Trump administration must seek return of third man who was improperly deported, judge rules

[Seymour Flops]

They haven't even started on the first one.

No, of course not. It would be absurd.

 

[Crepitus]

No, of course not. It would be absurd.

It would be absurd to follow the law?

 

[Seymour Flops]

It would be absurd

It would be absurd to seek the return of Abrego Garcia, a wife-beating, human-trafficking, member of a gang now designated a foreign terrorist organization.

to follow the law?

Two responses:

Judges do not make law, that's a legislative function.

No judge has ordered Trump to "seek the return" of Abrego Garcia. If you're going to claim that judges make laws by speaking, at least quote the "new law" they made correctly.

 

[Crepitus]

It would be absurd to seek the return of Abrego Garcia, a wife-beating, human-trafficking, member of a gang now designated a foreign terrorist organization.

Two responses:

Judges do not make law, that's a legislative function.

No judge has ordered Trump to "seek the return" of Abrego Garcia. If you're going to claim that judges make laws by speaking, at least quote the "new law" they made correctly.

Judges interpret the law and rule on the use of the law.

And legal hairsplitting notwithstanding, yes he has been ordered to return Garcia.

 

[struth]

“The Trump administration must arrange the return of an immigrant who was deported to Mexico without being afforded his legal right to raise fears of torture or persecution, a federal judge ruled Friday night.

The ruling marks the third time that courts have ordered the administration to try to bring back deportees who were found to have been improperly or illegally deported. So far, however, the administration has not cooperated in returning the immigrants to the U.S. so they can receive the due process that, according to the courts, is legally required.

Friday’s ruling from U.S. District Judge Brian Murphy concerns a Guatemala native, identified in court papers only as O.C.G., who claims he had been raped and targeted for being gay during a previous stint in Mexico. His lawyers say he was not given a chance to assert those fears when the Trump administration put him on a bus in February and delivered him across the border. Mexican authorities then deported him to Guatemala, where he has also faced threats of persecution and violence.

U.S. and international law prohibit deporting people to countries where they are likely to be tortured. People in deportation proceedings in the U.S. have the right to formally seek protection from deportation on the basis that they may face torture in the country where they are designated to be sent.”

Trump administration must seek return of third man who was improperly deported, judge rules

The Guatemala native claims he was raped and targeted for being gay during a previous stint in Mexico but never given a chance to assert those fears before he was deported in February.

www.yahoo.com

Trump is a criminal and convicted felon, he has contempt for U.S. and international law and the rule of law.

He’ll of course ignore the ruling and make no effort to return the immigrant unlawfully and illegally removed from the country.

Of course we will ignore it, he was and illegal alien, he was here illegally, we aren’t going to waste a dime to go get him and bring him back

 

[struth]

Judges interpret the law and rule on the use of the law.

And legal hairsplitting notwithstanding, yes he has been ordered to return Garcia.

Wrong, the court order never said nor could it say that trump is ordered to go get an illegal alien and bring him back to our country

 

[Seymour Flops]

Judges interpret the law and rule on the use of the law.

And legal hairsplitting notwithstanding, yes he has been ordered to return Garcia.

It's not hairsplitting. You WANTthe order to be to return Abrego Garcia, but the order is only to facilitate his release in EL Salvador. Then further to give him due process.

If the USSC had wanted to order Trump to return Abrego Garcia, I'm sure they could have spelled r-e-t-u-r-n.

 

[WEATHER53]

Judges just became so over the top with ridiculous edicts that they too are now part of the wishful coloring book crowd and like any child directive-Must Be Ignored

 

[Crepitus]

It's not hairsplitting. You WANTthe order to be to return Abrego Garcia, but the order is only to facilitate his release in EL Salvador. Then further to give him due process.

If the USSC had wanted to order Trump to return Abrego Garcia, I'm sure they could have spelled r-e-t-u-r-n.

Facilitate his return, not just release.

 

[Seymour Flops]

Facilitate his return, not just release.

That's what the media is falsely reporting.

The court struck down the lower court's order to affectuate his return, but left standing the order to facilitate his release.

You should look at original sources, not rely on journalists who often present paraphrases as quotes.