Why Do I Like Guns?

MikeK

Gold Member
Jun 11, 2010
15,930
2,495
290
Brick, New Jersey
While Creationists will reject all I have to say here, if they have a more plausible explanation for why some people have a strong affinity for firearms (other than the over-used small penis Freudianism) I'd be interested in reading it.


At the stage of his evolution, when evolving Man came down from the trees and moved about on the ground, he became easy prey for a variety of well-armed predators whose turf he chose to occupy. Because without any specialized natural weapons, such as large canine teeth, sharp claws, or exceptional strength and agility, he was, as Desmond Morris aptly described him, The Naked Ape. And had he remained so poorly equipped for survival in a violently dangerous world the human species would have occupied no more than a mere moment in a history of which there would be no record.

But this pathetically vulnerable creature had something very special going for him. It was an exceptionally active and versatile brain, a cerebral mutation which enabled him to realize something that altered the universe he'd come to inhabit. He discovered that he could stand erect, pick up a stout fallen tree branch, and swing it hard enough to severely injure or at least repel just about any of the frightening predators which had previously ravaged his kind at will. And he thus graduated from the status of naked ape into that of Man -- the weapon maker. Eventually the most fearsome predator of all.

In the epochs that followed, the evolving brain of this thinking animal produced such progressively lethal devices as stone axes, spears, and flint-napped daggers, weapons which enabled him to easily and effectively defend against any other creature in his world but one. His own kind.

I am an accomplished competitive archer. I don't hunt and all of my equipment is specifically designed or adapted for target shooting. But with a hunting bow I could easily send a razor sharp broadhead hunting arrow into a man-size target at ninety meters. And I often wonder about the naked ape whose brain enabled the leap forward from standing toe-to-toe with another stone ax-wielding homo-sapiens, to that of an application of the applied physics of stored energy and motion made possible by combining a flexible tree branch, a strand of strong hide, and a straightened, sharpened stick. I believe that burst of inventive brilliance to be a development in weapons technology which rivals if not surpasses the historic significance of the the atomic bomb.

For centuries the bow and arrows reigned as the ultimate weapon, epitomized by enabling a small group of vastly outnumbered English archers to defeat the French at the Battle of Agincourt. But using the bow effectively is much easier said than done. The fact is it takes years of long and arduous practice and the development of special muscles to acquire the skill needed to make effective use of the bow as a reasonably accurate long-range weapon.

So the next stage in the evolution of weapons technology was the crossbow, which anyone who is strong enough to cock it can make fairly effective use of at up to a fifty yard range, beyond which the trajectory of the bolt (arrow) begins to drop significantly.

The Chinese are credited with the discovery of gunpowder and creation of the earliest firearm, a crude hand-cannon that propelled rocks for a short distance with little to no accuracy. But that burst of science-based ingenuity gave rise to a relatively rapid progression of increasingly brilliant developments in the brief history of firearms, culminating in the examples of modern "assault" rifles, sniper rifles, machine guns, revolvers and automatic pistols.

The bottom line to all this is the question; why do I like guns? And the answer is without them I am a naked ape.

A disarmed man is like a de-clawed cat.
 
In 21st Century America, a disarmed Monkey can lead a full, productive and highly competitive life, thanks to the pooling of resources in the form of taxes and the hiring of armed security called 'Police'.

:rock: Thank (insert your preferred Deity here) for living when there's air conditioning!
 
In 21st Century America, a disarmed Monkey can lead a full, productive and highly competitive life, thanks to the pooling of resources in the form of taxes and the hiring of armed security called 'Police'.

:rock: Thank (insert your preferred Deity here) for living when there's air conditioning!

He left his claws at the automatic door of the supermarket. No amount of firepower is going make up for that.
 
MikeK, do you shoot moving targets?
No.

With a bow that takes exceptional skill at instinctive "barebow" shooting. I use a sight, which makes shooting at a moving target virtually impossible.

I like shooting guns and bows and throwing knives and rocks. I even like punching stuff but I would last about as long as any other 'wild animal' who has spent his whole life in a cage, even with all the firearms in the world. Mainly because we have killed off all the wild beasts we are so afraid of.
 
I think you'd like this movie.
Other than that, I got nuttin'.

War of the Arrows (2011) - IMDb
I watched the trailer. Thanks.

