It's not fair, Romney pays less tax by percentage than his secretary does.A flat tax would only make the gap between the rich and the poor wider than it is today:We could implement a flat tax and employers could collect and send the taxes to the US government then we could slash the IRS down to a fraction of its size to deal with the smaller part of the population that is self employed or owns businesses.
What's Wrong With the American Tax System
"A flat, single rate of tax on all income has had some adherents, who emphasize its simplicity and argue that it would be fairer to charge all taxpayers the same rate.
"However, to raise the level of revenue required for government operations, it would be necessary to adopt a rate so high that the burden on lower-income taxpayers has been judged economically and politically unrealistic."
A flat tax is the only equitable tax.
and there is more than enough money if you get rid of all the deductions and convoluted tax laws.
in 2019 the total was were 18.6 trillion the revenue from income tax was 1.9 trillion a flat tax of 9.6% would have brought in the same revenue. And there would be savings from reducing the size of the IRS and getting rid of the expense of issuing refunds every year.
So your contention that a flat tax would have to be extremely high is wrong.
and
Clearly making everyone pay a flat tax would be a huge boon to the rich and is regressive.
I see both those thoughts expressed by the same people all the time and yet they are 100 percent contradictory.