The top 10% make 73% of all wealth. I promise you that they don't pay the kind of taxes into the system for what they make.
Red:
That has nothing to do with who pays how much taxes or whether they who pay taxes pay enough, too much or too little.. Your remark is about income earned, not taxes paid, not tax rates, or anything else taxes.
Blue:
That's an opinion, one to which you are to some extent potentially entitled. Whether the the top 10% should pay more or less in taxes is a subjective matter. That they do indeed pay more as taxes than do all other income segments is a fact.
Now it seems to me that folks who say the wealthy should be made to pay even more in taxes want two basic things:
- To exact a penalty for doing precisely what Americans are supposed to do: analyze the situation, identify opportunities (present and future) for profit making, avail themselves of those opportunities.
- Subsidize the non-wealthy even more than is already the case.
That wouldn't be terribly onerous but for the what those same folks also want in concert with the two bullets above:
- Dramatic reductions in the influence wealthy folks have in the policy making processes.
- Dramatic reductions in the influence wealthy folks have in the electoral process.
So you tell me, if you and several other folks buy a vacation home. If you pay for 50% of the mortgage and your several friends together pay the remaining 50%, would you not demand greater control in how and when the house is used and by whom? Well it's no different with taxes.
So what I'm saying is that folks can either the first pair of bullets or the second pair of bullets, but they can't expect both pairs of bullets, or even the first pair and either one of the second pair.