abu afak
ALLAH SNACKBAR!
- Mar 3, 2006
- 7,434
- 2,632
- 315
There is no "Right of Return" to what is now another country, or even the same country.
Countries can (many but Not most do) INVITE/allow/extend a Privilege to ancestral Ethnics to live in a country but, there is NO Universal "Right of Return."
Especially in cases where borders have changed/it is no longer their country.
Tens of Millions who fled to either side of the Pakistani/India 1947 Partition (and countless ancestors) have NO "right of return" to what is now another country.
2 million original Sudetan Germans and their ancestors have NO "right of return" to the what is now the Czech Republic, because the War/land Germany Lost in 1945.
If and when Palestine becomes a real country, they will probably extend the privilege to their 'ethnics' to do same, but not to Israel.
But who would want to return to 'palestine'?
It's over-crowded and under-employed due it's staggering Birth rate of the last 70 years - supported by the UNRWA. Were it not for that support, a few million probably would have left in a natural immigration.
`
Countries can (many but Not most do) INVITE/allow/extend a Privilege to ancestral Ethnics to live in a country but, there is NO Universal "Right of Return."
Especially in cases where borders have changed/it is no longer their country.
Tens of Millions who fled to either side of the Pakistani/India 1947 Partition (and countless ancestors) have NO "right of return" to what is now another country.
2 million original Sudetan Germans and their ancestors have NO "right of return" to the what is now the Czech Republic, because the War/land Germany Lost in 1945.
If and when Palestine becomes a real country, they will probably extend the privilege to their 'ethnics' to do same, but not to Israel.
But who would want to return to 'palestine'?
It's over-crowded and under-employed due it's staggering Birth rate of the last 70 years - supported by the UNRWA. Were it not for that support, a few million probably would have left in a natural immigration.
`
Last edited: