Discussion in 'Israel and Palestine' started by Coyote, Apr 15, 2018.
It is not the real story
What is incorrect?
Lemme just interject here. THe subject of this thread is "the Palestinian Emirates Solution". Because we want every thread to be different -- if anyone wants to argue the history of the situation --- as has been done in this forum 100 times or more already -- take that discussion to a NEW thread. Or one that is kept in the "sticky section" (at the top of the forum listings) on the history of the conflict.
The standard list of universal rights.
The right to self determination without external interference.
The right to independence and sovereignty.
The right to territorial integrity.
I was fine with it if it has not come and overridden my standard rights
Israel does not have the right to violate the rights of the Palestinians. The plan in the OP would violate all of them.
If they want to take the right of me, I have the right to not give them this option...
Equal rights for the Palestinians will not deny the rights of the Jews.
Yes, it is, It means full control all over 67 lines and more, It means more wars for Israel, It means Gaza 2 just much bigger and closer to the center of Israel, It mean Nitghmear or death and kills in Israel...
While this Palestinians keeps behaving like they do Isreal cannot allow to itself this death bath...
Your hurt feelings are your own to deal with.
The Emirates Solution has a number of positive atttrubutes but ultimately has some likely, unresolvable flaws. One of which is the core solution of establishing many tribes as governing bodies for the various city-states. I think history is pretty clear that tribal rivalries tend to lead to hostilities as we see is the case with Hamas and Fatah. We saw those tribal rivalries emerge after the removal of Saddam Hussein in Iraq. We see that dynamic of Islamic clerics and their tribes seeking power played out across the Islamist Middle East.
Separate names with a comma.