Anyone with eyes and common sense could see the Rodney King beating for what it was, black folks have seen plenty of Rodney Kings.
This is going to take a little time. I pray you will indulge me. Before I joined the Army I worked as a Rent a Cop. I signed up for and got the training for the Baton, in those days it was the side handle, before the collapsible ASP they all carry now. The old nightsticks. The course was taught by a Trainer from the LAPD. It was just one day, and eight hour course. We covered the laws that governed the use of the nightstick. We covered the precedents which determined the application of the law, and how to employ it. At the end of it, I got a card mailed to me to show I was licensed to carry a Side Handle Baton in the State of California.
One bit of that training stuck with me. The cop who was teaching it told us that the public would be very upset if we beat on someone with a stick. However, to turn the public to your side, just tell the witnesses the suspect was a Child Molester. Everyone hates them, and even if the guy is never charged with it, we’ll still be viewed as the good guy because of the visceral hatred for Child Molesters. It changes the witness testimony from they were beating him for no reason, to the guard was doing everything he could but the bad guy was just fighting too hard.
I never forgot that. The idea that the police would train a bunch of rent a cops to lie in an effort to manipulate the witnesses. A routine lie. In the many years since that time, I’ve never forgotten those routine lies.
I wrote all that so you could understand the place I am coming from. In the police reports the officers all wrote that they had utilized the Swarm Technique to subdue Rodney King after a brief use of force. Obviously, that wasn’t what they had actually done. However, the Prosecutor didn’t want to take on the routine lies. He didn’t want to expose those routine lies to the public eye. So he approached the case from the other direction. He came at it for the Jury, as a simple case of excessive force. Assault with a deadly weapon, which the Baton was considered to be under California Law.
The entire case fell apart during the cross examination of the Use of Force expert. The Defense got the Expert to agree that a kick or swing by the Suspect would be considered resisting. And they played the video and demanded that the Expert identify the point where Rodney stopped resisting, and where the force became excessive. The case was lost.
Instead, the Prosecutor should have started the other way. With the written reports. Get the training and use of force experts up there to show the videos of training. Where the officers actually swarm the suspect. Three or four jump on him and wrestle him into cuffs. It is what they do in Prisons when they have to drag a guy out of the cell. The team chants which body party they are supposed to focus on. Right arm, Right leg. Etc. Each one grabs one limb and they get the guy into the shackles.
The simple case of excessive force fell apart in that one day. After that, focusing on the lies was useless. It was too late. The cops used routine lies, and it was too late to explain to the jury about these routine lies, which the Prosecutor didn’t want to bring up anyway. Too many of his cases would now be suspect if he had.
The Defense used the predisposition of people to believe it is a problem elsewhere. We see it here all the time. If you live in a city, police corruption, widespread police corruption is a big problem in those podunk towns. The entire department is corrupt. And has been since the formation of the first cops in that town. If you live in those towns. There isn’t a corruption problem here. It’s a city problem. Those corrupt cops in New York, and Chicago, and all of that is just the cops trying to fight back against liberal hurdles.
It’s always someone else’s problem. It’s not our problem. We don’t do that here.
The reason is the ability to deceive ourselves. It’s hard to look at your friends and neighbors, sons and fathers, and know they are using those routine lies to excuse misbehavior. And that is just the first phase of misconduct. The use of the routine lies.
From there it goes downhill. I honestly wish the cops in real life were like the ones in the Rookie, and the other shows. Scrupulously following the laws and policies. With superiors demanding absolute adherence to the laws, and utmost honor. With bad cops being the focus of the fury and disgust of the rest of the department. In real life, the superiors know about the routine lies and allow cops to rewrite their reports to more closely resemble the events on the tape. They get a do-over on the sworn statement.
I could go on and on for hours. But I hope you understand my point now. The Prosecution thought they had a simple and easy case to win. Publicity aside. They never considered the damning question, unless they intended to throw the prosecution. A possibility I don’t rule out but it isn’t my first choice.
There were probably millions of events like the beating of Rodney in that decade. Only one got recorded, and it was part of the catalyst to get cops wearing the body cameras, and using dash cameras later. Now, the Routine lies have evolved, but they’re still in use.