Norman
Diamond Member
- Sep 24, 2010
- 31,254
- 15,176
- 1,590
I hope social security does die.
Maybe then individuals will not plan their economic future based on an imaginary government safety net.
Safety net? 15 percent of every dollar I made was to be sat aside and I had no choice in the matter. It's not an entitlement program, it's a Ponzi scheme.
Nope... nothing was set aside, that's not how social security works, it's a pay as you go plan. Meaning you pay for the retirement of the old people and the young pay for you. Funded exactly like a pyramid scheme.
That is how Social Security worked for the first 40 years, and soon will be again. Today the Trust Fund contributes about 100 billion which equates to roughly 25 million workers who are not young.
There is no legitimate trust fund, it's just an accounting gimmick. In other words, if the trust fund would be gone tomorrow, nothing would be different. Government can create any amount of debt to itself without any issues, just like anyone can. It cancels out.
That is an opinion that does not have a basis in law. If you visit page 257 of the Trustees Report, they tend to discount this type of thinking because it does not conform to current law. There is nothing in current law that would create any revenue to pay the system's bill. Wake me when the law changes.
If the Trust Fund were gone today, the program would by current law face immediate reductions of benefits. Maybe the laws change, but once we get into maybes, the discussion is little more than candy and nuts. It would be Christmas all year round.
Law does not dictate economic realities any more than it determinates the pull of gravity.
I was not talking about how much the program pays out, I was talking about the funding of the plan as a part of the government. There is nothing there... It's just debt from the government itself... to itself.