Who didn't see
the transcript of Trump's conversation with Mexico's president? Mexico is not going to agree to pay for Trump's wall. Period. Trump can cry all he wants, it's not going to happen. To this day, I don't know what he was thinking when he made the claim that Mexico would pay for the wall.
He dosnt need Mexico to agree. He can divert money we currently send them in the form of finacial aide and drug enforcement to his wall. Thats about 300 million a year. He can also use a trade tariff to finance the wall.
You guys do realize the more you mock him about this the more likely he uses draconian measures on mexico to force them to pay for the wall? If you guys let the issue go it would probably not get built at all. His supporters are indifferent to it as long as the flow is dramatically slowed. The more you guys insist that he is gonna fail the more likely he is to build it. If we end up with a wall it will be thanks to the persistence of the left.
Sent from my SM-T800 using Tapatalk
He can divert money we currently send them in the form of finacial aide and drug enforcement to his wall.
I suppose strictly speaking he can order that employees of his Administration do that, but
whether doing so is legal depends on the way Congress appropriated those funds. (See also:
Appropriations Clause) That's
circumventing Congress' appropriation laws is the essence of what the Reagan Administration did in concocting "arms for hostages," though that unlawful "deal" was considerably more complex than what we're discussing here. Trump can certainly attempt to unlawfully do something similar; the man certainly seems to have no compunction about doing whatever the heck he wants regardless of whether it's lawful or right or turpitudinous.
Congress, for the most part, does not in effect say, "Here's several trillion dollars. Spend it as you see fit." It typically says, "Here's X-dollars for 'this' and X-dollars for that." The POTUS (his Administration) may or may not spend all that Congress appropriates, but in many instances it cannot on "B" spend the money appropriated for "A."
In some instances the
level of the appropriation is high enough that money can be shifted from one place to another, but whether the money we provide to Mexico for "financial aid and drug enforcement" (your terms not mine [1]) are by the POTUS/Cabinet secretaries discretionarily transferable to other uses is something I don't know.
One'd have to review the relevant appropriations to find out. Generally speaking, appropriations are made at a program level, the consequence being that the Administration can spend it on that program or not, but not on something other than that program. Such is the "power of the purse."
Note/Edit:
- AFAIK, the U.S. doesn't give "financial aid" to Mexico, "financial aid" meaning "money for nothing," that is, "straight-up" hand-outs of money/resources/supplies...what some might call "welfare." I don't know what you meant by "financial aid" as you made no effort to be clearer than that, and that term has relevance to me in the context of trade school, graduate school and undergraduate college tuition assistance for students attending institutions in the U.S. The money the the U.S. provides to other nations is called "foreign aid," which includes all monies provided to foreign governments and organizations.
Overwhelmingly, what the U.S. spends in Mexico is money for U.S.-related defense and law enforcement.
According to the U.S. Agency for International Development, roughly a dozen agencies directed roughly $1.6 billion overall in aid to Mexico from 2011 to 2015, the most recent year for which complete data is available.
The State Department, Defense Department and USAID provided the largest amounts, accounting for 95% of the $338 million in aid in 2015. The remainder included much smaller slivers from the departments of Energy, Labor, Interior, and Health and Human Services, and the Peace Corps, among others.
Law enforcement and counter-narcotics initiatives accounted for $260 million, while support for justice and legal reforms added up to roughly $10 million, and military aid accounting for another $10 million. The other aid initiatives in 2015 include:
- $5.7 million for a program to improve the competitiveness of Mexican businesses and to improve “environmental policy management to mitigate climate change and preserve Mexican biodiversity.”
- $4.4 million to help with implementation of programs to reduce emissions from deforestation and forest degradation.
- $ 4 million to support Mexican-led efforts to develop and implement a low-emissions development strategy.
- $4 million for crime and violence prevention.
The Bernstein Research group estimated the cost for building the southern border wall could range from $15 billion to $25 billion. If the United States redirected all of its foreign aid, at the current annual average, it would take nearly 50 years to reach the low end of that range.