While the Koreans are by far the world's greatest archers, all of these Robin Hood-type movies combine some technically correct shots with a lot of trick camera work, such as precision shots from horseback at a full gallop. Although the Japanese do practice an organized sport (Yabu Sami) which requires exactly that, but their target is quite a bit larger than shooting another bowstring (as depicted in the movie trailer).
 
In 21st Century America, a disarmed Monkey can lead a full, productive and highly competitive life, thanks to the pooling of resources in the form of taxes and the hiring of armed security called 'Police'.

:rock: Thank (insert your preferred Deity here) for living when there's air conditioning!
Of course you're right, but I maintain belief that some of us are affected by the phenomenon of primal memories, which are recollective vestiges of the most primitive stages of our evolution. And while it might seem fantastic to you at first thought, consider how newborn kittens, born in the loving safety and security of a modern apartment, will manifest stalking behavior within days of their birth.

Something accounts for why some people harbor a strong affinity for firearms while others do not. And I'm talking about ordinary, non-aggressive, law-abiding, socially sophisticated, intelligent, educated, relatively successful people -- not yokels. They just like guns.

Why?
 
MikeK, do you shoot moving targets?
No.

With a bow that takes exceptional skill at instinctive "barebow" shooting. I use a sight, which makes shooting at a moving target virtually impossible.

I like shooting guns and bows and throwing knives and rocks. I even like punching stuff but I would last about as long as any other 'wild animal' who has spent his whole life in a cage, even with all the firearms in the world. Mainly because we have killed off all the wild beasts we are so afraid of.
But think about why you like shooting the guns and throwing the knives and rocks, even punching stuff. What inner urge is it satisfying? What accounts for the mild compulsion that motivates you to do those things?

All of these are things which, if you did them to a person or to a different kind of animal, who was about to harm you, would put an immediate stop to it. You are exerting power. The ability to do damage. Which is not necessarily a bad thing.
 
As someone here said guns are the great equalizer. You feel like you have a fighting chance if confronted physically.
 
No.

With a bow that takes exceptional skill at instinctive "barebow" shooting. I use a sight, which makes shooting at a moving target virtually impossible.

I like shooting guns and bows and throwing knives and rocks. I even like punching stuff but I would last about as long as any other 'wild animal' who has spent his whole life in a cage, even with all the firearms in the world. Mainly because we have killed off all the wild beasts we are so afraid of.
But think about why you like shooting the guns and throwing the knives and rocks, even punching stuff. What inner urge is it satisfying? What accounts for the mild compulsion that motivates you to do those things?

All of these are things which, if you did them to a person or to a different kind of animal, who was about to harm you, would put an immediate stop to it. You are exerting power. The ability to do damage. Which is not necessarily a bad thing.

Native Americans for centuries hunted with bow and arrow. They did not see as it as asserting power. They knew that they needed to eat so they killed but they also realized they were taking something away from nature. It is that desire to exert power and do damage that scars the planet and it scars ourselves.
 
The bottom line to all this is the question; why do I like guns? And the answer is without them I am a naked ape. A disarmed man is like a de-clawed cat.
Here is a bit of commentary on the assertion that a man has a psychological need to possess firearms.
FYI: Ted Nugent was on TV tonight asserting that he carries a concealed Glock at all times.
Not everyone manifests their personal impulses in a positive, inoffensive way.
 
Last edited:
Native Americans for centuries hunted with bow and arrow. They did not see as it as asserting power. They knew that they needed to eat so they killed but they also realized they were taking something away from nature. It is that desire to exert power and do damage that scars the planet and it scars ourselves.
Of course that's true. But desire to do do something is very different from simply being aware of the ability to do it.
 
In 21st Century America, a disarmed Monkey can lead a full, productive and highly competitive life, thanks to the pooling of resources in the form of taxes and the hiring of armed security called 'Police'.

:rock: Thank (insert your preferred Deity here) for living when there's air conditioning!
Of course you're right, but I maintain belief that some of us are affected by the phenomenon of primal memories, which are recollective vestiges of the most primitive stages of our evolution. And while it might seem fantastic to you at first thought, consider how newborn kittens, born in the loving safety and security of a modern apartment, will manifest stalking behavior within days of their birth.

Something accounts for why some people harbor a strong affinity for firearms while others do not. And I'm talking about ordinary, non-aggressive, law-abiding, socially sophisticated, intelligent, educated, relatively successful people -- not yokels. They just like guns.

Why?

All Monkeys like power over other Monkeys. That's why Monkeys dig Lawyers, Guns & Money.

 

Forum List

Back
Top