Official USMB Mafia Game #9: Battle for Cityville

[Nutz]

So how would two Scum play it?

Buddy? The stronger bus the weaker? One lead and one follow?

How are the two Scum behaving?

Perhaps we can't know yet because they are quiet on purpose?

Nutz - I usually take revenge but cannot this time. Muhahaha!

Regards from Rosie

Why would you take revenge on me?

I have no reason to.

Regards from Rosie

You will...

Vote Rosie

 

[RosieS]

So how would two Scum play it?

Buddy? The stronger bus the weaker? One lead and one follow?

How are the two Scum behaving?

Perhaps we can't know yet because they are quiet on purpose?

Nutz - I usually take revenge but cannot this time. Muhahaha!

Regards from Rosie

Why would you take revenge on me?

I have no reason to.

Regards from Rosie

You will...

Vote Rosie

Nah. After your first half dozen times of being lynched you get used to it.

Just don't go tossing me under any bus.

I am not getting Scumreads.

Time to post Aye, FA_Q2, Avatar and Wake!

Regards from Rosie

 

[House]

Which reminds me - did the Scum have time before the game? I don't think so- so that means one Scum doesn't know the other until the first Night.

We will get better Scumreads after Night 1 then.

Regards from Rosie

How do you know the scum don't know each other?

Was this pointed out by the mod? Because if it was, I didn't see it.

 

[House]

[18] I've reserved this color for any purposes I might choose. Don't use it or anything similar to it. If you use this color or if I deem you're impersonating the mod you may be warned, force replaced or modkilled.

Oh shit, we're all going to be modkilled!

Oh, and I still haven't found a peep about scum not knowing who the other scum are. It sounds like RosieS knows more than she should. She's smart enough to know that scum have their partner's name in the role pm unless the mod specifically omits it due to mechanics.

[v]RosieS[/v]

 

[House]

Vote: RosieS

 

[Wolfsister77]

Vote: RosieS

L-2 just an FYI but this wagon needs to happen.

 

[RosieS]

Oh puhleeze.

Yeah, show the noob what not to do.

Sheesh.

Can't wait to search out real Scum...just lynch whoever.

I have gone on and on about strategy before - not one of you three gets it.

Can't instruct unlearnables.

Lynch me now and Scum laffs their butts off. Believe it.

Will the Scum vote to L-1 and hammer? We will see.

BTW- not posting in Dead Zone this time. Do Dead without me.

Regards from Rosie

 

[Nutz]

Oh puhleeze.

Yeah, show the noob what not to do.

Sheesh.

Can't wait to search out real Scum...just lynch whoever.

I have gone on and on about strategy before - not one of you three gets it.

Can't instruct unlearnables.

Lynch me now and Scum laffs their butts off. Believe it.

Will the Scum vote to L-1 and hammer? We will see.

BTW- not posting in Dead Zone this time. Do Dead without me.

Regards from Rosie

Ya know, rosie...I sort of believe you...and notice how quick those two are ready to lynch you....hmmm, what are your reads. I still think wolfsister is scum.

 

[Avatar4321]

Just posting to show I am not hiding.

Some Scum hide.

I am not hiding.

Regards from Rosie

This post tells me she is worried about something no one has even accused her of yet.

FoS: Rosie

idk, I don't think I want to lynch there today.

Would scum be so blatant?

Not sure but it seems odd.

There's more than one reason to do things, sometimes.

So... what are your reads, thus far?

Nutz seems pretty relaxed for a first time player, leaning town there. I'm a little suspicious of Aye for being antagonistic and Avi for being so passive and kind of hands off so far.

Wake, Rosie, and FA are null.

You are leaning town so far but that probably means you are scum because I can't read you for shit for some reason even though I think I can, LOL.

I am playing three games at the moment and there has barely been any activity here.

 

[Avatar4321]

Just posting to show I am not hiding.

Some Scum hide.

I am not hiding.

Regards from Rosie

This post tells me she is worried about something no one has even accused her of yet.

FoS: Rosie

idk, I don't think I want to lynch there today.

Would scum be so blatant?

She has been in the past.

 

[AyeCantSeeYou]

Ya know, rosie...I sort of believe you...and notice how quick those two are ready to lynch you....hmmm, what are your reads. I still think wolfsister is scum.

