montelatici
Gold Member
- Feb 5, 2014
- 18,686
- 2,107
- 280
When did palistanians have any land in the first place is the relevant question here, of course.Where is the surrender and treaty to cede land to Israel?
Poppycock!
That question has NO relevance and is simply BS.
The Arabs in the land, were not owners to begin with. That is a valid point. Sucks to be you.
Balderdash.
Per Table 2 on page 566 of "A Survey of Palestine" (prepared by the British Mandate for UN prior to proposing the 1947 partition plan). Arabs owned 94% of the land Jews less than 7%.
View attachment 32324
"AWOL - The Ancient World Online Online British Mandate A Survey of Palestine"
Huh? That's not what I was talking about at all.
You are talking about private citizen ownership of the land. That's not the discussion.
I'm talking about national ownership.
There are Arab Citizens of Israel, in Israel today, that have ownership of land. And Israel offered 100% citizenship, and 100% property rights, to Arabs that stayed with Israel during the war of independence.
The Arabs of Palestine, are not asking for that. They want to wipe Israel off the planet, and establish an Arab state on the land of Israel, and claim that they have that right.... but they don't.
Before Israel:
Briton owned it.
The Ottomans owned it.
The Mamluks owned it.
The Crusaders and Ayyubid Kurds owned it.
The the Arabian Caliphate owned it.
Then the Byzantine, the Romans, the Greeks, the Persians, Babylon, and lastly Assyrian.
The last time that the land of Palestine, was an independent country, run by the people of Palestine......... Was the Israelites in 700 BC.
The only people who ever had an independent country in the land of Israel, was Israel. Ancient Israel, and now modern Israel.
We're not talking about did non-jews own land there. Non-jew citizens have ALWAYS owned land in Israel, even in ancient Israel.
But the people of Gaza and West bank, are claiming they have a NATIONAL right to the land. No.... they don't. They never owned that land as a separate independent country..... EVER. The only nation that has ever been on that land, as an independent country..... has been Israel. Now, and before.
Balderdash.
The only Christian and Muslim Arabs in Israel are those few that the Jews were unable to ethnically cleanse. The Jews ethnically cleansed most of the Christians and Muslims. Jews expelled non-Jews (who owned 94% of the land) and took their land. It was theft, plain and simple.
The Latin Kingdom of Jerusalem was an independent country (kingdom) ruled by descendants of Europeans of the Christian faith. Israel is an independent country ruled by descendants of Europeans of the Jewish faith. Demographics will determine the end game for Israel just as it did for the Latin Kingdom.
Non-Jews do not have property rights in Israel.
"“The real situation in Israel is really very simple: Israel is not an ‘Israeli’ state, or a state of its citizens but it is a ‘Jewish state.’ ” With regard to land, “More than 90% of the inhabited areas of the State of Israel are under the rule of the Jewish National Fund regulations, under which non-Jews cannot rent or buy a house or flat, open a business, in short cannot live. This land is called in Hebrew ‘the land’ saved. The land which belongs to non-Jews is called unsaved not national (meaning Jewish) and by buying or confiscating it from a non-Jew by a Jew, the land is supposed to be ‘saved.’ ”
Israel 8217 s Discriminatory Land Policies Global Research