives that can even be fathomed.

youve been indoctrinated to think you have a "right" to their island.

Do you support killing illegals in the US?

one has nothing to do with the other

 

[Wyatt earp]

Then why are thousands of baby's killed a year?

All those wrongs don’t make this action right. It’s natural law that killing is the worst offense one commit.

They are a race of people that want to be left alone.. it's there island and India acknowledge it ..


.

So what? I want to be left alone and don’t want outsiders coming into my country as well. I can’t kill anyone if I don’t get what I want

Start your own country


.

Our people did that, now everyone wants to come here, but we dont kill them for it.

You do know the US has roughly 3,500,000 square miles..

North sentinal island has like 18 square miles






.