How do you reconcile a FEDERAL law legalizing abortion with the Tenth Amendment?

[StatesRightsForever]

The 10A in its entirety says:
"The powers not delegated to the United States by the Constitution, nor
prohibited by it to the States, are reserved to the States respectively, or to
the people."

Since abortion is never mentioned or implied anywhere in the constitution, it is a state issue. Any attempt by the feds to legalize it will be struck down by the Supreme Court.

 

[Donald H]

Eggs and sperm should be baptized, to settle the argument.

 

[konradv]

The 10A in its entirety says:
"The powers not delegated to the United States by the Constitution, nor
prohibited by it to the States, are reserved to the States respectively, or to
the people."

Since abortion is never mentioned or implied anywhere in the constitution, it is a state issue. Any attempt by the feds to legalize it will be struck down by the Supreme Court.

All depends on whether you believe in penumbras.

 

[progressive hunter]

The 10A in its entirety says:
"The powers not delegated to the United States by the Constitution, nor
prohibited by it to the States, are reserved to the States respectively, or to
the people."

Since abortion is never mentioned or implied anywhere in the constitution, it is a state issue. Any attempt by the feds to legalize it will be struck down by the Supreme Court.

thats easy,,

protecting human life let alone an innocent child is a national issue,,

if its OK to murder an innocent child in the womb it should be legal to murder anyone,,
do you want to live in that world??

 

[konradv]

thats easy,,

protecting human life let alone an innocent child is a national issue,,

if its OK to murder an innocent child in the womb it should be legal to murder anyone,,
do you want to live in that world??

A matter between a woman and her physician.

 

[progressive hunter]

A matter between a woman and her physician.

nope,, just like if someone wanted to murder you it falls on all of us to either stop them or punish the murderer,,

 

[0311]

The 10A in its entirety says:
"The powers not delegated to the United States by the Constitution, nor
prohibited by it to the States, are reserved to the States respectively, or to
the people."

Since abortion is never mentioned or implied anywhere in the constitution, it is a state issue. Any attempt by the feds to legalize it will be struck down by the Supreme Court.

Who are you to decide medical procedures a Woman can under go? For years you bitched not having the government in Doctors Office and now you do.

 

[Billiejeens]

nope,, just like if someone wanted to murder you it falls on all of us to either stop them or punish the murderer,,

We could look away in that particular case.

 

[john doe 101]

thats easy,,

protecting human life let alone an innocent child is a national issue,,

if its OK to murder an innocent child in the womb it should be legal to murder anyone,,
do you want to live in that world??

Ahh the "logic" of a red hat.

 

[WorldWatcher]

The 10A in its entirety says:
"The powers not delegated to the United States by the Constitution, nor
prohibited by it to the States, are reserved to the States respectively, or to
the people."

Since abortion is never mentioned or implied anywhere in the constitution, it is a state issue. Any attempt by the feds to legalize it will be struck down by the Supreme Court.

#1 And this is a weird thing for me about language. States don't have rights. People have rights. State have powers.

#2 I'm fine with states having their own laws about abortion in their states.

#3 However at the point where states attempt to restrict traveling out of state (either criminally or civilly) then they begin to run afoul of the commerce clause which provides the federal government the ability make laws about interstate commerce.

#4 Finally the federal government does have the ability to set conditions on how federal dollars are spent. If a state doesn't want federal dollars for certain types of programs (MediCare, MedicAid, TRICARE). Then they can forgo federal rules.
.
.
.
If a state want's to ban all abortions, I'm fine with that. If a state wants viability as the marker? I'm fine with that also. If third trimester abortions are limited to life/health of the mother or a fetus that can't survive I'm fine with that.

WW

 

[okfine]

nope,, just like if someone wanted to murder you it falls on all of us to either stop them or punish the murderer,,

Yes. NOYFB

 

[john doe 101]

nope,, just like if someone wanted to murder you it falls on all of us to either stop them or punish the murderer,,

A lump of tissue isn't a human.

 

[progressive hunter]

Ahh the "logic" of a red hat.

yeah aintt it horrible,,

how dare I protect innocent children from sick fucks that want to kill it,,

 

[progressive hunter]

A lump of tissue isn't a human.

youre right,, but a baby in the womb with a DNA of their own is a human being,,

thats a scientific fact,,

 

[john doe 101]

yeah aintt it horrible,,

how dare I protect innocent children from sick fucks that want to kill it,,

Did you just refer to a "human" as an "it"?

 

[john doe 101]

youre right,, but a baby in the womb with a DNA of their own is a human being,,

thats a scientific fact,,

I bet you think all abortions involve pulling a baby out and killing them, don't you incel?

 

[progressive hunter]

Did you just refer to a "human" as an "it"?

beings I dont know the sex of the child I sure cant call it a him or her now can I,,,

 

[progressive hunter]

I bet you think all abortions involve pulling a baby out and killing them, don't you incel?

normally its killed before its removed,,

if a doctor removed the child and then killed it he would go to jail,,

we need to make it illegal regardless of the geography of the child,,

 

[john doe 101]

beings I dont know the sex of the child I sure cant call it a him or her now can I,,,

Yes you can't tell the sex of a clump of cells.

 

[john doe 101]

normally its killed before its removed,,

if a doctor removed the child and then killed it he would go to jail,,

we need to make it illegal regardless of the geography of the child,,

America disagrees with you.