It is not about natural rights; it is about the security of a free State. It says so in the first clause.
One clause:
"A well-regulated militia, being necessary for the security of a free state"

...is wholly dependent on the second clause.

The second clause can stand on its own.

It's not about a militia or a free state. It is SOLELY about Congressional Power. It still does not protect individual natural rights. It only limits Congress. And, as you said, leaves the power to states to protect natural rights.

Admit that or I have nothing more to say to you. Even the most one-sided partisan hack will admit that a proper reading of the 2nd Amendment demonstrates an intent to limit the power of Congress, regardless of the purpose.
No, it isn't. The first clause is the legislative Intent and Purpose. It is in Writing.

The first clause is the end, the second clause is the means.
 
We have a Second Amendment and should have no security problems in our free States.
More proof that you are a PRT (Paid Russian Troll). You copy and paste the exact same phrases over and over and over and over. You're horrible at your job. Vladimir doesn't like people who are horrible at their job. You should be worried. Very worried. You've been exposed. He will not be happy.
 
No, it isn't. The first clause is the legislative Intent and Purpose. It is in Writing. The first clause is the end, the second clause is the means.
Snowflake, there is a reason you are the only one saying this stupid shit and everyone else disagrees with you. The first clause was the prefatory clause (that is a legal fact). It was just an explanation for why the founders were inserting a 2nd Amendment. The second clause is the operative clause. It is the what (or meaning) of the amendment. And it clearly states "the right of the people to keep and bear arms shall not be infringed". This could not be more black and white.

You're Paid Russian Troll schtick as played itself out. It really is time for you to move along now.
 
We have a Second Amendment and should have no security problems in our free States.
More proof that you are a PRT (Paid Russian Troll). You copy and paste the exact same phrases over and over and over and over. You're horrible at your job. Vladimir doesn't like people who are horrible at their job. You should be worried. Very worried. You've been exposed. He will not be happy.
we should be more worried; the right wing has nothing but fallacy instead of better solutions at lower cost.
 
No, it isn't. The first clause is the legislative Intent and Purpose. It is in Writing. The first clause is the end, the second clause is the means.
Snowflake, there is a reason you are the only one saying this stupid shit and everyone else disagrees with you. The first clause was the prefatory clause (that is a legal fact). It was just an explanation for why the founders were inserting a 2nd Amendment. The second clause is the operative clause. It is the what (or meaning) of the amendment. And it clearly states "the right of the people to keep and bear arms shall not be infringed". This could not be more black and white.

You're Paid Russian Troll schtick as played itself out. It really is time for you to move along now.
You are the One who has nothing but ad hominems; which are nothing but fallacy.

To provide for calling forth the Militia to execute the Laws of the Union, suppress Insurrections and repel Invasions;
 
we should be more worried; the right wing has nothing but fallacy instead of better solutions at lower cost.
Oh look! Yet another phrase you repeat over and over and over and over. That is a tell-tale sign of a Paid Russian Troll. Vladimir is not going to be happy with your poor performance.
 
we should be more worried; the right wing has nothing but fallacy instead of better solutions at lower cost.
Oh look! Yet another phrase you repeat over and over and over and over. That is a tell-tale sign of a Paid Russian Troll. Vladimir is not going to be happy with your poor performance.
we should come up with echelon order only strategies; the right wing can be "nugatory and void from inception, all they want".
 
Average number of children killed per year in school shootings: 6.8

Average number of children killed per year by MS-13: 28.5

If Dumbocrats actually cared about children like they claim, they would focus on securing the border and outlawing MS-13 rather than violating our 2nd Amendment.
 
Enforce the common law! We should have no security problems in our free States!

The defense and protection of the state and of the United States is an obligation of all persons within the state. The legislature shall provide for the discharge of this obligation and for the maintenance and regulation of an organized militia.
 
As is always the case, the left has been caught in a web of lies. As is always the case, a firearm wasn’t the problem. As is always the case, it was left-wing policy that lead to the deaths of children.
“It was so many things. I had three students bring knives to my classroom. One was out of the classroom for one day. Another had so many things on his record, he was gone for five days. None were expelled,” Mary Fitzgerald, who taught in the district for 37 years, said. “My principal basically would tell me it was his job to market the school. He was adamant about not looking bad.”
That sums up the left nicely. More concerned about appearance and P.R. than protecting children and effective policy.

Florida newspaper exposes Broward County School system’s incompetence with blockbuster new story

The Blaze is fake news fiction.

Nice try.
 
Enforce the common law! We should have no security problems in our free States!
Because criminals adamantly follow the law? :lmao:
Organize the militia.
They can’t. You left-wing assholes have (unconstitutionally) disarmed the militia!
Why do we pay legislators for?

The defense and protection of the state and of the United States is an obligation of all persons within the state. The legislature shall provide for the discharge of this obligation and for the maintenance and regulation of an organized militia.
 
Another topic where I am motherfucking sick and tired of arguing with you motherfucking commies who want to confiscate our guns.

It's time for war. Talking is over.

.
 
Another topic where I am motherfucking sick and tired of arguing with you motherfucking commies who want to confiscate our guns.

It's time for war. Talking is over.

.
The beautiful thing is, we don’t need to go to war. We own the House, the Senate, the White House, and 33 of the 50 states. We’re in great shape! All they can do is whine. Just ignore them like their parents do.
 
ELEVEN more people gunned down...in a friggin HOUSE OF WORSHIP

Four COPS shot

But the fact that we have too many guns on the streets and too many assault weapons on the street has nothing to do with anything

Thoughts and prayers huh?

That's ALL we get
 
ELEVEN more people gunned down...in a friggin HOUSE OF WORSHIP

Four COPS shot

But the fact that we have too many guns on the streets and too many assault weapons on the street has nothing to do with anything

Thoughts and prayers huh?

That's ALL we get
You can just fuck off with your fake concern for public safety. We already know that is straight bullshit. You just want the guns so your commie overlords can rule.

Read what your hero Mao said about guns.

But, I am pretty much done talking. There will be no more gun laws and only repeal or the MILLIONS of guns doing no harm will start.

We'll leave it at that.

.
 

Forum List

Back
Top