It doesn't matter how enthusiastic Newt's voters are. What matters/mattered is how enthusiastic Obama's voters aren't/weren't.
The GOP has plenty of anti-Obama enthusiasm. That would get out the vote no matter who was at the top of the GOP ticket.
The Democrats did not have enthusiasm. A lot of their people would have stayed home. NOW they WILL have enthusiasm. A lot of people on the left who would have stayed home will now get out and vote for Obama because the hatred for Newt is so strong.
I personally think we could have gotten a lot of people from the middle who appreciate Romney's competence. I don't think those people in the middle who would have appreciated Romney's experience are going to switch to Newt.
So what you have for Newt is a solid hunk of the right. But you would have had them anyway because they were voting for "anybody but Obama".
You lose the middle.
And you fire up the left to vote against Newt in a way that Obama couldn't have achieved on his own.
And there is the fundamental difference.
Newt (and I) believe we can win head to head based on the common sense Conservative ideas.
Romney (and you evidently) believe you need to sneak in the backdoor...if you can seem innocuous enough, perhaps no one will notice you.
That was the GOP strategy in choosing Moderate McCain, and the base was so lethargic (myself included) that he needed Palin to fire get Republicans to the polls.
Moderate Romney will induce the same lackluster energy.
Romney just isn't an energizing leader.
He'd make a great vice president...he even kind of reminds me of wooden Al Gore.
You see, the problem with this strategy, is that Newt is NOT a conservative.
This "rah rah" stuff is stirring. But that won't make Newt conservative no matter how hard you want it to.
He was for the federal healthcare mandate from 1993 to 2009. He was only against it because Democrats embraced it in order to try to get Republicans on board.
And that's just one obvious piece of territory that Republicans will have to irrevocably cede to Obama if our nominee is Newt.
We are in deep ****.
And nominating a Massachusetts Moderate like Romney will have the same result as nominating RINO McCain.
Romney isn't comfortable with himself, Republicans aren't comfortable with him.