Florida Judge Rules ObamaCare Unconstitutional

[jillian]

From what I am hearing is that it still will be going to the SC. What was claimed unconstitutional was the insurance mandate. Which in it's own right should kill the whole law but that is yet to be seen.

no. if the court looks at a law, even if it decides that part is unconstitutional (which it isn't unless scalia and his buds continue to be hacks), then only the part that is unconstitutional is struck down.

you'd know that if you weren't just spewing.

 

[RDD_1210]

0bamacare just got smacked...

Perhaps Harry & Nancy should have read it before passing it....

or maybe the rightwingers should know what's in it before opining?

you know, given they keep repeating the same lies over and over.

0bamacare is now officially unconstitutional...

Umm, no it isn't.

 

[The Infidel]

0bamacare just got smacked...

Perhaps Harry & Nancy should have read it before passing it....

or maybe the rightwingers should know what's in it before opining?

you know, given they keep repeating the same lies over and over.

We were'nt allowed to read before those asshats voted for it.

Its a bullshit law and YOU know it.

 

[syrenn]

0bamacare just got smacked...

Perhaps Harry & Nancy should have read it before passing it....

Shush. It had to be rammed through before anyone could read it. Didn't you get the memo?

 

[Dr.House]

Last page....

 

[boedicca]

The judge made an excellent decision. One more small step in the long march to protect individual liberty.

 

[Trajan]

this has been posted already..

 

[Trajan]

heres the whole decision.

Vinson opinion

 

[boedicca]

I like this:

"Because the individual mandate is unconstitutional and not severable, the entire act must be declared void. This has been a difficult decision to reach, and I am aware that it will have indeterminable implications," Vinson wrote.

Judge rules healthcare reform unconstitutional | Reuters

 

[jillian]

0bamacare just got smacked...

Perhaps Harry & Nancy should have read it before passing it....

or maybe the rightwingers should know what's in it before opining?

you know, given they keep repeating the same lies over and over.

What lies?

Apparently the authors of the bill didn't think about the Constitutional ramifications of, well, ramming it down our throats....


0bamacare is now officially unconstitutional...

the law isn't unconstitjutional by any measure given prior precedent.

what lies? really?

that it's 'job killing'
that it's unconstitutional
that there are death panels.

it's a whole bunch of stupid when a bunch of idiots run on a platform of taking health coverage away from kids.

what what the hell... right?

and what i do know is vinson's decision has no basis iaw where it says that the whole bill has to be thrown out.

that's one of the dumbest comments i've ever heard a judge make.... ever.

and why is the bill officially "unconsitutional" because two lower court judges don't like it.

two do.

bfd.

you're smarter than that.

 

[RDD_1210]

Last page....

So what about the two judges who ruled it wasn't unconstitutional? Their decisions make it official too?

 

[Soggy in NOLA]

(which it isn't unless scalia and his buds continue to be hacks)

When did deciding something on the merits, or lack thereof, rather than basing decisions on desired outcomes make someone a hack?

Sorry hun.

 

[Meister]

merged

 

[Dr.House]

or maybe the rightwingers should know what's in it before opining?

you know, given they keep repeating the same lies over and over.

What lies?

Apparently the authors of the bill didn't think about the Constitutional ramifications of, well, ramming it down our throats....


0bamacare is now officially unconstitutional...

the law isn't unconstitjutional by any measure given prior precedent.

That's your opinion, but for now a federal judge says it's unconstitutional...

what lies? really?

that it's 'job killing'
that it's unconstitutional
that there are death panels.

Right now, it is unconstitutional according to a federal judge...

it's a whole bunch of stupid when a bunch of idiots run on a platform of taking health coverage away from kids.

what what the hell... right?

Ahhh... The "Think of the children!" defense... Well played, counsellor...

and what i do know is vinson's decision has no basis iaw where it says that the whole bill has to be thrown out.

that's one of the dumbest comments i've ever heard a judge make.... ever.

and why is the bill officially "unconsitutional" because two lower court judges don't like it.

two do.

bfd.

meh... You agree with your judges and I agree with mine...

Opinions are a dime a dozen, but there is a legal document ruling it unconstitutional - tha's a FACT...

you're smarter than that.

My intellegence has nothing to do with this ruling, thank you very much...

 

[Jarhead]

Health insurance was supposed to be just that. Insurance in CASE you have a catastrophic medical situation arise.

Somewhere along the way it turned into paying for anything that has to do with your health....if I recall it was coined as "preventative" care...which was nothing more than your typical semi annual physical....

So whereas we used to pay out of pocket the few hundred dollars per visit, now it is up to the insurance company to pay it for us...

And you wonder why insurance rates skyrocketed.

 

[boedicca]

I trust Judge Vinson's opinion far more than jillian's.

Just sayin'.

 

[Dr.House]

Last page....

So what about the two judges who ruled it wasn't unconstitutional? Their decisions make it official too?

I guess you an post their decision saying it is if you like, but the one I posted says it is unconstitutional....

 

[theHawk]

A federal judge has ruled that the health care reform bill signed into law by President Barack Obama in March is unconstitutional.

Judge Roger Vinson, a Reagan appointee serving in Pensacola, Florida, ruled that key components of the law are unconstitutional and that the entire law "must be declared void."

MSNBC

We now have two judges who say it's unconstitutional and two judges who say it's not.

Of course it's unconstitutional, just like the whole Obama Presidency.

 

[Trajan]

or maybe the rightwingers should know what's in it before opining?

you know, given they keep repeating the same lies over and over.

What lies?

Apparently the authors of the bill didn't think about the Constitutional ramifications of, well, ramming it down our throats....


0bamacare is now officially unconstitutional...

the law isn't unconstitjutional by any measure given prior precedent.

what lies? really?

that it's 'job killing'
that it's unconstitutional
that there are death panels.

it's a whole bunch of stupid when a bunch of idiots run on a platform of taking health coverage away from kids.

what what the hell... right?

and what i do know is vinson's decision has no basis iaw where it says that the whole bill has to be thrown out.

that's one of the dumbest comments i've ever heard a judge make.... ever.

and why is the bill officially "unconsitutional" because two lower court judges don't like it.

two do.

bfd.

you're smarter than that.

whose taking care from kids? Schip has been around for a while....right?

 

[boedicca]

ObamaCare's damage to the existing system is far more harmful to The Children than is reversing the Obamanation.

What good is free health care with immense waiting lists in an economy with low growth, tons-o-debt, and structurally permanent double digit unemployment?