Who Are The Palestinians? Part 2

[rylah]

So until now the Palestinians chose to be:
1. Arabs 2. Jews 3. Syrians 3. Phoenicians 4. Plishtim-Greeks 5.Jebusites 6. Cnaanites
7. Bedouines

But no distinct culture as a people...somebody is trying to play all he cards at once, while rewriting the Jewish history. How convenient, however their flag shows they're Arabs FOR NOW- therefore invaders (as their name directly suggests).

At least they didn't have to reinvent themselves.

That's exactly what they are doing- 'PALESTINIANS' all the time reinventing their roots.
But the name they chose states it clear- INVADERS.

That's why no one showed the distinct Palestinian culture-
they're Arabs, late invaders of Jewish homeland.

 

[P F Tinmore]

...Palestine is a multi ethnic, multi racial, and multi religious country. It would be difficult to define an exclusive cultural trait.

Close.

More like...

Palestine is multi-ethnic, multi-racial and multi-religious region, under a singular actual control It would be next-to-impossible to define an exclusive cultural trait.

A region is an undefined area.

Palestine is defined by international borders.

You need to get off that Israeli propaganda crap.

 

[Billo_Really]

The historic documents argue with this. What You say is wrong.
I've attached a real scientific study, READ IT.

I read your links and they are just critique's of what someone else wrote. Show me the archeological evidence that the diaspora occurred.

There's a bunch of ancient writings saying it happened, but no archeological evidence proving it happened.

Pony up that and I'll admit I'm wrong.

 

[Billo_Really]

That's exactly what they are doing- 'PALESTINIANS' all the time reinventing their roots.
But the name they chose states it clear- INVADERS.

That's why no one showed the distinct Palestinian culture-
they're Arabs, late invaders of Jewish homeland.

How could they possibly be invaders, when they constituted 90% of the population, before the Zionist migration?

 

[P F Tinmore]

So until now the Palestinians chose to be:
1. Arabs 2. Jews 3. Syrians 3. Phoenicians 4. Plishtim-Greeks 5.Jebusites 6. Cnaanites
7. Bedouines

But no distinct culture as a people...somebody is trying to play all he cards at once, while rewriting the Jewish history. How convenient, however their flag shows they're Arabs FOR NOW- therefore invaders (as their name directly suggests).

At least they didn't have to reinvent themselves.

That's exactly what they are doing- 'PALESTINIANS' all the time reinventing their roots.
But the name they chose states it clear- INVADERS.

That's why no one showed the distinct Palestinian culture-
they're Arabs, late invaders of Jewish homeland.

OK, I get it. The cavemen were the indigenous people. Everyone who came later are invaders.

 

[Kondor3]

...Palestine is a multi ethnic, multi racial, and multi religious country. It would be difficult to define an exclusive cultural trait.

Close.

More like...

Palestine is multi-ethnic, multi-racial and multi-religious region, under a singular actual control It would be next-to-impossible to define an exclusive cultural trait.

A region is an undefined area.

Palestine is defined by international borders.

You need to get off that Israeli propaganda crap.

Palestine had no defined borders, when it existed as a regional reference.

Those hard-borders actually marked the edges of real countries, to which the area known as Palestine was connected.

It was an unincorporated, non-autonomous area surrounded by actual borders, but, inside, it was a political vacuum.

Nature abhors a vacuum.

So, naturally, the Jews rushed in to fill the void.

 

[P F Tinmore]

...Palestine is a multi ethnic, multi racial, and multi religious country. It would be difficult to define an exclusive cultural trait.

Close.

More like...

Palestine is multi-ethnic, multi-racial and multi-religious region, under a singular actual control It would be next-to-impossible to define an exclusive cultural trait.

A region is an undefined area.

Palestine is defined by international borders.

You need to get off that Israeli propaganda crap.

Palestine had no defined borders, when it existed as a regional reference.

It was an unincorporated, non-autonomous area surrounded by actual borders, but, inside, it was a political vacuum.

Nature abhors a vacuum.

So, naturally, the Jews rushed in to fill the void.