Ask yourself why they could be in a hurry to lynch someone when the game just got started.

 

[Avatar4321]

No need to look back at the playerlist unless you need the names of townies.

You need the names of townies if you're going to provide reads on them, aren't you?

I went back to the OP to get the list of names as well. Am I scum for admitting to that?

Who cares if someone is town...we are looking for scum, right?

Ever hear of process of elimination?

If you read somebody as town, you're taking a stance that you can be held accountable for if you later decide to vote them. You'll need to have good reason to do so.

Scum don't want to read townies as town unless they can do so in a way they can back out of, because it makes it harder to mislynch.them later.

However, they have to toss out town reads because it'd be far too easy to find scum simply by saying, "Hey, you never townread ANYBODY, you must be scum!"

Are there only 3 scum?

We don't know. There are likely 2-3 in an 8 player game.

A good rule of thumb is square root of playerlist = scum.

It's prob two. A 3 scum game with 8 players would put us game ending scenario day two with mislynch.

 

[Nutz]

Ya know, rosie...I sort of believe you...and notice how quick those two are ready to lynch you....hmmm, what are your reads. I still think wolfsister is scum.

Ask yourself why they could be in a hurry to lynch someone when the game just got started.

Yeah...but you are suspect too...you are leading me but have made no reads.

 

[Avatar4321]

LOL-You haven't seen me get defensive in this thread yet. I'm being very patient and restrained compared to my normal town play.

Which is the reason I haven't cleared you yet

 

[Avatar4321]

So how would two Scum play it?

Buddy? The stronger bus the weaker? One lead and one follow?

How are the two Scum behaving?

Perhaps we can't know yet because they are quiet on purpose?

Nutz - I usually take revenge but cannot this time. Muhahaha!

Regards from Rosie

Why would you take revenge on me?

I have no reason to.

Regards from Rosie

You will...

Vote Rosie

Nah. After your first half dozen times of being lynched you get used to it.

Just don't go tossing me under any bus.

I am not getting Scumreads.

Time to post Aye, FA_Q2, Avatar and Wake!

Regards from Rosie

Only scum can toss each other under the bus. That was either a scum slip or you are misusing the term again.

 

[Nutz]

So how would two Scum play it?

Buddy? The stronger bus the weaker? One lead and one follow?

How are the two Scum behaving?

Perhaps we can't know yet because they are quiet on purpose?

Nutz - I usually take revenge but cannot this time. Muhahaha!

Regards from Rosie

Why would you take revenge on me?

I have no reason to.

Regards from Rosie

You will...

Vote Rosie

Nah. After your first half dozen times of being lynched you get used to it.

Just don't go tossing me under any bus.

I am not getting Scumreads.

Time to post Aye, FA_Q2, Avatar and Wake!

Regards from Rosie

Only scum can toss each other under the bus. That was either a scum slip or you are misusing the term again.

Hmmm...and she is implicating me in the process. Clever?

 

[Wolfsister77]

Ya know, rosie...I sort of believe you...and notice how quick those two are ready to lynch you....hmmm, what are your reads. I still think wolfsister is scum.

Ask yourself why they could be in a hurry to lynch someone when the game just got started.

Why don't you ask me? Where did I say I wanted to lynch right now? I said I wanted a wagon on Rosie.

 

[Avatar4321]

I'm tending to think Rosie is town at this point.

FA and wake are not saying a lot. That does give me some concern.

Aye seems off this game. Not sure if it's scum off. But her game is off.

Ill give nutz a town read for day 1. Not going to discourage new players.

House is town and wolf is still unknown to me.

 

[Wolfsister77]

LOL-You haven't seen me get defensive in this thread yet. I'm being very patient and restrained compared to my normal town play.

Which is the reason I haven't cleared you yet

You probably won't for awhile then because I'm not making this game uncomfortable for new players.

 

[Nutz]

LOL-You haven't seen me get defensive in this thread yet. I'm being very patient and restrained compared to my normal town play.

Which is the reason I haven't cleared you yet

You probably won't for awhile then because I'm not making this game uncomfortable for new players.

Don't hold back on my account...that sort of defeats the purpose of entertaining me and yourself.