When will the arab muslims compensate/give aid $$ to their ethnically cleansed jews?

[montelatici]

How are they related? The Palestinians had nothing to do with either one.

The Jews must not be interested in the issue. I don't see them organizing for the right to return like the Palestinians.

You dodged my question. And the Arab Palestinians most certainly bear responsibility for their actions in Palestine and Israel. They were not and are not children who are incapable of acting and can only be acted upon. They may not have had the ability to control the immigration of the Jewish people returning to the Jewish Homeland, but they sure had a choice as to what to do about it. They still do.

And on the contrary, the Jewish people seem to be the ONLY people interested in ensuring the (true) refugees achieve a humanitarian solution to their living conditions. The Arabs don't seem to be doing shit about it.

The actions of the Palestinians have been to resist colonization and when the colonization was complete they continue to resist occupation. What else could they do beyond accepting permanent occupation?

 

[Shusha]

How are they related? The Palestinians had nothing to do with either one.

The Jews must not be interested in the issue. I don't see them organizing for the right to return like the Palestinians.

You dodged my question. And the Arab Palestinians most certainly bear responsibility for their actions in Palestine and Israel. They were not and are not children who are incapable of acting and can only be acted upon. They may not have had the ability to control the immigration of the Jewish people returning to the Jewish Homeland, but they sure had a choice as to what to do about it. They still do.

And on the contrary, the Jewish people seem to be the ONLY people interested in ensuring the (true) refugees achieve a humanitarian solution to their living conditions. The Arabs don't seem to be doing shit about it.

Irrelevant to the issue.

Well, the issue on this thread is compensation for the Jewish people who were ethnically cleansed from the surrounding Arab countries post-1948. Do you agree that they should receive compensation? Yes or no? If no, why not?

 

[montelatici]

How are they related? The Palestinians had nothing to do with either one.

The Jews must not be interested in the issue. I don't see them organizing for the right to return like the Palestinians.

You dodged my question. And the Arab Palestinians most certainly bear responsibility for their actions in Palestine and Israel. They were not and are not children who are incapable of acting and can only be acted upon. They may not have had the ability to control the immigration of the Jewish people returning to the Jewish Homeland, but they sure had a choice as to what to do about it. They still do.

And on the contrary, the Jewish people seem to be the ONLY people interested in ensuring the (true) refugees achieve a humanitarian solution to their living conditions. The Arabs don't seem to be doing shit about it.

Irrelevant to the issue.

Well, the issue on this thread is compensation for the Jewish people who were ethnically cleansed from the surrounding Arab countries post-1948. Do you agree that they should receive compensation? Yes or no? If no, why not?

This thread should be in the Middle East and/or Africa sections. The Palestinians had no power to expel anyone from anywhere, they were themselves expelled from their land, Palestine.

 

[Hollie]

How are they related? The Palestinians had nothing to do with either one.

The Jews must not be interested in the issue. I don't see them organizing for the right to return like the Palestinians.

You dodged my question. And the Arab Palestinians most certainly bear responsibility for their actions in Palestine and Israel. They were not and are not children who are incapable of acting and can only be acted upon. They may not have had the ability to control the immigration of the Jewish people returning to the Jewish Homeland, but they sure had a choice as to what to do about it. They still do.

And on the contrary, the Jewish people seem to be the ONLY people interested in ensuring the (true) refugees achieve a humanitarian solution to their living conditions. The Arabs don't seem to be doing shit about it.

Irrelevant to the issue.

Well, the issue on this thread is compensation for the Jewish people who were ethnically cleansed from the surrounding Arab countries post-1948. Do you agree that they should receive compensation? Yes or no? If no, why not?

This thread should be in the Middle East and/or Africa sections. The Palestinians had no power to expel anyone from anywhere, they were themselves expelled from their land, Palestine.

You are obviously unaware of the Ottoman Turks relinquishing all rights and title to the land area they controlled. Can you guess what land area that was?

 

[louie888]

Craziest thread ever award!

 

[rylah]

Craziest thread ever award!

Why? Let's see You compose at least 3 sentences on You own.

 

[louie888]

Craziest thread ever award!

Why? Let's see You compose at least 3 sentences on You own.

The maps speak for themselves. There is no way that ANYONE WITH TWO BRAIN CELLS THAT STILL FIRE can not see what they represent. If you can't figure them out, then by all means, please, have someone you trust explain it to you..