 

[Hollie]

That's exactly what they are doing- 'PALESTINIANS' all the time reinventing their roots.
But the name they chose states it clear- INVADERS.

That's why no one showed the distinct Palestinian culture-
they're Arabs, late invaders of Jewish homeland.

How could they possibly be invaders, when they constituted 90% of the population, before the Zionist migration?

Egyptian, Syrian, Lebanese, etc. Arab squatters were not an indigenous population. They were squatters and land grabbers, many of which were Bedouin herders.

 

[Kondor3]

...Palestine is a multi ethnic, multi racial, and multi religious country. It would be difficult to define an exclusive cultural trait.

Close.

More like...

Palestine is multi-ethnic, multi-racial and multi-religious region, under a singular actual control It would be next-to-impossible to define an exclusive cultural trait.

A region is an undefined area.

Palestine is defined by international borders.

You need to get off that Israeli propaganda crap.

Palestine had no defined borders, when it existed as a regional reference.

It was an unincorporated, non-autonomous area surrounded by actual borders, but, inside, it was a political vacuum.

Nature abhors a vacuum.

So, naturally, the Jews rushed in to fill the void.

Link to WHAT, Tinny?

That so-called Palestine had no substantive and authoritative and defining political life of its own, within its vacuum-like unincorporated pseudo-existence?

Asking me to prove a negative?

Nice try.

If, on the other hand, you can prove otherwise - prove a positive - why, then, have at it.

 

[Penelope]

So until now the Palestinians chose to be:
1. Arabs 2. Jews 3. Syrians 3. Phoenicians 4. Plishtim-Greeks 5.Jebusites 6. Cnaanites
7. Bedouines

But no distinct culture as a people...somebody is trying to play all he cards at once, while rewriting the Jewish history. How convenient, however their flag shows they're Arabs FOR NOW- therefore invaders (as their name directly suggests).

At least they didn't have to reinvent themselves.

That's exactly what they are doing- 'PALESTINIANS' all the time reinventing their roots.
But the name they chose states it clear- INVADERS.

That's why no one showed the distinct Palestinian culture-
they're Arabs, late invaders of Jewish homeland.

I mean the Israelites or jews. I believe the Samaritans and some Jews were there when Rome took over. Palestine was not full of Jews, far from it, most stayed in their beloved Babylon , some stayed and worked the land for Rome, some became Christians and some Muslims, but they belong to the old Canaanites and other civilizations. They are all intermarried. The descendants of Hebrews are most likely the Palestinians.

 

[Kondor3]

None of that old shit matters, anymore.

The Jews of Israel hold the pink slip now.

Time for the squatters to pack up and leave.

 

[Billo_Really]

Egyptian, Syrian, Lebanese, etc. Arab squatters were not an indigenous population. They were squatters and land grabbers, many of which were Bedouin herders.

WaffenHollie!

Historical records say you're full of shit.

 

[Billo_Really]

OK, I get it. The cavemen were the indigenous people.

Not according to Jewish Neanderthals.

 

[Hollie]

Egyptian, Syrian, Lebanese, etc. Arab squatters were not an indigenous population. They were squatters and land grabbers, many of which were Bedouin herders.

WaffenHollie!

Historical records say you're full of shit.

No, they don't. Hysterical responses of pointless drivel you posted with your former account as Loinboy won't help you here.

 

[Billo_Really]

No, they don't. Hysterical responses of pointless drivel you posted with your former account as Loinboy won't help you here.

You can't use "drivel", that's docmausers word!

 

[Hollie]

So until now the Palestinians chose to be:
1. Arabs 2. Jews 3. Syrians 3. Phoenicians 4. Plishtim-Greeks 5.Jebusites 6. Cnaanites
7. Bedouines

But no distinct culture as a people...somebody is trying to play all he cards at once, while rewriting the Jewish history. How convenient, however their flag shows they're Arabs FOR NOW- therefore invaders (as their name directly suggests).

At least they didn't have to reinvent themselves.

That's exactly what they are doing- 'PALESTINIANS' all the time reinventing their roots.
But the name they chose states it clear- INVADERS.

That's why no one showed the distinct Palestinian culture-
they're Arabs, late invaders of Jewish homeland.

