Independent thinker
Diamond Member
- Oct 15, 2015
- 31,480
- 27,214
- 2,788
Hopefully with the re-election of Donald Trump the Progressive movement will be officially dead. The following is a very interesting article from a one time or still Progressive. Some excerpts from it:
I spent pretty much all of the 2010s—my first decade as a writer and pundit—advocating for various progressive causes…I called for expanded immigration, national health insurance, and a bigger welfare state, extolled the benefits of diversity, cheered for a revival of labor unions and stronger antitrust, criticized mass incarceration, dreamed of a phase-out of fracking, and even endorsed reparations for slavery. In the late 2010s, it felt like a long wave of progressive sentiment…had finally reached a critical level of intensity…
A few years later, I’m not so sure. My values haven’t become more conservative—my desire for a more economically egalitarian and socially tolerant society has not diminished an iota…But I have to say that I now doubt the practical effectiveness of some of the policies I embraced in previous years. Others still seem like good ideas, but I’ve been dismayed at their botched implementation where they were tried. And many progressive ideas simply don’t seem like they’ll be able to win majority political support in the near future.
1. Loosening restrictions on illegal immigration was a terrible idea and voters hate it
2. Promoting lax law enforcement and tolerance of social disorder was a terrible idea and voters hate it
3. Insisting that everyone should look at all issues through the lens of identity politics was a terrible idea and voters hate it
4. Telling people fossil fuels are evil and they must stop using them was a terrible idea and voters hate it
I spent pretty much all of the 2010s—my first decade as a writer and pundit—advocating for various progressive causes…I called for expanded immigration, national health insurance, and a bigger welfare state, extolled the benefits of diversity, cheered for a revival of labor unions and stronger antitrust, criticized mass incarceration, dreamed of a phase-out of fracking, and even endorsed reparations for slavery. In the late 2010s, it felt like a long wave of progressive sentiment…had finally reached a critical level of intensity…
A few years later, I’m not so sure. My values haven’t become more conservative—my desire for a more economically egalitarian and socially tolerant society has not diminished an iota…But I have to say that I now doubt the practical effectiveness of some of the policies I embraced in previous years. Others still seem like good ideas, but I’ve been dismayed at their botched implementation where they were tried. And many progressive ideas simply don’t seem like they’ll be able to win majority political support in the near future.
1. Loosening restrictions on illegal immigration was a terrible idea and voters hate it
2. Promoting lax law enforcement and tolerance of social disorder was a terrible idea and voters hate it
3. Insisting that everyone should look at all issues through the lens of identity politics was a terrible idea and voters hate it
4. Telling people fossil fuels are evil and they must stop using them was a terrible idea and voters hate it