 

[rylah]

 

[louie888]

Hahaha...

Maps don't lie, people do. And what you posted above is nonsense.

 

[ForeverYoung436]

Hahaha...

Maps don't lie, people do. And what you posted above is nonsense.

Why is it nonsense, Benedict? Provide some proof.

 

[montelatici]

 

[louie888]

Hahaha...

Maps don't lie, people do. And what you posted above is nonsense.

Why is it nonsense, Benedict? Provide some proof.

It clearly shows the land lost by the people who were already living there and the land gained by the immigrants.

 

[rylah]

Hahaha...

Maps don't lie, people do. And what you posted above is nonsense.

Why is it nonsense, Benedict? Provide some proof.

It clearly shows the land lost by the people who were already living there and the land gained by the immigrants.

Jews lived there too You know, they even call it 'Sahara Yahudin'.
When will You apply the same standards to Jews who were expelled from Jerusalem, Hebron, Tiberias, Sefad, Gaza?

 

[Shusha]

It clearly shows the land lost by the people who were already living there and the land gained by the immigrants.

So, by your criteria, sovereignty is a function of "who lives there". Cool. The Jewish people in the "settlements" will be thrilled to hear it. Are wide open spaces where no one lives up for sovereign grabs then? The Jewish people in the "settlements" will be thrilled to hear it.

 

[P F Tinmore]

Hahaha...

Maps don't lie, people do. And what you posted above is nonsense.

Why is it nonsense, Benedict? Provide some proof.

It clearly shows the land lost by the people who were already living there and the land gained by the immigrants.

Jews lived there too You know, they even call it 'Sahara Yahudin'.
When will You apply the same standards to Jews who were expelled from Jerusalem, Hebron, Tiberias, Sefad, Gaza?

Correct. A few percent of Palestinians were Jews.

When the Zionists arrived they destroyed generations of peace.

 

[Shusha]

When the Zionists arrived they destroyed generations of peace.

Translation: Damn dhimmis wouldn't be content with their dhimmitude.

 

[P F Tinmore]

When the Zionists arrived they destroyed generations of peace.

Translation: Damn dhimmis wouldn't be content with their dhimmitude.

There were no dhimmis in Palestine.

 

[rylah]

Hahaha...

Maps don't lie, people do. And what you posted above is nonsense.

Why is it nonsense, Benedict? Provide some proof.

It clearly shows the land lost by the people who were already living there and the land gained by the immigrants.

Jews lived there too You know, they even call it 'Sahara Yahudin'.
When will You apply the same standards to Jews who were expelled from Jerusalem, Hebron, Tiberias, Sefad, Gaza?

Correct. A few percent of Palestinians were Jews.

When the Zionists arrived they destroyed generations of peace.

If by 'Peace' You mean 'Salam'...then surprise surprise it means 'submission'.
If You call a slaughter here, massacre there once in a while- a 'Peace' then what problem do You have with Jews? They just keep the famous local 'Peace' thats so spread out in the Arab Muslim world of brotherly tribal love.

 

[rylah]

When the Zionists arrived they destroyed generations of peace.

Translation: Damn dhimmis wouldn't be content with their dhimmitude.

There were no dhimmis in Palestine.

Really? Weren't the peasants enraged when they were made equal to infidels, by leveling the taxes to all and calling for conscription?

 

[montelatici]

When the Zionists arrived they destroyed generations of peace.

Translation: Damn dhimmis wouldn't be content with their dhimmitude.

There were no dhimmis in Palestine.

Really? Weren't the peasants enraged when they were made equal to infidels, by leveling the taxes to all and calling for conscription?

Really? The Ottomans did not treat non-Muslims any different than Muslims, Jews actually had more rights, they did not have to serve in the military. The millet system was equal for all Ottoman citizens. The Jews were not treated any differently than Christians or Muslims except for their being able to avoid military service if they did not want to serve, and none did. The Jews have always been clever, too clever for their own good actually. The Muslim peasants (and the Christians) may have been upset that Ottoman law forced them to serve in the military but allowed the Jews the privilege not to serve. Could you blame them? What the millet law did state is that the harmed party had the right to have his/her case judged within its millet. So if a Jew or Christian harmed a Muslim, the case would be heard in a Sharia court. Since there were many more Muslims a lot of cases between members of millets were tried under Sharia law. However, if a Jew or Christian was harmed by a Muslim the case would have been tried in the Christian or Jew millet court system.