OK, I get it. The cavemen were the indigenous people. Everyone who came later are invaders.

Your incessant whining about Israel making a nation from lands formerly part of Arab-Islamist conquest is pointless and time wasting.

You Muhammedans were former conquerors and Crusaders who lost any relevancy in terms of the lands you squatted on.

Send an email to ISIS and demand they provide a home for their Arab-Islamist co-religionists. Report back to us on how that goes.

 

[Hollie]

No, they don't. Hysterical responses of pointless drivel you posted with your former account as Loinboy won't help you here.

You can't use "drivel", that's docmausers word!

Why not? You recycle the same drivel you posted under your Loinboy account.

 

[Hollie]

Who are the Pal'istanians?

PA: Rock throwing is legitimate, endorsed by Abbas, who praised 12 year-old rock thrower

PA: Rock throwing is legitimate, endorsed by Abbas, who praised 12 year-old rock thrower - Promoting violence for children | PMW

“President Mahmoud Abbas received yesterday [Sept. 3, 2015] at the presidential headquarters in Ramallah, the family of Martyr Muhammad Al-Atrash, who was killed by the Israeli occupation forces at the Tapuach junction, south of Nablus, and the family of youth Muhammad Al-Tamimi, whom the Israeli occupation forces attacked and tried to arrest in the village of Nabi Saleh, west of Ramallah.




Lovely, lovely folks.

The faux "president" of an invented people with an invented identity who represent the greatest welfare fraud inflicted on the planet takes time from counting his welfare money to encourage stupidity.

Stateworthy!

 

[P F Tinmore]

...Palestine is a multi ethnic, multi racial, and multi religious country. It would be difficult to define an exclusive cultural trait.

Close.

More like...

Palestine is multi-ethnic, multi-racial and multi-religious region, under a singular actual control It would be next-to-impossible to define an exclusive cultural trait.

A region is an undefined area.

Palestine is defined by international borders.

You need to get off that Israeli propaganda crap.

Palestine had no defined borders, when it existed as a regional reference.

Those hard-borders actually marked the edges of real countries, to which the area known as Palestine was connected.

It was an unincorporated, non-autonomous area surrounded by actual borders, but, inside, it was a political vacuum.

Nature abhors a vacuum.

So, naturally, the Jews rushed in to fill the void.

So the surrounding countries had international borders with a black hole?

You are a hoot!

 

[rylah]

So until now the Palestinians chose to be:
1. Arabs 2. Jews 3. Syrians 3. Phoenicians 4. Plishtim-Greeks 5.Jebusites 6. Cnaanites
7. Bedouines

But no distinct culture as a people...somebody is trying to play all he cards at once, while rewriting the Jewish history. How convenient, however their flag shows they're Arabs FOR NOW- therefore invaders (as their name directly suggests).

At least they didn't have to reinvent themselves.

That's exactly what they are doing- 'PALESTINIANS' all the time reinventing their roots.
But the name they chose states it clear- INVADERS.

That's why no one showed the distinct Palestinian culture-
they're Arabs, late invaders of Jewish homeland.

I mean the Israelites or jews. I believe the Samaritans and some Jews were there when Rome took over. Palestine was not full of Jews, far from it, most stayed in their beloved Babylon , some stayed and worked the land for Rome, some became Christians and some Muslims, but they belong to the old Canaanites and other civilizations. They are all intermarried. The descendants of Hebrews are most likely the Palestinians.

You can believe whatever You wish.

Facts stay the same:
-Palestinians use the Arabic revolt flag.
-Their culture is Arabic
-They consider themselves Ishmaelites
-Israelites and Ishmaelites come from the same ancestor- Abraham.

Ismaelites (Arabs) are not Greek or Pleshtim and not more Cnaanites than Israelites.
Even their religion admits Allah gave the land to Israelites.
Ishmael is still wild and traitorous and that's why he and his mother were rejected by Abraham. Hagar mistreated Abraham's wife Sarah, while Ishmael was pointing arrows at Isaac. However they were promised great kingdoms and got them, but that's not enough. They still want to kill their brothers.