Mariner said:
might work if a community were completely homogenous--but even there, it would represent placing Christianity in a favored position for students, as expressed by a gov't entity (school). That seems wrong to me, on principle (and yes, I am against "under God" on coins, in the Pledge, etc.). Schools are there to teach everyone, and to make it seem that one religious has privileged status is discriminatory--because it doesn't represent the reality of planet earth, which is that Christianity is one of several major religions.
Also, if schools in one area voted for Hindu prayers, and those in another voted for Christian prayers, then you'd soon have people moving from community to community in order to find a place they felt comfortable. That would not serve the interests of diversity, of having kids mix with one another before they form hardened opinions of one anothers' cultures.
Would you really be happy if your Muslim-majority school district voted to pray to Allah before each public high school football game? Why not just avoid all this mess, and keep religion apart from schooling? What's the big need to force it in where it doesn't fit very well?
Mariner.
What I meant was that, people within a community can vote whether to have school prayer at all. Further, if there were prayers, they could be generic or even have a moment of silence at the start of each day with the Pledge.
Strange thing, you mention forcing something where it doesn't fit well at all. For generations, religion was part of school life. To this day, the Congress starts each day with a prayer and has done so ever since the first day of the first session of the First Continental Congress.
To make the claim that God does not belong anywhere in public life is going overboard. This country was founded by people who had a deep belief in God. Most of the founding fathers were ministers.
I believe that most people would be OK with schools that had references to God or a Superior Being, taught an absolute sense of right and wrong and had a moment of silence or even a generic prayer. What has happened though is that the right to decide has been taken out of the hands of people and has been usurped by a bunch of judges. Furthermore, the ACLU has gone wild and is trying to expunge every reference to God. That is what irks people.
People like you that want to go so far as to even expunge references to God from our money are a very tiny minority. Most people believe in God and want God in public life.
Many the situations that you describe may be the norm in larger cities, but in most of the country, it isn't. Where I live, we have people of different backgrounds, but almost entirely, they are Christian. Even in cases where people aren't, they share a definite set of moral codes with the rest of us. Most people believe adultery, theft, murder, envy, and telling lies are wrong. Perhaps that isn't the case with the liberal elite, but it is the case with 99.99% of Americans regardless of their religious affiliation.
As far as diversity is concerned... let me tell you something.... the motto of the United States is "E Pluribus Unum" - out of many one. Diversity focuses on people's differences, not their similarities. It also encourages people from different backgrounds to stay distinct, and not to assimilate to the American way of life.
We should be encouraging people to consider themselves as Americans FIRST and consider their differences as being something secondary. But that idea doesn't find a lot of favor with liberals, because after all being an American is somehow a bad thing.
Assimilation should be encouraged in America, not discouraged. I come from an immigrant family and grew up without diversity; I had to learn English since Italian was all that was spoken in my home. Learning English and American ways is a good thing. Like the old' saying goes.....when in Rome do as the Romans do.
One only has to go to Europe and see how well diversity works. There, a large Moslem population that remains distinct in its language and culture is a growing menace to the stability of Europe. An example is the murder of Theo Van Gogh in Holland on November 3rd by Moslem thugs who objected to a film he produced about Moslem misogyny. The terrorist attack in Spain was pulled off by a bunch of Moslems who thought of themselves as Moslems first and Spanish as a distinct second (if at all).
We should be teaching kids the meaning of the word "respect" instead of stuffing their heads with diversity. Sure, we should respect all people, regardless of whether they are different or the same, but that isn't diversity it's just plain old' respect. We should also teach them the Golden Rule (which is not only Christian, but is found in practically all religions), that is treat others as you would like to be treated.